Logwritten
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2009 12:27 PM IST

Mumbai: There are two political events in Mumbai where crowds do not have to be hired and trucked in to create a false show of strength: the death anniversary of B.R. Ambedkar on 6 December and the annual Dusshera rally addressed by Shiv Sena supremo Bal Thackeray. These are the two days when loyalists come on their own in packed trains, alight at Dadar railway station and then walk another 15 minutes to reach the Shivaji Park area where the city’s big political rallies are traditionally held.

So old timers in Maharashtrian-dominated area took notice of the fact that this was happening all over again when Raj Thackeray held a political rally. It was an advance warning to other political parties that the leader of the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) had struck a chord with his growing band of supporters, even as his divisive political acts threatened Mumbai’s famed cosmopolitan culture and made him the man many love to hate.

Illustration: Jayachandran / Mint

Illustration: Jayachandran / Mint

There were similar reports from other urban centres in Maharashtra, of teeming crowds listening with rapt attention when Raj Thackeray spoke. “You could feel the electricity in the air during his campaign speeches,” said Avinash Gowariker, a photographer and close friend of Raj Thackeray, who went along for many of the rallies. “He has Balasaheb’s skills of oratory. But that’s not all. Raj did not go around making empty promises as most politicians do. It almost seemed as if he was shaking people out of their inertia. Every rally was like a wake-up call,” he added.

The results of the state assembly elections, out on Thursday, show that Raj Thackeray and his party have made huge inroads into the Shiv Sena’s voter base in cities such as Mumbai, Thane, Pune and Nashik. His party’s own tally is a modest 13 in a 288 seat state assembly. But the MNS split the opposition vote and helped the Congress-Nationalist Congress Party combination return to power for a third time in a row.

“The MNS has decimated the Shiv Sena, especially in urban areas and, to some extent, even in rural areas. The MNS is trying to occupy the opposition space which the Shiv Sena and Bharatiya Janata Party, or BJP, have failed to do. However, we must remember the divisive politics of the MNS are not good for a cosmopolitan city like Mumbai. Since the three years that he formed the MNS, apart from his own charisma, a combination of factors helped Raj Thackeray. To begin with, the media gave him ample publicity. Two, the NCP helped it to an extent by going soft on it on several issues. Three, he managed to capture the constituency that Shiv Sena has been losing,” said B. Venkatesh Kumar, professor of political science at Mumbai University

Tags - Find More Articles On:
READ MORE ARTICLES BY:
 
Sam Said:


This guy is same as the people who voted for Raj. MNS is same as Nick Griffin's racist party in UK. One common thing "Stupid leader". I had always defended my matrabhumi where I was born and raised(Mumbai). After looking into the results of Mumbai I seriously doubt it. MNS won in Mumbai and most of the seats second. Raj is doing to India what ISI and even powerful countries could not do. What does he mean by Indigenous people? Am I one? I was born there I was raised their I speak marathi? No so who are those people? The same questions were raised against Nick griffin leader of BNP in London yesterday who could not answer this and even Raj can not because both of them are Frog in a well who have not seen the sea. I wish Marathi people to come forward and defeat him. My parents are from Uttarakhand where more than 50% of the people join Armed forces. They do not ask if someone is marathi manoos or not. They defend the country. Dehradun is also full of people from all over. They do not protest. The thing they do is make people from their community better so that they can compete instead of taking back route. Happy to discuss.

Posted On 10/23/2009 4:54:33 PM
Re: Hari Said:


Hey Sam: You are probably the product of the Hindi and English news channels media which tends to project Raj's views in negative light. Tell me something - how many translated interviews have you heard of Raj? I bet not a single one! There is an underlying economic argument on the basis of which the MNS was formed. The argument is that of crumbling infrastructure due to complete non-governance in states like UP and Bihar. If you want to country to develop. let each state work for its own development. You cannot have some state CM's building statues while others work their butts off. Is it not every local's prerogative to be employed in his own state? Even so economic migration is ok. It happens all over the world. The difference here is it acts with political connivance - where politicians from UP encourage people to move and set base elsewhere (either on streets or govt land) and create ghettoized vote banks. Once you change the demographics of the new place, capturing state and local lower is easy. Already, SP candidates are being elected in pockets of Maharashtra due to these ghettoes. Many of these migrate illegally consume resources of the state without paying for it. This is not an opinion. It is a fact supported by data. One cannot use the excuse of Raj Thackeray being divisive etc etc. as an excuse to beat him while continuing to ignore the ground realities. A lot of the media attention he receives is beating up a taxi driver which was like a ONE off incident. He is silly that he is diluting his own message by indulging in this. But he dosen't need to. The underlying message is strong and someone has to listen to it.

Posted On 10/24/2009 7:20:47 AM
Re: Common Said:


Mumbai faces a tragedy of the commons. In such cases, its upto local politicians to take the mantle and restore some order. Thakaray may be a goonda, but that is the need of the hour. Mumbai has turned into a shithole and because its a lush green field to be looted (as the constitution provides no "controlled immigration" (nor is it practical), the only option is political methods, like thackarays...if he can get rid of ALL zopadpattis in mumbai, thats what we want. What about the economy being driven by these people ? I think the economy will take care of itself. Private property MUST be safeguarded by law. if the law is not powerful enough, politicians have to take matters in their own hands. Indigeneous people are all those who intend to speak in marathi on the streets. Are you ? :-) ?

Posted On 11/10/2009 7:47:19 AM
Anant Said:


Dear sir, Raj Saheb i hope ur future u very great person . JAI MNS JAI MAHARASHTRA.... MO- 9920823181

Posted On 10/23/2009 5:36:02 PM
Mohit Said:


There is no place for the divisive policies of certain political paties and leaders in India. No sensible person will endorse the policies of Raj. He has got nuisance value, which is helping Congress. Therefore Congress is indifferent to Raj and his brand of politics. The electrorate in country is getting mature by each day. The maturity of electrorate will ensure no more rise in political fortuns of Raj. His bubble will burst in next election. BJP and Shiv sena need to look within and be more accommodative to persons of other region and religion if they want to head any government in Maharashtra or in India. It may be noted that BJP could manage to come back in States where CM's are busy in developing the states without the slogan of Hindutava or for regional feelings. Congress is going high these days winning all important elections However next UP election will decide whether congress will be able to maintain their grip on electrorate and BJP loosing the same. BJP may become a spent force by the time of next UP elections

Posted On 10/23/2009 6:07:34 PM
Mallikarjun Said:


For a cosmopolitan city like MUMBAI, a leader like Raj, is not a good sign of improvement. I agree that he has got lot of attention in the recent past by his activities and the support from media. The question whether he deserves that or not is left to you. Divide and rule policy, conservative, myopic attitude, these are not the characters of the leader who is dreaming to rule the city of dreams "Amchee Mumbai". Mumbai is not just a part of Maharashtra it's the financial capital of India.

Posted On 10/24/2009 12:36:09 PM
Re: MeMarathi Said:


Now there would be improvement in Mumbai. As there would be less migration of people.Each city has its limit, I am afraid Mumbai is near to crossing the limit. Mumbai is first the capital of Maharashtra and then financial capital. Jai Hind, Jai Maharashtra

Posted On 10/26/2009 11:52:50 AM
Ajay Said:


This is the funny side of the Media, because they want to increase they are TRP now they are accepting that Raj is a hero. All the states were created based on the Language, so without any doubt "Marathi" should be the language which should have importance". In Maharashtra people from Rajasthan have also settled but nobody ever targeted them, because they speak marathi,they respect Marathi. Today Raj has 13 MLA's next time he would be ruling the state for sure. There would be no party called Shivsena in this state. BJP would have no option to go with Raj. If

Posted On 10/26/2009 11:47:13 AM
Re: Sandesh Said:


My views- parameterized.blogspot.com

Posted On 10/27/2009 10:46:13 PM