Log has written
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2009

Vishal Bhardwaj’s Kaminey has been the most anticipated film of this year. And justifiably so. His earlier works are products of a ripe, evolved imagination—one that gives flight to the ugly, and revels in it. In his two most successful films—Maqbool and Omkara—lurks a thick texture of rot and violence. It is in the air that the bad, foul-mouthed goons and gangsters inhabit. It’s in the milieu, the story, the climate and the temper.

Kaminey is no different, although alongside the evil, there’s its equally riveting—and flawed—flipside, the good. The bad and good are intertwined by blood, hate and circumstances in this multi-plot story—a narrative circle of interconnecting, time-jumping episodes that involve gangsters, druglords, their flunkies and some ordinary people. As in all his films, Bhardwaj blurs the boundaries of morality.

Suffice it to say, it is indeed the year’s best film so far.

It is everything you expected it to be: brutal, sexy, and not pretty. The song Dhan ta nan, which pulled off the film’s promotion, is, in fact, not one of the film’s best things. There’s much more happening here.

The story has too many strands for me to outline here. Essentially, it’s about Charlie and Guddu, twins separated after their father died a sudden, tragic death. They are each other’s diametric opposites: Guddu (Shahid Kapur) is an NGO worker who lives in a concrete Mumbai chawl; he stammers. He has planned his life: success in 2009, marriage in 2014, children in 2016, towards which he is earnestly working. Guddu is in love with Sweety (Priyanka Chopra), a feisty Maharashtrian girl, the sister of a gangster, Bhope (Amole Gupte). Charlie on the other hand, is only after money. He hedges bets in horse races and has no qualms about killing someone for a lakh of rupees. Fearless and gleefully self-destructive, he dreams of owning his own betting booth one day. Guddu and Charlie don’t see eye to eye.

These three characters are the story’s centre, but much of what makes Kaminey so engaging are the other characters propelling the story.

Bhardwaj uses the entire first half of the film in establishing the characters, but there’s hardly a dull moment because the scenes are bolstered by superb dialogues (written by Bhardwaj himself) and a humour that has his roots as much in the situations and the characters, as in the city in which the characters live. Gritty Mumbai, by the gutters, and in luxury hotel suites, gets its due. The entire film is visually enticing, filmed by Tassdduq Husain, who also shot Omkara.

You watch one potent scene after another, and then get to the climax. Kaminey has this effect: it psychs you up to accept everything it shows you. After I walked out of the theatre, I took time to absorb all that had happened. Which is not to say that the story is so intricately layered with meanings. It’s not. Kaminey is meant to be a thrilling ride; it is a smart and stylish potboiler.

Its calculated grunginess somewhat works against it. The cleverness of the writers (four people get credit: Vishal Bhardwaj, Abhishek Chaubey, Supratik Sen and Sabrina Dhawan) are evident is every scene. Although Bhardwaj never loses touch with the ordinary look of things, or the common touch, the style overpowers the film. The climax scene is a bizarrely funny episode that is meant to be ironic, but it gets drowned in all the noise.

Kaminey is in the genre of Pulp Fiction, Mean Streets, Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels and Satya. In these films the multi-plot narrative is taken to the perfect pitch, where every character has a complete, satisfying graph. Here, it’s more a mosaic. Like one of its memorable characters, Kaminey is a tad too high on cocaine in parts.

Bhardwaj’s biggest achievement is in extracting performances out of Shahid Kapur and Priyanka Chopra. In two different roles, Kapur is always in character; the lisp and the stammer comes at just the right time. Kapur’s career should take a different turn after this performance, undoubtedly he can be one of the best actors we have. Chopra’s role as the mulgi (Maharashtrian for girl, that’s what her brother calls her) doesn’t seem laboured although the Maharashtrian accent doesn’t really have that raspy zing. The performance by Amole Gupte as the mean, hilarious gangster whose enemy is any outsider who comes to live in Mumbai is memorable.

Kaminey is a film of danger, hilarity and vibrant local colour. It is thrillingly alive; go get high.

Kaminey released in theatres across the country on Friday. In Mumbai, navi Mumbai and Thane, it is scheduled to release on 17 August, Monday.

sanjukta.s@livemint.com

Tags - Find More Articles On:
READ MORE ARTICLES BY:
 
Anand Said:


Sanjukta - thanks for a well written review. Infact, your review is one of the best i have read in a long time.

Posted On 8/14/2009 5:10:59 PM
rahul Said:


i also highly recommend this movie to all

Posted On 8/14/2009 8:37:04 PM
nisha Said:


Your writing is so superficial. no depth. And, do you really know anything about the films?

Posted On 8/14/2009 9:30:51 PM
Nikhill Said:


dis is d best movie . u must go n watch shahids new look as KAMINEY.

Posted On 8/14/2009 10:12:40 PM
Imaan Said:


OMFG!! I LOVE SHAHID KAPOOR AND I THINK ITS HIGH TIME PPL SHOULD RESPECT HIM FOR BEING ONE OF THE BEST ACTORS IN BOLLYWOOD!! THE MOVIE IS REALLY REALLY GOOD!!

Posted On 8/14/2009 11:24:26 PM
Bhaskar Said:


Its torture sitting for full length of this movie...........this muve SUCKS BIGTIME.....one of the most meaningless movie ever made...the story goes nowhere..actually it doesn't has any ??

Posted On 8/14/2009 11:49:04 PM
Re: Kam Said:


I couldnt agree more.. it has no meaning.. the end has no logic.. and priyanka says dont leave your brain behind before you come to the movie.. i say they should not have left it behind before making it :) If you can digest illogical situations just because they are thrilling.. you will love it!

Posted On 8/16/2009 3:45:08 PM
Bhaskar Said:


Its torture sitting for full length of this movie...........this muve SUCKS BIGTIME.....one of the most meaningless movie ever made...the story goes nowhere..actually it doesn't has any ??

Posted On 8/14/2009 11:49:04 PM
Re: Raja Said:


Maybe you need everything to be served on a platter.

Posted On 8/16/2009 4:29:45 PM
Vijay Said:


It is one of the worst films I have ever seen in a theatre( insisted by my wife0 I could have well come out after the 1/2 but did not wish to annoy my better half.Story was spoiled by Direction and Sound effects photography was awfull.The characters were subdued and good work of Shahid was brought to nought by Vishal.A must not see film

Posted On 8/15/2009 4:13:39 AM
Shubham Said:


I totally agree with the Review writer. Shahid can be the best actor we have considering he is 28, he has at least 10 more years to reach the zenith. Chopra- Mulgi, for most of north Indians may just be very attractive as we haven't gone deep into the 'accent'. But rightfully put, the movie has more. The other characters were well carved. Ultimately it is not the actors but their characters that you wanna talk about. Kudos to Kaminey- Class apart!

Posted On 8/15/2009 2:23:39 PM
nakshtra Said:


i expect it to be a good movie,typical of vishal to make a dark but scintillating movie. and yes, of course shahid looks great in his stammering avatar. priyanka, as always is pretty.

Posted On 8/16/2009 12:38:48 AM
poonam Said:


really glad to *finally* read a review that tags it as a 'smart movie' as opposed to 'intelligent cinema'. i have no complaints from vishal bhardwaj though - after the textured and richly nuanced maqbool and omkara he deserves his bit of razmatazz with kaminey. and what a stylish way to deliver.

Posted On 8/16/2009 2:35:41 PM
vikas Said:


Seriously, have you even seen pulp fiction or snatch or lock stock? how can you even compare kaminey to any of these movies? what the hell were you thinking when you were writing such a misleading review? you really dont understand cinema!

Posted On 8/16/2009 2:45:19 PM
Inder Said:


I think this movie is a result of Sick mind, no story / nothing to see in the movie, normally people goes to movie to relex him self, after comming out there will be a headche. I have seen the worst movie / westage of money

Posted On 8/16/2009 4:37:36 PM
Ashok Said:


""Guddu (Shahid Kapur) is an NGO worker who lives in a concrete Mumbai chawl;"" Hulloo!!!!!!!!! Get your facts right! He's supposed to be a student of a local polytechnic, staying in a hostel. And how come, girls are freely allowed inside the hostel for sex??

Posted On 8/16/2009 5:01:50 PM
Ashima Said:


It has real characters, real comedy, identifiable situations (I have friends as crazy as Mikhail, and most of us know someone or the other from the movie) excellent layering of the sub plots, definitely intelligently written...the icing on the cake was that Vishal cared to put a few points across with the 'aamchi mumbai' zealot and a protagonist who was distributing condoms in a red light area in his opening scene...and very thoughtfully done..Not seen a reel life romance as real as that of sweety and guddu in quite a long time. Dont see why someone should not enjoy even a bit of it, leave alone hate it!

Posted On 8/16/2009 6:25:34 PM
Film Said:


Movie sucks.,,period!

Posted On 8/17/2009 2:15:28 AM
Alekhya Said:


I just cant believe that this movie is termed as the best movie of this year so far....i personally think the movie was TERRIBLE!..too much violence...and the story wasn't fabulous...seriously i think the director is messed up....its definitely not worth watching

Posted On 8/26/2009 7:14:39 AM
Shankar Said:


Kaminey = Pulp ficiton Dhan Te Nan = Pumpkin and Honey Bunny with a little black eyed peas Write your own damn stories or just stop making movies :)

Posted On 11/9/2009 4:44:32 AM