Log has written
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 24, 2009

Mumbai: It was supposed to be an innocuous briefing on a new business proposal, recalls Arun Nanda, chairman of Mahindra Holidays and Resorts India Ltd, of a meeting in the mid-1990s that he had with Anand Mahindra, vice-chairman of Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd.

The agenda was to evaluate the concept of timeshare—a form of ownership or right to use a property, typically a holiday resort—as a potential new business opportunity to diversify the group’s interests from manufacturing tractors and utility vehicles.

 Old hand: Arun Nanda plans to give up all executive positions in the group from 1 April while remaining chairman of Mahindra Holidays.

Old hand: Arun Nanda plans to give up all executive positions in the group from 1 April while remaining chairman of Mahindra Holidays.

Nanda took along to the meeting a bunch of clippings to make his case for a business that, in those days, made news for all the wrong reasons, such as dubious promoters and fly-by-night operators. What swayed Mahindra into green-lighting the proposal was that no newspaper questioned the concept of timeshare as a business, per se.

Incorporated on 20 September 1996, Mahindra Holidays received an infusion of Rs18 crore from the group to start its business. The venture turned out to be a rare multi-bagger; Mahindra Holidays, which raised Rs180 crore in a June initial public offering (IPO) that saw demand for 10 times the stock on offer, now commands a market value of around Rs3,000 crore.

The company’s flagship Club Mahindra Holidays brand has a customer base of at least 100,000 members and around two dozen resorts in India and abroad, offering holiday activities ranging from indoor games to adventure sports, water sports, camping and treks.

For the group, timeshare was the second attempt at entering the hospitality sector. A 50:50 joint venture with Accor SA, Europe’s largest hotel company today, had proved to be short-lived.

In hindsight, the decision to end the venture with Accor and cut losses was a prudent move, says Nanda, a Mahindra veteran of 36 years, who joined as an accountant in the management trainee cadre and plans to give up all executive positions in the group effective 1 April while remaining chairman of Mahindra Holidays and Resorts.

“The hotel business is a very capital-intensive business and it’s not easy to become the No. 1 player in the segment, as the capital requirement is very high,” Nanda said in an interview from his fifth floor office in the red brick headquarters of the Mahindra group, a signature building in Mumbai’s Worli area.

In the conventional hotel business, the promoter would need to invest for six-seven years before reaping any returns. “It takes years to make a profit, two-three years to build the business; whereas in this business, you sell timeshares today and give the right to use 12 months later. Hence, financially, the timeshare business model requires low capital,” Nanda says.

Analysts agree that the business model works, obviating the need for timeshare companies to borrow.

1  2 3 4 
READ MORE ARTICLES BY:
 
sreeni Said:


Time shared holidays never makes sense for members, only for "investors" and "promotors". If you are considering to be member, just invest the membership money in fixed deposit or some other safe investments, you can have better holiday wherever and whenever you want. In Florida, time shared holiday sellers looked as evil salesmen.

Posted On 11/5/2009 9:19:57 AM
B Said:


"Mahindra is moving to address the complaint." So do they are really short of capacity? with how many %? Why they should deliver late when customer has committed/paid for 25 years. To maintain bottom line for share holders who can sell his share any time (compared to member who has committed for 25 years)? ------------------- Why not ClubMahindra declare exactly how many hotel unit (or unit available to non members) they have in their different resorts? What is left for members? ----------------------- Who take hit of resort under utilisation? Are promotion/other events usages of resort replenished back? -------------- ClubMahindra earn good amount of interest money from their EMI schemes. Why CM does not give any interest to the people who get late refund of their money after membership cancellation?

Posted On 11/5/2009 11:31:55 AM
Ajay Said:


If the writeup is only to inform the public that Club Mahindra has a market value of Rs. 3000 crores and at least 100000 members, I have no problem. However, the service offered is of dubious quality and the number of active members (those who actually avail the holidays) is far less.

Posted On 11/5/2009 11:35:08 AM
Shibashish Said:


Club Mahindra resorts are great, but their sales team are cheats. The real-cost, annual subscription charges, and hidden costs are never communicated. Since there has been quite a number of memberships, it is very difficult to get a holiday booked in any of their 25 resorts. I have posted my review on Mouthshut.com as well as on my blog at http://shib4u.blogspot.com/2009/04/club-mahindra-review.html

Posted On 11/5/2009 11:40:56 AM
Sridhar Said:


"13 years on, the firm commands a market value of Rs3,000 crore and has at least 100,000 members" - Doesn't this say everything? Rs. 3000 swindled from each member. Anyone who buys timeshares direct from Club Mahindra is an idiot. If you REALLY want to buy a timeshare , use the resale market.

Posted On 11/6/2009 5:00:53 AM
sreeni Said:


Time shared holidays promoters build private assets with member's money. Look at what Country Club is doing. Members own nothing other than false promises. Country Club sells membership and then tries to give 20% "discount" on hotel charges which are anyway 100% jacked-up! Company gets capital in the name of "membership", "maintenance", "service" charges and potentially guaranteed customers who are going to pay hefty rate! Never, ever try to be member of these holiday clubs, let the investors put their hard earned money to build facilities and you pay for using it. If X hotel doesn't have vacancy when you want, there will be y, z etc who will provide the same service at much more competitive prices. If you are not happy, don't go to that hotel next time, try something else, where as you are locked in Clubs!!!

Posted On 11/6/2009 2:05:40 PM
Sudha Said:


We took membership in Feb 2009 and our Id is 1445180.This is to inform you that we have not yet received the gift voucher of Rs 15,000/ which we were supposed to receive in mid July.This is as per the membership letter we received from Mr.Nambiar on March 12.We have been asking for the same and clarification on delay since begining July.I am sorry to say that the response from MR dept, Mumbai was (and still is) very pathatic to say the least. We did not get any response or could get people on phone (in the month July/August) after great dificulty. Even when we could get someone on phone we would get reply that concerned person is not there and he/she would get back to us, which would never happen.When we were frustrated by this prolonged non response we indicated that we may think of cancelling membership if such thing contiues.Only in this case undue promptness was shown by the team saying that we have asked for cancellation. I do not know what prompted them to take this incorrect step, without even bothering to check with us.We sent a mail on 12 Aug saying we have not asked for cancellation.Even after this we got call from MR team saying that they need letter from us that we do not want to cancel the membership.We told that when we had not asked for cancellation why should we give this letter.Then standard official answer came saying that it is required for official purpose and you will immedietly get the gift voucher. Even though it was not our fault and the mistake was on MR ,we sent a letter saying that for your record purpose we are sending it.This was sent on 22 Sept.Till now we have not received the gift vouchers nor any intimation on the same. We have already paid 7 EMI already with 50% downpayment. We came to know that there was a member grievence meet on 26/27 Sept in mumbai but we did not get any intimation regarding this.We did not expect this kind of pathetic responce from clubM. We feel cheated and are wondering what kind of an Orgnisation is this!!

Posted On 11/9/2009 9:47:36 AM
Re: n Said:


Either you have surplus money or you don't care about the amount you are paying to such useless business model firm. I think it's high time you stop making payment and ask for the refund. The amount you have paid already, you might have got a better holiday yourself if you have utilized it..

Posted On 11/10/2009 10:36:58 AM
Sudha Said:


We took membership in Feb 2009 and our Id is 1445180.This is to inform you that we have not yet received the gift voucher of Rs 15,000/ which we were supposed to receive in mid July.This is as per the membership letter we received from Mr.Nambiar on March 12.We have been asking for the same and clarification on delay since begining July.I am sorry to say that the response from MR dept, Mumbai was (and still is) very pathatic to say the least. We did not get any response or could get people on phone (in the month July/August) after great dificulty. Even when we could get someone on phone we would get reply that concerned person is not there and he/she would get back to us, which would never happen.When we were frustrated by this prolonged non response we indicated that we may think of cancelling membership if such thing contiues.Only in this case undue promptness was shown by the team saying that we have asked for cancellation. I do not know what prompted them to take this incorrect step, without even bothering to check with us.We sent a mail on 12 Aug saying we have not asked for cancellation.Even after this we got call from MR team saying that they need letter from us that we do not want to cancel the membership.We told that when we had not asked for cancellation why should we give this letter.Then standard official answer came saying that it is required for official purpose and you will immedietly get the gift voucher. Even though it was not our fault and the mistake was on MR ,we sent a letter saying that for your record purpose we are sending it.This was sent on 22 Sept.Till now we have not received the gift vouchers nor any intimation on the same. We have already paid 7 EMI already with 50% downpayment. We came to know that there was a member grievence meet on 26/27 Sept in mumbai but we did not get any intimation regarding this.We did not expect this kind of pathetic responce from clubM. We feel cheated and are wondering what kind of an Orgnisation is this!!

Posted On 11/9/2009 9:47:36 AM
Re: Sudha Said:


Mr N, We don't have surplus money. It is our hard earned money.They are not saying that they won't give the vouchers. They are just delaying it. All the time they are saying, it as an isolated case, but are not correcting their mistakes immediately. We have sent mail to people like Ajay Nambiar, Ramesh who hold higher level posts in the organisation but that has not helped us. Our intention to post this comment is to let the owners of the organisation realize what kind of inefficient jockers it is filled with.

Posted On 11/11/2009 9:15:14 AM
Sujata Said:


I am one of those lucky ones who lost only Rs 50000 because of the false promises made by the promotional team. I could cancel the membership and save the rest of the money which I hope to invest and go for holidays at my own convenience. Be careful and cancel the membership within 2 weeks if you have second thoughts about the membership otherwise you will loose the whole money paid (like me!)

Posted On 11/9/2009 3:17:07 PM
Re: Vasu Said:


Giving false promises while taking CM membership and then making you frustrated by not keeping, is probably a parallel racket run by some of the employees.They see to it that you loose atleat Rs 25,000/-. This may be happening to hundreds/thousands of people. Then the respective employees show it as a profit(running in lakhs) to the organisation because they need not have to take any bookings from you, once you cancel the membership.So it is better to take the benefits of the mistake that is made than cancelling the membarship. Whether owners are aware of it ???

Posted On 11/13/2009 11:37:22 AM