Log has written
SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 28, 2009

The Sri Ram Sene, or Lord Ram’s army, whose self-appointed guardians recently dragged young men and women out of a pub in Mangalore and thrashed them for drinking in public, may be disappointed at what the scriptures say.

Contrary to what the Sene believes, Hindu scriptures are full of references of gods, goddesses, kings and queens enjoying their drink.

Ramayana has it that Ram offered Maireya, a favourite wine of the royalty, to his bride Sita. And later, when on their exile, while crossing the Ganga, Sita vowed that if they survived the 14-year ordeal and returned unharmed to Ayodhya, she’d pour a thousand jugs of wine into the river as thanksgiving. When the couple did return, says Valmiki, author of the epic, the city celebrated with binge drinking and happy slogans. A delirious Ayodhya, writes Valmiki, reeked of joy and wine for days.

True, the Rig Veda frowns somewhat on alcoholic drinks and says they may cloud one’s judgement and lead minds astray. But a little later, the sutras (treatises on the Vedas) say that people may swill alcoholic drinks on happy occasions such as the arrival of an honoured guest, entering a newly built house or the arrival of a bride into the family. The sutras also lay down a caste-based list of who shall drink what. They forbid the warrior castes from drinking grain-based liquor, but permit them to drink wine brewed from fruits and flowers.

Traders and sailors and non-caste folk could drink what they liked. Later, Vedic literature mentions several popular drinks such as Kilala (a sweet fermented alcoholic drink), and Masara (filtered rice gruel liquor much like the Handiya still drunk by the tribals in central India) and Madira (a honey-based drink).

Also Read Mrinal Pande’s earlier columns

Ramayana refers to four types of liquors, Kautilya’s Arthshastra (fourth century BC) mentions a dozen and Charaka, the medicine man, refers to 84 kinds of alcoholic drinks. Kautilya mentions that in his time, there were liquor vends in most villages and janpads (districts).

Rice, barley, honey, sugar cane products, sap of coconut and palmyra trees and numerous sweet fruits (ber, grapes, mangoes and dates) and flowers (Mahua and Kadamba) were used to create intoxicating brews. Dhataki flowers were used to tinge extracts with eye-catching red colour.

Not content with the home brewed, by the beginning of first century AD, our ancestors were also importing at least two kinds of grape-based wines from Afghanistan (Gandhar). The chief minister of Karnataka, so vociferous against the pub culture in his state, would do well to know that the southern states took the lead in importing and exporting alcoholic drinks as trade with Rome grew. Ports in southern India were importing large quantities of Roman wines delivered in containers called amphorae, when their northern brethren were still making do with crude brews extracted from grains. Toddy or taadi, distilled from palmyra and coconut palms, remained the aam admi’s favourite drink down south. Arrack, a distilled version of taadi, was especially beloved of sailors who frequented the coastal regions. Kuttanad (in Kerala) was voted the producer of the best kind. Another favourite was thoppi extracted from fermented rice. The flavour of this extract was enhanced by distillers who poured the brew into hollow bamboos and buried it in the earth to mature. In the mountainous regions, honey was fermented similarly to produce an expensive alcoholic beverage for the elite.

Records of around seventh century AD include drinking traditions of Kashmir and the North-East. Chinese traveller Huen Tsang notes warriors favoured fruit and sugarcane-based drinks, while traders enjoyed strong distilled liquor. Some Brahmins were happy to imbibe alcoholic beverages in the company of women.

Despite the ban on drinking in Islam, there are references from the Sultanate period to drinks being served at gatherings of nobility. Among the Mughul emperors, Babur enjoyed wine as did Jehangir and Shahjehan; Aurangzeb was a strict teetotaller.

The first distillery was registered in Kanpur in 1805. Today each district and village has either a licit or illicit distillery. Gujarat tried prohibition but failed to eradicate alcohol. N.T. Rama Rao, the charismatic founder of the Telugu Desam Party, rose to power in Andhra Pradesh by promising the women of alcohol-ravaged families that he would ban the sale of arrack if voted to power. He banned it for a brief while, but revoked the ban when he was reminded that the amount of revenue generated by the liquor trade was vital for state coffers. Ditto with Haryana. Devi Lal was petitioned by irate farmers’ wives to ban country liquor vends. He promised that if voted back to power as chief minister, he would. He didn’t. The main reason being that several sons and sons-in-law of powerful politicians ran large distilleries and accepted bulk orders for supplying cheap liquor in pouches, especially during district and state level, and of course the national elections.

Babur is the best guide to the subcontinent’s ambivalence towards alcohol. He is said to have had periodic bouts of abstinence when he broke all his goblets and swore never to touch wine, only to resume after a while.

“The new year”, he writes, “the spring, the wine and the beloved are pleasing. Enjoy them, Babur, for the world is not to be had a second time”.

Yediyurappaji, Ramadossji, Gehlot sir, are you listening?

Mrinal Pande likes to take readers behind the reported news in her fortnightly column. She is chief editor of Hindustan. Your comments are welcome at theotherside@livemint.com

Tags - Find More Articles On:
READ MORE ARTICLES BY:
 
Mamta Said:


Dear Madam, I was an admirer of your articles and opinion on most of the political and social issues published in newspaper and also telecasted in T.V. Your article on use of alcohol & its promotion has upset me . It is clearly refected in the article about your positive opinion about use of alcohol by giving references from our ancient indian culture. Madam, the time has changed . We are very well aware than how sensible our youth and gender are on consumption. Being a development activist , I myself have seen how misuse of alcohol has broken the backbone of social , financial , values and ethics of our society . The vulnerable condition of women and children in rural India because of having a drunken husband and father in not hidden. The corporate culture and drink has strong coordination . Alcohol is treated as an ordinary commodity . What is the result of it - more cupprution , crime , road accidents , absentism , pregnancy problems , health problem and many more. I hope you must be aware of that in western culture the consumption of alcohol has come upto a saturation level. Pepole have realised the loss of their life because of alcohol use while in India it is on rise . Most of the alcohol industries have their eyes on India as the most potential market for alcohol consumption. Alcohol has become an additional stone to the burdens to carry already : poverty , malnutrition, unemployment , malaria, T.B, HIV /AIDS, economic marginalisation. Your article on alcohol can act as a promotor , motivator for youth and women of India who consume alcohol in name of mordenisation , cultured society and role model for others.It might encourage our young generation to adopt this culture. Being a responsible reporter in media , its my request to you to show the new generation of India about the negative consequences of alcohol use in past and in present too. With regards, Mamta Srivastava Programme Manager Indian Alcohol Policy Alliance

Posted On 2/10/2009 10:58:18 AM
BanditMoorkhjee Said:


The press, especially ELM, is making a mountain out of a molehill. The so-called Sri Ram Sene is nothing more than a local outfit of roughnecks, who ought to be dealt by the local police force. But attacking them and comparing them with Taliban etc. gives ELM an opportunity to attack Hindu organizations, which they call pejoratively as the "saffron brigade". Why is everyone forgetting that it was one Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi who started all this sanctimonious campaign against alcohol? The refrain was taken up by later "Gandhians" who appointed themselves as custodians of the people's morality. This "Gandhism" was actually a perversion. Why does no one dare criticise Gandhi for having denounced alcoholic beverages? Why are Gandhi's abnormal views on sex, industrialisation etc admired? We need to sort ourselves out of this confused thinking.

Posted On 2/10/2009 11:33:23 AM
B Said:


Even Yedruppa enjoys a good drink. He really enjoyed the drink when the BJP meet happened in Bangalore. Talk about Politicans having a good time in their "guest houses" legal and illegal but dont like common people having legal fun

Posted On 2/10/2009 12:04:53 PM
rk Said:


Dear madam, I appreciate your understanding and knowledge about the great epics and sutras but dont you think this kind of article will mislead the younger generation. I am upset and angry about the hooliganism of Rama sene and strongly advocate strict punishments to them but never ever I thought of encouraging such activities to counter them.The minister had advised the young generation "Pub Bharo". It is not justified at all and now by this column , you are trying to justify the alcohol activities. Lord shiva is also known as Bhola as he takes Ganja and other things ( as told by eminent persons in different sutras) , that does not mean lets start encouraging the use of drugs and liquors by his name. Please , please do not write such articles to justify these bad things.Who knows if something bad happens to anybody ( may be you , me or anybody per se) due to influence of these things, then there will be no one to take the blame. If society defines what is wrong and what is right, then let it be. Condemn the goonda acts of rama sene but never justify the acts of drinking and smoking by giving instances of epics.

Posted On 2/10/2009 1:06:31 PM
Re: Roshan Said:


I don't think she is encouraging young men and women to take up drinking. She has tried to dispel the myth that's been created by organisations like the Ram Sena that drinking and alcohol is not part of our culture but a foreign import. I don't see anything wrong with this article. If Ram Sena and co can spread disinformation we need people like Ms. Mrinal here to give us a different and more authentic perspective.

Posted On 2/11/2009 11:55:19 PM
Deep Said:


I would like to say that the issue is not limited to drinking alcoholic beverages. The real issue is what does drinking lead to. I ask the author of this article whether she is blind to the increasing incidents of drunk driving, wives getting beaten up by drunkard husbands, drugs being mixed with drinks at pubs so that girls can be easily taken advantage of. Do our epics anywhere exhort people to drink alcohol as is being done in this article?

Posted On 2/13/2009 3:21:43 PM
S Said:


Dear Ms Pande, I applaud your courage and intellectual fortitude. We as a 'sermonising' country could do well to remember we are an ancient culture and therefore, but naturally have dabbled in brewing. But fact of the matter is, every adult individual has a choice which is his/her own to make. Period. If alcohol is being abused, perhaps we need to understand why it is so.

Posted On 2/14/2009 3:53:35 PM
Khagen Said:


This is a belated entry on your article on drinking in Mahabharatian times in the context of the attacks on pubs and on drinkers in Bangalore. Doesn't the Lord God Himself in chapter 9 of the Geeta ( the bible of India), atanzas 20 & 21, extol the cleansing power of 'soma', and the free ticket it gives to Trivedis to make a quick trip of the heavens ? Regards and more power to your elbow.

Posted On 9/5/2009 11:49:35 PM