How much is Michael Jackson worth in death?
It has been 48 days since Michael Jackson died, and while the family of the late pop star is still at war with the executors of his estate, the answer to that question is becoming clear: The singer has already earned $100 million (Rs481 crore) through a film deal and various merchandising contracts, and the executors expect another $100 million to roll in by the end of the year.
“Clearly that’s a new record for estates that likely will not be broken,” said John G. Branca, Jackson’s longtime lawyer who was named in Jackson’s will as a co-executor of the estate, along with John McClain, a music executive and Jackson family friend.
Living on: The business of Jackson, whose estate is valued at several hundred million dollars, could generate $50-100 million annually. Kevin Mazur/AP
While several business deals have been reached—for things such as commemorative coins, a line of school supplies and a $150 coffee-table book—the matter of untangling Jackson’s vast estate, assets and debt goes on, as does wrangling with family members.
Cash has been collected from former advisers who had held money for Jackson—several million dollars from one—and the executors have tracked down a collection of Jackson’s personal memorabilia and other items that were almost auctioned off last April to pay debts. The items, which included artwork and several glittery white gloves that had been at the singer’s Neverland Ranch, had been stored in several locations around Los Angeles.
The model for Jackson’s posthumous business empire is Elvis Presley. “When you look at what the Presley estate has done, you see the opportunities here,” Branca said. “I quite frankly think this will be a bigger estate.”
Presley’s estate generated $55 million in revenue last year, according to Billboard, the music industry trade publication. In 2004, Robert Sillerman, a New York music entrepreneur, purchased 85% of Elvis Presley Enterprises, the business umbrella for Presley’s intellectual property rights and Graceland, for about $100 million.
Business aside, Branca and McClain—a judge has named them special administrators and could decide in October to name them permanent executors—remain at odds with Katherine Jackson, Jackson’s mother, who is a beneficiary of 40% of the estate. In July, she sought to wrest control of the estate from the executors, but was denied by a judge.
“Both McClain and Branca certainly are aware of our intentions to have Mrs Jackson have a seat at the table, because I believe that her sensibilities with respect to the legacy of Michael bring a very important and valuable dimension to any kind of plans,” said L. Londell McMillan, a lawyer for Katherine Jackson.
Valuable dimension: A view of the train station at Jackson’s Neverland Ranch in Los Olivos, California. Jackson’s estate contains some big assets, including a 50% stake in Sony/ATV, a music publishing partnership that includes the rights to the Beatles catalogue and the Neverland Ranch. Phil Klein/Reuters
More recently, Katherine Jackson and her legal team have sought, in behind-the-scenes negotiations, to have her named as an additional executor or as a co-trustee, a move that Branca and McClain have resisted, partly because they say having a beneficiary also serve as a trustee could result in more taxes being owed.
Instead, a more likely possibility is that one of Katherine Jackson’s other children would be named as a co-executor or co-trustee, according to Branca.
McMillan said of the potential negative tax implications, “that’s not a legal position we support. The research we’ve done allows for tax avoidance with respect to our request.”
While Jackson’s will stipulated that Branca and McClain had authority over running the business affairs of the estate, they are aware that their efforts will be more successful if relations with the Jackson family are collegial. Branca said, “We’ve always been open to a dialogue with Mrs Jackson about what is best for the estate.”
Jackson’s estate has been valued at several hundred million dollars. It contains some big assets, including a 50% stake in Sony/ATV, a music publishing partnership that includes the rights to the Beatles catalogue; Jackson’s own song catalogue; and Neverland Ranch. But there also are large debts, because of Jackson’s free-spending ways. While Jackson’s portion of Sony/ATV was worth an estimated $500 million at the time of his death, he had about $300 million of debt against it held by Barclays. Despite speculation, Branca said, “we do not contemplate selling any portion of Sony/ATV.”
Beyond 2009, Branca and others estimate the business of Michael Jackson could generate $50-100 million annually.
“We are very optimistic about the revenue we will generate,” said Howard Weitzman, an attorney for the estate. “But we also have to be sober about the debt the estate has.”
The overall value of Jackson’s business, were it to be sold in the future as Presley’s was, would most likely be several hundred million dollars, said Mark Roesler, chairman of CMG Worldwide, a licensing firm that has worked with estates of Presley, Marilyn Monroe and James Dean.
“You have someone who left a mark on six billion people in the world,” Roesler said. “If you put a value of $110 million on Elvis Presley’s intellectual property rights, that’s a baseline. It’s certainly in the hundreds of millions of dollars.”
Neverland Ranch itself could become a future moneymaker, just like Elvis Presley’s Graceland. Some family members hope Jackson will be buried there, but that decision has not been made. Neverland is owned in partnership with Colony Capital, a Los Angeles real estate company that stepped in when Jackson was on the brink of foreclosure.
Another idea is to establish a permanent Jackson attraction in Las Vegas, which would house the late singer’s memorabilia. This option may be preferable to Neverland, because Las Vegas is more easily accessible to tourists.
In life, Jackson faced a precarious financial future, as he piled on debts to finance his tastes in art, to travel on private jets and to keep up Neverland. In death, his estate may enjoy the financial security he never had.
Ben Sisario contributed to this story.
©2009/THE NEW YORK TIMES