Experts deem GM bankruptcy inevitable

Experts deem GM bankruptcy inevitable
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Tue, May 19 2009. 10 39 AM IST
Updated: Tue, May 19 2009. 10 39 AM IST
Detroit: After 100 years in business and 10 months of frenzied but failed restructuring, General Motors Corp is weeks from the bankruptcy filing experts say will be required to complete the Obama administration’s bid to reshape a fallen icon of American industry.
Facing a government-imposed 1 June deadline to restructure, GM is scrambling to slash some $27 billion of bond debt, win sweeping cost concessions from the United Auto Workers union and eliminate almost 1,600 US dealers.
But with the clock ticking, experts see it as all but certain GM will follow its smaller rival Chrysler into federal bankruptcy court.
“I almost think it is inevitable,” independent auto industry analyst Erich Merkle said. “I don’t know how they are going to escape it.”
The battery of problems to have hit GM range from plunging sales and declining share to a line-up that has seen more misses than hits over the past decade and that trails engineering leaders like Toyota Motor Corp and Honda Motor Co in hybrid technology.
But GM’s debt-laden balance sheet is the source of its immediate crisis and the reason restructuring experts, analysts and auto executives do not see a way forward that avoids what could be a complicated and contentious bankruptcy.
“The only way it is not inevitable is if the government accepts whatever percentage of bondholders have tried to exchange, whether it is 40% or 50% or 60%,” said Peter Kaufman, president and head of restructuring and distressed mergers and acquisitions at the Gordian Group LLC in New York.
GM has said that it must have 90% of the $27 billion of bonds participate in the exchange or it will be forced to file for bankruptcy.
GM’s offer to its bondholders would give them only a 10% equity stake in a reorganized company. Representatives of a committee representing major bondholders have called that offer unfair given the payout being offered to the UAW.
In a sign of how far apart the sides remain, bondholders have sought a majority stake in the new GM, the controlling position in a new and smaller auto company GM has offered to the US Treasury.
After extending $15.4 billion to keep GM afloat since the start of the year, the US Treasury would own at least 50 percent of the automaker under GM’s proposed terms.
A UAW healthcare trust would hold nearly 40% of GM in return for allowing GM to pay $10 billion - half of its remaining funding obligation - in stock, instead of cash.
Chrysler’s case, the sixth-largest US corporate bankruptcy, has been watched from the start by some analysts and administration officials as a dry run for a GM case.
Chrysler, which filed for bankruptcy on 30 April, has won court approval to proceed with a rapid sale of most of its assets to a new company led by Italy’s Fiat SpA, paving the way for its emergence in as little as 60 days.
GM said last week that it would probably follow suit by looking for an equally quick sale of its best assets, but experts caution that its process could be harder.
“GM is a case that is much larger in scale and by virtue of its size it’s more complicated on many different levels,” said Scott Stuart, a partner with Donlin Recano, a claims administrator for bankruptcy cases. “It will be a more traditional reorganization.”
Underscoring the divisions between GM and stakeholders, the UAW on Monday repeated its opposition to a GM restructuring plan that includes closing 16 US plants.
GM’s announcement last week that it planned to drop more than a quarter of its nearly 6,000 US dealers has also triggered an outcry from some of those independent businesses.
Chief Executive Fritz Henderson, who took GM’s top job when his predecessor was fired by the Obama administration’s autos task force, has said it could be possible for GM to complete the bankruptcy process within 60 days.
But Chrysler was helped by having Fiat as a buyer waiting on the other side of its reorganization. It is unclear what entity would buy GM’s assets if U.S. officials run its reorganization by the Chrysler play book, analysts said.
Chrysler’s major secured lenders agreed to cut their claims on $6.9 billion in debt to 29 cents on the dollar. A similar consensus among GM’s major bondholders is seen as unlikely.
GM has warned that its shares could be worth nothing in a bankruptcy filing or less than two cents on the dollar if it presses ahead with an out of court restructuring that would include the issuance of 60 billion new shares.
Shares have dropped 94% over the past year but were up more than 8% on Monday to $1.18.
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Tue, May 19 2009. 10 39 AM IST