Logwritten
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2009 2:34 AM IST

About 1500 children are diagnosed with a rare eye cancer, or retinoblastoma, every year in India. If an average Indian classroom has 50 students, the number afflicted with retinoblastoma would cover one whole school each year.

The irony is, many of these children diagnosed with retinoblastoma will never go to school. Retinoblastoma primarily affects children between the ages of one and five years. Sadly, most of these children could have been learning their standing and sleeping lines if one informed adult had given a seemingly innocuous eye problem more thought.

According to Santosh Honavar, ocular oncologist with LV Prasad Eye Institute, Hyderabad, and one of India’s most highly regarded retinoblastoma specialists, “The lives of 95% of children who receive protocol-based treatment can be saved.” Treatment can save the eyes of at least 70% of the children diagnosed overall. That’s 2,100 eyes saved every year. For the others, the only viable option is to remove the eye.

The reasoning sounds simple; but reality, whether in rural India or the national capital, is different.

What that long word means

Retinoblastoma is literally cancer that attacks the retina. Till a decade or so ago, this rare condition was fatal since just 3 of 10 advanced cases were curable.

Also Read more about retinoblastoma in our earlier article ‘Looking Ahead

Advancements in early diagnosis and in treatment made it possible to cure 9 of 10 patients. In the last few years, say experts in India, the introduction of new treatment techniques such as periocular chemotherapy with nanoparticles has ensured that the vision and lives of 70% of children with advanced retinoblastoma are saved. This is a huge jump from the earlier 30%.

When ignorance is not bliss

Sadly, the 30% of children who lose their vision or even their life to retinoblastoma are not entirely let down by technology being beaten by a raging tumour. “The major loose link in retinoblastoma is the delay in diagnosis,” points out Dr Santosh Honavar, who continues to see patients in advanced stages. As you read this, Shreyas Barthwal of NOIDA, just 22 months old, battles retinoblastoma.

His parents were concerned about a squint in the right eye of their two-month-old baby and took him to several established hospitals, but paediatricians dismissed the squint as innocuous. Shreyas also had white flecks on his eye ball from the time he was a few months old. By the time the cancer was detected and treatment began at LV Prasad Eye Institute, Shreyas, an active and seemingly healthy baby, was about 18 months old. The tumour had spread to both eyes by then. While the average eyeball measures about 25mm across, the tumour in Shreyas’ right eye was 20mm. The right eye may have suffered irreparable damage, those treating him fear. Doctors are trying to save what they can of his left eye.

READ MORE ARTICLES BY:
 
Gangadhar Said:


The article is good. A photograph of an early symptom of retinoblastoma in a child would have helped carry the message better. It is important for all of us to know about the eye cancer retinoblastoma, as early detection will go a long way in helping the child to a lead a normal life, by saving his sight, eyes and life.

Posted On 5/20/2009 2:08:53 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Mr Gangadhar, thank you for the suggestion. Early detection will save so many young lives, we all need to spread the word wherever we can: a printout put up in a school notice board, a community centre board... wherever. Regards, Benita Sen

Posted On 5/22/2009 8:54:03 PM
Re: VASANTHA Said:


The Posters prepared to disseminate awareness on Retinoblastoma and other childhood cancers were put up in some schools in Delhi during the cancer awareness week a few years ago.

Posted On 5/25/2009 11:16:13 AM
Rajkumar Said:


You have hit the nail on the head, Ms Benita Sen - lots of people don't know of cancers, of the eye, that is the pity. When people are informed of this we can expect early detection, until then it is a big challenge to publicize the symptoms nationwide. When those living in urban localities and those who are literate do not know of this life-threatening eye cancer retinoblastoma, what is to be said of those living in rural areas? The pediatricians should not overlook the disease nor provide inappropriate treatment. I think if pediatricians feel unsure about recognizing retinoblastoma, then they should refer the baby to an eye doctor. I feel that for a country the size of India, intermittent year-round messages in the media will be of greater help than would a once-in-a-year retinoblastoma symptom awareness drive. Surely looking into the eyes of a child would not take a minute of our time. Thank you for your article on the importance of pediatricians routinely checking the child's eyes.

Posted On 5/20/2009 4:48:30 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Mr Rajkumar, Thanks for the response. The irony of retinoblastoma is that it strikes an age group that is seen more frequently by a doctor than most other age groups. This is my second article on RB and I plan to continue spreading the word.

Posted On 5/22/2009 8:58:45 PM
Muralikrishna Said:


Your article has identified pediatricians as a resource for early diagnosis of retinoblastoma - but what about sensitizing doctors of all specialities to the early symptoms of this deadly childhood eye cancer? You have made two very relevant points - that not many know of retinoblastoma and that this ignorance is the same be it in the rural areas or nation's capital alike. It would be good to replicate the AIIMS-government community outreach program across our country and not wait for private organizations to provide relief to the children and their families. Orphanages and government organizations should come forth to assist children having retinoblastoma. I think your article was thought-provoking - i felt deeply moved by the Father's agony on late diagnosis of retinoblastoma in the child. Losing an eye to cancer will have its own repercussions in time to come - may God give strength to the family to face this immense loss. Media, including the television channels, press and social activist channels, should work together to facilitate early diagnosis and treatment. As they say, together we can do it.

Posted On 5/20/2009 5:04:52 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Thanks for the encouragement. You've raised some excellent points which I will convey to Dr Thavaraj. You're right: Together we can do it. Each one of us could spread the word in our offices, residential buildings, children's schools...

Posted On 5/22/2009 9:21:46 PM
naveen Said:


Great job Benita, since the disease was diagnosed to Shreyas I was desperate to know more about this disease in indian context, unfortunately not much indian material and experiences of people is available on net. This disease maximum hits children 0-4 years of age and its a matter of great surprise, pediatricians themselves are not much aware about the symptoms of this dreadful disease(as far as my experience is concerned, since shreyas was having minor squint in right eye since birth). Its very unfortunate maximum cases of advanced stages of retinoblastoma are coming just because of not giving due emphasis to the causes of abnormality in affected eyes, and there are very few examples when tumor was detected at grade A stage, I sincerely thankful to Dr. Santosh Honavar, Dr. Reddy and Dr. Vasantha and the other Medical Practitioner who are not only treating the Retinoblastoma cases but also working toward the spreading awareness about this life threatening disease. But despite of all this I firmly believe a very little is been done in this direction and a lot more is expected from govt, medical community and society as a whole I also appeal to all parents pl don’t ignore any minor abnormality in kids and also request parents like us to come up with the positive attitude and believe in your Childs ability and the finest creation of the GOD, coz every individual is a unique identity, and believe for spreading awareness about any life threatening disease we should not wait for any international event or some particular day, rather these subjects/articles should come in public on very regular basis, to make public educate enough, to take timely action and avoid the permanent disability of body part and can save life as well, and thanks murulikrishna for showing concern and for your valuable suggestions.

Posted On 5/21/2009 6:48:31 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Naveen, I hope to continue writing about retinoblastoma. Will keep you posted. Best wishes to Shreyas for a speedy recovery.

Posted On 5/22/2009 9:20:18 PM
david Said:


Good doctors here have correctly opined that early diagnosis will save many children's eyes. The public must continue to be alerted so that the national message gets out to parents. Parents must, in turn, realized the seriousness of the malady are get their kids treated if there are symptoms. It is a shame if a child loses eyesight in the 21st century, due to misinformation or lack of communication, when there are medicines to treat this disease. We praise these physicians who are battling this pestilence and saving children!

Posted On 5/24/2009 8:28:43 AM
Re: Benita Said:


David, you've hit the nail on the head. It is a shame to lose a child through late diagnosis. One fears to even begin imagining how many rural children we are losing. Let us all spread the word on the symptoms.

Posted On 5/24/2009 7:30:48 PM
Robyn Said:


Thank you for your excellent article about this terrible but curable cancer. I remember my tears shed in a rural part of southern India on my mission trip there in 2000, when I saw a young couples first son affected by retinoblastoma binocularly. I was at a loss to know what to do,as I was just a Westerner on a short-term trip. I am heartened to see the word re.early diagnosis and hopeful cure, is disemminating. In Australia, infant health nurses are trained to check for eye abnormalities as they provide immunizations for measles, mumps and diptheria, etc. When they notice abnormalities, they refer to the GP for further examination. If they arent confident in diagnosis, they refer on to a paediatrician ophthalmologist. This model may not work in India, nor in rural areas. With the use of teleophthalmology in future, health nurses may be able to do retinal photography and email these images to the hospitals such as LV Prasad where diagnosis can be administered quickly, efficiently and at a lower cost. This is starting to happen in Australia with our remote area inhabitant indigenous people who suffer diabetic retinopathy at rates up to 30% of their population. All the best in your efforts to save these little ones, in not just their sight, but their lives.

Posted On 5/24/2009 2:15:52 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Robyn, thank you for sharing some very practical, replicable experience of the model being followed in Australia. I will forward this link to the doctors I spoke with for the article. I can understand how helpless you felt when you met that couple because recently, a family we know, from a village in eastern India lost their little girl to RB. Unfortunately, by the time we heard of the diagnosis, it was too late.

Posted On 5/24/2009 7:37:11 PM
Gita Said:


Benita, what an insightful story-- and a very powerful description of the agony the Barthwals had to go through. I will make sure to spread the word to my family and friends. Thank you for taking the time to write this! Gita

Posted On 5/24/2009 5:43:09 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Thanks, Gita. Let's hope we won't need too many such articles. I say this in the hope that screening for RB will soon be routine.

Posted On 5/24/2009 7:43:32 PM
Gordon Said:


This is a most timely article for family doctors, pediatricians, and also ophthalmologists all of whom see children. We can all be guilty of missing a diagnosis from time to time but eye examinations are particularly needed in this disease. To dismiss a strabismus patient or one who has leukocoria (white pupil), or not fully examine a child in this early age group is not acceptable. If the doctor or eye technician who first sees this child is not capable of dilating the pupil a obtaining a full fundus examination then the child should be referred immediately. Early diagnosis is the key and should be practiced even if the doctor has not had a lot of training in retinal examination continuing medical education should include such things. It was not mentioned but a point of information was not mentioned - retinoblastoma was the first familial (hereditary) neoplasm. A very valuable article for all!

Posted On 5/25/2009 12:46:09 AM
VASANTHA Said:


Mannequins were used in some campaigns to highlight early disease ie,white spot in the pupil and late disease fleshy mass protruding in the eye. Photos attached

Posted On 5/25/2009 11:31:31 AM
Re: Benita Said:


Mannequins seems like a great idea. Would drive the point home faster.

Posted On 6/4/2009 10:45:52 PM
VASANTHA Said:


Also prepared a skit on the family as the setting which depicted the dialogue between two families one took the child for an early check up and survived the other one took the child late due to lack of knowledge among elders in the family and faulty advise and postponing the visit to a specialist and suffered and lost an eye. The moral of the story was early diagnosis you could save both eye and the life of the child

Posted On 5/25/2009 3:44:29 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Dr Thavaraj, has the skit been performed anywhere?

Posted On 5/27/2009 9:06:44 PM
Rob Said:


Congratulations Benita on a vitally important issue. We tend to think that the responsibility for picking up problems such as RB lies with doctors, however I believe that parents can often play a critical role in early detection, not only for RB, but other medical conditions too. No-one knows their children better than the parents. We mustn't ignore anything that looks a bit unusual, and we mustn't feel embarrassed or guilty of "wasting" the doctor's time by mentioning something that may or may not be a problem. Trust your "gut feelings". I've found they're usually right. Best of luck Benita and the team at LV Prasad in your quest to minimise the impact of RB.

Posted On 5/25/2009 3:50:57 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Rob, you're right. We need to inform more and more parents about different problems in children. At the same time, the awareness campaigns need to be two-pronged: parents and doctors. I have met alert parents who have helped the doctor detect problems early. But I have met more parents who took their child repeatedly to one or several doctors but were turned away. At the same time, there are many parents who have not been able to catch the problem early enough, probably because they were not aware or did not want to face the difficult truth. So, the health of our children ought to be team effort.

Posted On 5/27/2009 9:01:33 PM
Marnie Said:


Very interesting article. Thank you for bringing attention and awareness to retinoblastoma.

Posted On 5/25/2009 5:51:45 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Thanks. Do spread the word on retinoblastoma, Marnie.

Posted On 5/27/2009 9:12:44 PM
MR Said:


It is a sad truth; the medical system as a whole has little interest in prevention or early detection. Let us be thankful for valiant efforts like this article are gentle prods; but a nudge is simply not enough. What will force us to change - a thunderbolt from Heaven? How about a concerted effort by all interested NGOs in the field against all preventable and curable cancers - focusing on prevention and early detection?

Posted On 5/25/2009 8:19:09 PM
Re: Benita Said:


MR, good suggestion. Can you recommend any NGOs working in the field of preventable cancers in India?

Posted On 5/27/2009 9:15:05 PM
Kiran Said:


Very well written and a timely article too! My heart goes out to Barthwal family! It's unfortunate to still miss out on a curable condition in this day and age. Hopefully through Barthwal family's as well as Dr Thavaraj's activism many more treatable cases are identified in good time. As always the solution to this problem perhaps lies in multipronged approach, viz. education of the medical fraternity right at the under-graduate level, increase awareness among families with new-borns through their hospitals, neonatal clinics etc., policy changes at governmental level through its inclusion in standardised neonatal check-up etc.

Posted On 5/25/2009 10:04:06 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Yes, Kiran. Policy changes by the government may gave the fight against RB an impetus. There are countries where checks are routine. Let's hope India joins the list soon.

Posted On 5/27/2009 9:22:16 PM
JuanCarlos Said:


Good article. It would be good to measure the impact of the World Retinoblastoma Awareness Week in your own practice and with other colleagues in India working in Eye Oncology. You may identify in all cases coming to your office, early or late referral and how the parents/ patients, pediatricians etc. got the awareness and information to consult early. Year by year this may change as a result of the intervention.

Posted On 5/26/2009 7:08:15 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Good suggestion. Have forwarded your comment to some doctors in the field.

Posted On 5/27/2009 9:19:11 PM
Mopasa Said:


Dear Editor, The article is a superb one featuring many aspects the general public need to know. Is it a benign tumour when it starts off as a gleam or fleck that picks up killer character as it progresses? Why it sneaks so supremely unobstructed has to be brought to the notice of the reading public. yours truly, Mopasa

Posted On 5/27/2009 8:12:39 AM
Re: Benita Said:


Mopasa, excellent questions. Have forwarded them to the doctors for their findings.

Posted On 6/4/2009 10:43:30 PM
Mopasa Said:


Dear Editor, The article is a superb one featuring many aspects the general public need to know. Is it a benign tumour when it starts off as a gleam or fleck that picks up killer character as it progresses? Why it sneaks so supremely unobstructed has to be brought to the notice of the reading public. yours truly, Mopasa

Posted On 5/27/2009 8:12:39 AM
Re: Santosh Said:


Hi Mopasa: Retinoblastoma is the most common malignant eye tumor in children. Very rarely does it start as a benign variant called retinocytoma. Generally, it begins as a minute tumor, a couple of mm in size, and progresses to fill the entire eye. It is impossible to detect it at a 2 or a 3 mm stage UNLESS an eye doctor screens the entire retina. This screening may not be cost or time-efficient to do since retinoblastoma affects only one in 10-15,000 children. Therefore the stress is, as Benita has so effectively mentioned, on screening children manifesting with the most common symptoms of retinoblastoma - a white gleam in the eye, squint, reduced vision, persisting redness or enlargement/protrusion of the eye. Best, Santosh Honavar

Posted On 6/5/2009 3:56:01 PM
dasu Said:


A week is not going to solve the problem. Ignorance of eye or any other disease occurs at two levels. One at the rural level. The next level is the first pediatrician who examines the child. He is just casual. The first responsiibility is that of every ophthalmologist who should examine not just the child that is brought to him but every child he meets at social gatherings like weddings or temples. Ophthalmologists must organize themselves into NGOs and spread the message and treatment. Bring pressure on legislators to sponsor a bill that makes it compulsory for every parent to bring the child to a government hospital for comprehensive examination of the child's health status. The initiative must primarily come from leaders in the field of ophthalmology. In my routine check-ups for glaasses I was never told I had gluacoma. I just happened to read an article in a newspaper which said that if you see a rainbow around a naked light it is glucoma. The next day I went to the Rajendra Prasad Center for Ophthalmic Sciences and the doctor told me I had come in time.

Posted On 5/27/2009 3:57:16 PM
Hitomi Said:


Adding powerful antioxidants to your diet can improve your eye health. There’s no substitute for the quality of life good vision offers. Adding certain nutrients to your diet every day – either through foods or supplements – can help save your vision. Researchers have linked eye-friendly nutrients such as lutein/zeaxanthin, vitamin C, vitamin E, and zinc to reducing the risk of certain eye diseases, including macular degeneration and cataract formation. For more info, go to http://www.youreyesite.com

Posted On 5/27/2009 7:35:56 PM
Mike Said:


I agree the article does a very good job highlighting the need to get out information about childhood retinoblastoma, particularly in India, although clearly this is a global concern. I would like to point interested individuals to the online resources of the National Library of Medicine related to this topic. For general information about eye cancers it is best to start with MedlinePlus: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/eyecancer.html and for clinicians and researchers looking for current articles on the subject, they should look at PubMed at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?db=pubmed . Again, Benita, you are doing a great service.

Posted On 5/28/2009 12:09:24 AM
VASANTHA Said:


The skit has not been staged .The PHC at Najfagarh , Delhi seemed the ideal place for me to carry out the awareness program and capacity building workshops.They have an open air theater and the population surrounding the PHC is mostly rural. We also plan to carry out awareness and early screening of Retinoblastoma through Telemedicine in one District near to Delhi. I am also planning to get a software prepared to detect through a dilated pupil and the software will detect Retinoblastoma. Some of the activities are being planned as part of the research activities through the Centre for advanced Research in retinoblastoma ICMR/AIIMS intiative at New Delhi.

Posted On 5/28/2009 9:38:47 AM
Sheila Said:


Good underplayed article, outlining a grievous wrong; hopefully the publicity will help stem the tide for the future - keep up the good work!

Posted On 5/28/2009 11:15:14 AM
parthasarathy Said:


the solution would need roping in academcians at every level and women&Child WELFARE depts and welfare organisations AND ANGAN WADI WORKERS AS WELL AS NURSES AND PEDIATRICIAN BODIES. How about quizzing a quiz master and putting it across to the person to take up awareness programme in his repertoire?

Posted On 5/28/2009 1:31:18 PM
Archana Said:


Dear Ms. Benita, Thank you for such informative article. It will definitely help young parent being aware of such deadly disease. Pediatricians must definetly inform parent about the disease and advise for eye check-up. I and my family wish all such ailing children and Shreyas speedy recovery.

Posted On 5/28/2009 4:53:43 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Yes, Archana, awareness is like a relay race: you pass the baton on from one to the next to reach that goal of saving every child's eye and life. Let's pass the word around wherever we can in the hope of saving at least one child's sight.

Posted On 6/4/2009 10:40:49 PM
Jeanne Said:


The L V Prasad Eye Institute must be praised for their excellent work in increasing awareness of early symptoms of retinoblastoma. I learned so much and will pass on the word to others who may not have heard of this eye cancer.

Posted On 5/28/2009 7:33:52 PM
Mark Said:


Thank you for the fine article . Early detection and practicing prevention is the key in early diagnosis. A photograph or video clip would be beneficial for the public. Regards, Mark Flaherty

Posted On 5/28/2009 8:50:20 PM
Re: Benita Said:


Mark, if you want visual material, please post your email id so that we may request Drs Thavaraj and Honavar to share some material with you.

Posted On 6/4/2009 10:38:23 PM
MariaTeresa Said:


Benita, Dr. Takahashi and I from Brazil congratulate you for this important article. In a recent survey, in a period of three years, all unilateral tumors were enucleated, mean presentation age at 2years and a half; one child died from central nervous system invasion. From the bilateral cases we could salvage 50% of the eyes, no child died. We had to face the tragedy of bilateral enucleation in two patients during the study period and, we can assure you that, this is the saddest situation not only for the family but also for the whole staff in the hospital. Unfortunately only macular tumors present with an early squint. Leucocoria is a sign of grown tumors so; actually the family alone will suspect the diagnosis seldom in small tumors. Early diagnosis is a task for the government and the medical class.

Posted On 5/29/2009 3:19:57 AM
Re: Benita Said:


MariaTeresa, thank you for the appreciation. I must put on record that I'm grateful to MINT for publishing two articles by me on retinoblastoma in as many years. You are right about the family not often being in the capable of detecting early symptoms. But my point is, in the absence of mandatory testing, alert parents may be able to bring about earlier detection.

Posted On 6/4/2009 10:36:31 PM
Pam Said:


This is of course an important public health issue, and even more a personal one for all families involved. The US National Institutes of Health funds an online resource, www.genetests.org, at the University of Washington. Anyone can use it to learn more about the clinical and genetic aspects of this condition; the 'review' section of the information includes predicting risk for future children in a family. Also included is a list of laboratories conducting testing for each condition; the Sir Ganga Ram Hospital in New Delhi is among those worldwide offering such testing. Doctors and parents can share this information.

Posted On 5/30/2009 1:50:38 AM
Re: Benita Said:


Pam, thanks for the link. We are planning to approach different media across the country to continue highlighting the early symptoms for timely detection. If anyone can help with contacts of owners/producers of health programmes or anyone else who has the power to include such pieces, please send them in.

Posted On 6/4/2009 10:31:15 PM
Lynda Said:


Thank you for writing this very interesting article about retinoblastoma. It does a very good job of explaining the need for early diagnosis and treatment as well as the warning signs to watch out for. L V Prasad Eye Institute is to be congratulated for their work in this area. I hope that their doctors will see those unfortunate patients at earlier stages of the disease where it can be treated without loss of the eye and especially, life. We have hundreds of E-Consultation cases with retinoblastoma that have been managed through ORBIS Telemedicine, Cyber-Sight (www.cybersight.org)by a team of experts at the Hamilton Eye Institute and St. Jude's Children's Research Hospital and this consultation service is growing. We have also undertaken the project of posting online courses through E-Learning and retinoblastoma is a subject that will be covered in the next category of pediatric ophthalmology. Our combined efforts along with those of many others can make a difference in the detection and treatment of retinoblastoma in India and many other countries around the world.

Posted On 6/30/2009 12:57:22 AM
Re: Benita Said:


Lynda, I sincerely hope more people, specially the medical fraternity, read your feedback. Although exactly the same system may not work in India, I'm sure we could take something from your early diagnosis programme.

Posted On 7/11/2009 2:12:40 PM
Monika Said:


Hi Benita, Thanx for sharing such a vital info with us on retinoblastoma. Most of the parents normally ignore this kind of squint or some smaller issues with their child and more often pediatrician unable to understand. When it comes to the knowledge, it has become more dreadful. I am sure after reading your article, every parent will consider the smaller uneven thing with their kid and take proper consultation. We should spread the info about teh detection and prevention about this dreadful but curable disease to the masses. Great job and go ahead.

Posted On 10/26/2009 4:20:03 PM