Log has written
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 24, 2009

The new United Progressive Alliance (UPA) has already stoked market appetite for big economic reforms in privatization and foreign investment. Whether or not it will deliver remains to be seen. But there are signs that the UPA is serious about reform in another, quieter area: education. Altering government regulation here may not spark a short-term stock market rally, but it will have a more long-term impact on the nation.

Kapil Sibal’s appointment as minister of human resource development (HRD) has already been hailed as a positive step. Now, as Mint reported on Monday, the government is seriously considering a regulatory overhaul.

A senior official at HRD told this newspaper that the government will soon abolish both the University Grants Commission (UGC) and the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE), replacing them with a new independent regulator. To put that in perspective, that’s like doing away with the Reserve Bank of India and installing a new banking regulator. The move may sound too bold to some, but multiple committees have found that this is the best avenue for reform.

The National Knowledge Commission (NKC) has recommended this repeatedly, as has a committee under Yash Pal. With not one but two regulators, supervision is already complicated. And heavy-handed regulation gives universities little autonomy—even introducing a new academic course requires approval.

Add to that the usual bureaucratic corruption and inefficiency, and India is left with incompetent management of perhaps its greatest resource today: its large and young population.

In the last UPA government, Arjun Singh’s HRD not only disregarded NKC’s suggestions but even downgraded the importance of the Yash Pal committee to make its recommendations non-binding. Under Sibal’s watch, we hope the government can correct this neglectful attitude.

No doubt, how the government goes about handling this is key. For instance, we still don’t know what this new independent regulator will look like. But even a small change of course from the past can help dismantle one of the last bastions of the licence raj. In turn, that would empower thousands of young Indians with opportunities.

Will the second UPA government reform education? Tell us at views@livemint.com

Tags - Find More Articles On:
 
s Said:


3 regulators are there. UGC, AICTE & their big brother HRD ministry itself. Like too many cook spoil the food. too many regulators have already spoiled the education system. Everybody is pointing at other for any decision especially any odd decision.

Posted On 6/9/2009 2:56:08 PM
KODUKULA Said:


The Editor, livemint.com Dear Sir, It is a good move to abolish both UGC and AICTE the present regulators of higher education in the country. The HRD ministry intends to establish one independent regulator for surveillance of higher education in the country. The new institution may be modeled on lines of IRDA/TRAI etc. It is reported that UGC is forced to revisit its own decisions on granting deemed university status to couple of institutions in the country. This is nothing but a mess created that should have been avoided. It is time the red-tapism must be given a goodbye to enable India to compete with best of universities in the world. UPA-I failed to live up to its expectation on this front, and let us hope the HRD ministry under the stewardship of Kapil Sibal will be able to deliver goods. In the wake of reforms in the education sector, government should pay its attention on creation of world class infrastructure hitherto neglected by the government. Excellent infrastructure coupled with well trained faculty is sine-qua-non to enable India to make a mark in the field of education. In my view, government will be compelled to carry on its reform agenda in the education sector also and the initiative taken by HRD minister is an indication in the right direction. Thanking you Knvs subrahmanyam Chartered Accountant Hyderabad

Posted On 6/9/2009 4:24:02 PM
Joy Said:


I wonder whther it is only the UGC, AICTE and teh MHRD that are the last bastion of license raj in education. There are a multiplicity of bodies controlled by various people who control education in our country. In the medical side we have the Medical Council of India, Dental Council of India, Pharmaceutical Council, Nursing council - on teh legal side we have the Bar Council and we also have the Directorate General of Employment and training. These bodies are controlled by different minsitries such as the misitry of law oversees the Bar Council, the Ministry of health teh medical council etc. Then we have the minsitry of agriculture overseeing Agricultural Universities, Veterinerary colleges What we need that all ministries that deal with education (in any form) should be brought under one single unbrella ministry at the national level. There are issues related to turf wars here and one doubts whether the UPA government II will take the opportunity of the mandate given to deal with this ones and for all. Revamping AICTE, UGC is only part of rectifying the current rot in the system and regime of lecense raj.

Posted On 6/10/2009 4:06:53 PM
Rahul Said:


Masters Programme in Government - MITSOG Hi Everybody! MIT School of Government is Asia’s first institute to offer a one-year, full-time MASTERS PROGRAM IN GOVERNMENT (MPG) – a leadership training program that prepares students for a career in Politics & Government. Search MITSOG to find out more. If you are fed up with today’s politicians, want to make a difference in society or want to join politics but don’t know where to start - MIT School of Government can show you the way. Thank you for your time. This is Rahul Bhatia helping MITSOG nurture leaders who care.

Posted On 6/10/2009 4:13:39 PM