New Delhi: Within weeks of Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) upholding levy of retrospective tax, the income tax department has slapped a fresh demand note of Rs10,247 crore on British explorer Cairn Energy Plc.
ITAT in its 9 March order held that Cairn Energy was liable to pay tax on the 2006 transfer of India assets to newly created Cairn India, prior to its listing. It, however, held that interest cannot be charged on it as the demand was raised using retrospective tax legislation.
The income tax department had raised a tax demand of Rs10,247 crore and another Rs18,800 crore in interest for 10 years. “Following the ruling of the ITAT, an amended tax demand, received on March 31, 2017, noted that late payment interest would now be charged from February 2016, i.e. from 30 days following the date of the original 2016 final assessment order,” Cairn said in a notice to shareholders.
Cairn said the decision of the ITAT is “potentially subject to appeal.” The company had on 24 January, 2014 received a draft assessment order for the alleged capital gains it made in 2006. The order restrained the company from selling the residual 9.8% stake it holds in Cairn India.
Cairn Energy had in 2011 sold Cairn India to Vedanta. “Then, on February 4, 2016... a final assessment order in respect of the Indian fiscal year ended March 31 2007, (was) issued by the Indian income tax department (IITD) in the amount of Rs10,247 crore plus interest back dated to 2007 totalling Rs18,800 crore,” Cairn said. The final assessment order did not include any penalties which may also be applied to the final assessment (potentially up to 300% of any tax finally agreed).
“The final assessment order was appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi which ruled on March 9, 2017 that tax in the amount of Rs10,247 crore remained payable but that the company could not be required to pay interest,” it said. This is because the tax demand was raised on the basis of a retrospective amendment done to the Income Tax Act in 2012 and Cairn could not have anticipated that payment of tax would be required. Stating that it strongly contests the final assessment order, Cairn said enforcement of any tax liability deemed due by the tax department will be limited to India assets, which had a value of about $750 million as of 31 December, 2016. These assets comprised principally Cairn’s residual shareholding in Cairn India.
Cairn said it had on 11 March, 2015 filed a notice of dispute under The UK-India investment treaty in order to protect its legal position and shareholder interests. “The international arbitration proceedings formally commenced in January 2016 following the agreement between Cairn and the government of India on the appointment of a panel of three international arbitrators under the terms of the Treaty,” it said.
“However, supported by detailed legal advice on the strength of the legal protections available to it under international law, Cairn strongly contests the actions of the IITD in these matters. “In addition to the resolution of the tax dispute, Cairn also seeks full recompense for the loss of value resulting from the restriction on its Cairn India shares,” the notice added.