Home Companies Industry Politics Money Opinion LoungeMultimedia Science Education Sports TechnologyConsumerSpecialsMint on Sunday

Ailing Air India may test government’s reform zeal

Ailing Air India may test government’s reform zeal
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Thu, Jul 02 2009. 10 58 AM IST
Updated: Thu, Jul 02 2009. 10 58 AM IST
New Delhi: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has been confronted by a high-profile challenge less than two months into his second term — how to fix the ailing national airline carrier, which has asked the government for a bailout.
The government has given Air India, which suffered $875 million in losses in the fiscal year ending March, a month to submit a plan to restructure and cut costs.
Aviation minister Praful Patel said last week the Congress-led government is “fully committed” to the airline but urged Air India to “rise to the occasion”.
But if the carrier does not, in Patel’s words, “shape up”, the government faces a choice whether to infuse cash without real changes in the running of the airline, attempting a partial privatization through an IPO, or letting the airline founder.
Air India’s plight could indicate how far Singh will reform India’s state companies often seen as dragging economic growth, or whether he will side with protecting jobs and votes.
Founded before India won independence from Britain, Air India was long a source of pride. But experts say the airline has been mismanaged for years and delivers a shoddy product..
Letting the airline fend for itself and lose many of its 31,500 employees would be risky for the Congress-led government, though it won a convincing general election victory in May.
Air India may also give a wider signal to how far Singh, with his strong mandate to push Congress’ agenda of inclusive growth, will dare to introduce market reforms and help India climb back to the 9% annual growth before the financial crisis bit.
“This is a test case,” said political analyst Amulya Ganguli. “The point is whether Manmohan Singh will have the guts, so to say, to turn it around.”
“The reformist line ... is still not very popular in India. It is seen as kowtowing to the money guys and being too harsh on the workers,” Ganguli added.
Leaner And Trimmer
The carrier, which wants to cut employee costs by more than $100 million annually and asked senior employees to forego salaries in July, has sought extra cash through equity and soft loans.
The aviation minister has promised support for the airline, which has a fleet of 148 aircraft, if it becomes “leaner and trimmer”, adding it would not be given “an open-ended chequebook”.
Praful Patel did not specify the bailout’s size, nor mention job losses. He said the airline would have to implement manpower restructuring, including top management, and cost-cutting.
Air India says it is another victim of the global crisis.
“Tell me, which airline is making profit?” said Air India spokesman Jitendra Bhargava. “You can’t have Air India in isolation, right?”
Air India’s dominance has been challenged in recent years by a number of new private airlines, and bilateral agreements that allowed a greater influx of foreign carriers.
Experts say the rot in Air India predates the financial crisis. Backed by powerful unions, the airline is bloated, badly managed and not held to account, they say.
“Air India is an example of a remarkable failure,” said Kapil Kaul, chief executive, India and West Asia, Centre for Asia Pacific Aviation (CAPA).
“Air India is still an iconic brand, but unfortunately it has a reputation which is of an unreliable and shoddy airline.”
Analysts said minister Patel’s tough line may lead to only cosmetic changes, a sign of the political limits of the reformist zeal of Singh, who was behind 1990s market reforms.
Last year, attempts to cut staff at privately-run Jet Airways met with political opposition and the backtracking of its owners.
Patel said in June there could be an initial public offering in Air India, but said it would not be privatizsed completely.
Congress will likely save Air India without nudging it too far into the private sector, said Swapan Dasgupta, a political analyst linked to the main opposition Bharatiya Janata Party..
“The Congress sees itself as the creator of the public sector. So they have that huge ideological baggage,” he said.
The focus of Singh’s reforms may be on newer sectors, such as insurance, and bypass tougher nuts to crack, such as steel and aviation with its strong, unionised workforce.
“There will be that rust belt in the economy which will continue,” Dasgupta said. “Air India will be part of that rust belt.”
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Thu, Jul 02 2009. 10 58 AM IST