Brahma as part of trinity is a very christian concept.Trying to understand Hinduism in the light of Cristian concepts brought in the idea of Hindu Trinity. Thrimurthy in Hinduism is totally different. But, That apart the article is a good conversation starter. Generalizations can be made about any society. I do not agree that indian or Hindu do not give. Public works such as building water bodies, irrigation system public choultries etc is part of Hindu ethos -- have you forgotton Annadana? Hindus don not advertise their philantrophy. Hinduism does not expect tithing [ which often masks as philanthropy or giving to church] US Philanthropy starts with "your tax deductible contribution" -- if there was no tax write off -- giving will not be a great business -- I know I work with non profits and it is a very big business. Are driving habits any better in a predominantly muslim country like Bangladesh or Pakistan? French drivers and Italian Drivers -- do they drive that way because they are of a certain faith ethos? Hindus do give when they need to; without the fanfare. Bartering with the divine is part of every faith at the non philosophical, daily life level.