We can’t seem to have enough of glass. It has become the symbol of modernity. And with good reason too. It is a versatile industrial material, lets in light through windows, lets us see through (or not, depending on whether it is translucent) and makes for shiny, clean surfaces and building forms.
For many people, especially in the corporate world, it is also a symbol of functionalism. The most common argument offered in its favour in this regard is that it allows natural light into interior spaces during the day. This saves energy and money by reducing electricity consumption.
But does it actually work that way? Is the glass curtain-wall (a continuous curtain of framed or connected glass sheets fixed to the structural frame) more about style than about saving money or the environment?
Most importantly, what portion of buildings—even in “developed” countries with cold climates, such as the US—actually use glass in a way that maximizes benefits and minimizes costs?
“A very, very small portion,” says Prasad Vaidya, an architect and energy analyst with The Weidt Group in Berkeley, California, who advises building professionals on energy matters.
As a broad rule of thumb, Vaidya suggests that the proportion of glass areas in windows must be kept between 12 to 25% of the total floor area in the US, so that interior spaces do not get overheated.
If that is ideal in the much-colder US, what’s with all the full glass towers in scorching Gurgaon (or Hyderabad)?
Glass and climate
Climate is important when thinking of glass in buildings. Glass is valuable in buildings fundamentally for its transparency, which lets in natural light. Hence its regular use in windowpanes.
But glass also lets in heat along with the light. And it allows only light to reflect back, trapping the heat inside.
Fixed glazing (or fixed panels of glass, as in picture windows in homes, or the large curtain walls on commercial buildings) on building exteriors thus helps create a greenhouse effect. When the curtain wall faces the west, it lets in the hottest sunlight of the day and turns the interior space into an oven. Of course, the simplest solution is to open the window. But windows clutter the smooth look of the curtain wall, and for that reason are not enthusiastically provided by architects.
In the heat of India, this means that the air conditioning works harder and costs more in terms of installation and electricity bills (while also emitting ozone-depleting chemicals such as chlorofluorocarbons). Of course, the more conspicuous the consumption, the more status it buys. A glass tower broadcasts the ability of the owner-occupier to pay for all this.
Reflection of modernity
But it is not only about power. With the curtain glazing being thin, it allows developers the extra floor space that omitting the external wall creates. Also, it is quicker to assemble than the age-old plastered brick wall, though aluminium composite panels (ACPs) offer competition to curtain glazing on this front.
Some architects may also be in thrall of glass for visual (and historical) reasons alone. Along with concrete, glass was a wonder material for early 20th century modernist European architects. Design leaders such as Le Corbusier (who later designed Chandigarh) and Mies van der Rohe were trying to create a new language for European architecture that expressed the high level of industrialization Western societies had achieved. Out with the heavy, overwrought architecture of stone and brick, they said. And in with white walls, unornamented “forms” (that is, three-dimensional shapes) and industrial materials such as concrete, steel and glass.
That language was disseminated all over the world, including India. And glass went on to tighten its grip on the imagination of architects as industry developed products that mitigated its heat absorption and insulation problems. A building wrapped in glass is easier to make attractive to the popular imagination than one in which different materials have to be balanced visually.
Like fire, glass works excellently if used well. The Gurgaon headquarters of Apollo Tyres, designed by Morphogenesis Architecture Studio, has “finger-like” indoor spaces alternating with enclosed open spaces, which let reflected daylight into the interiors. The reflected light is relatively glare-free and much cooler. The floor-to-ceiling glass is designed to let this light into the workspace and reduce electricity consumption to a very large degree.
Building plans can also be sensitively organized so the spaces receiving daylight through windows or curtain glazing are oriented correctly to reduce direct heat gain and let in the maximum amount of daylight.
It is also possible to provide sunscreening devices outside the glazed surface so that the hottest sun is screened off. After all, the path of the sun is fixed—and so is the angle of the building in relation to it.
To glaze or not to glaze
It all boils down to knowing why glass is being used in a building. If you want to show off, or if you are simply infatuated with glass, not only you, but the entire planet, pays a big price. Glass has a very high embodied energy—the energy that goes into making, transporting and fixing it. The embodied energy of framing materials (aluminium, for instance) is also high. Most of this energy comes from non-renewable sources.
Glass is also an expensive material, and gets more so when you choose to use double or triple glazing products, and those with various reflective coatings. The costs only mount when you consider maintenance.
But used in the right doses, and in the correct place, glass does have the potential to be the bright choice. Of course, that requires commitment, knowledge and time on the design board for all those concerned with building. Do we have enough of all this to use glass with intelligence and responsibility?
Write to us at firstname.lastname@example.org
The PVR Phoenix multiplex in Mumbai’s Phoenix Mills—designed by Jestico & Whiles in association with Era Architects— claims to be the city’s largest, with seven screens and 1847 seats. What interests us is the look of the place, which seems to have supplemented the usual PVR accoutrements with quirkier elements. Its screening halls, foyer and café lounge feature deep leather panelling and plush red furnishing—but these are common for a multiplex these days. More riveting is the ‘dewdrop effect’ ceiling in the foyer, with spheroids seeming to melt off the plaster; or the movie art plastering the wall along which the elevators open. Staff Writer
From Asterix and Obelix to brooding comic-book hero Largo Winch, the French have long adored their cartoon heroes. Now the visual world of comics is being embraced for the first time by Paris’ Louvre museum. The exhibition, ‘Small Design: The Louvre invites Comics’, opened on 22 January and will display comic strips by five authors. ‘Glacial Period’ by Nicolas de Crecy, Marc-Antoine Mathieu’s ‘The Basement of the Louvre’ and Eric Liberge’s ‘Odd Hours’ have been completed, with the fourth set for release in May. AP
With 497 days to go before South Africa hosts the 2010 World Cup soccer tournament, engineers at Durban’s Moses Mabhida 2010 soccer stadium fit the final piece to the 350m-long arch over the stadium on 16 January. The arch, consisting of 56 separate 10m pieces, stands 106m high, weighs 3,500 tonnes and is symbolic of the South African flag. The last piece fitted weighed 60 tonnes and the arch pieces had to be opened 5cm on either side to accommodate the final section. The arch will provide critical support to the stadium roof, which consists of Teflon-coated glass fibre membranes. AP
Ng Chee Leong from Singapore attacked a squid-topped octopus tentacle with a hair dryer and a bunch of ribbons. John Qi, a member of the Chinese team, torched some Nemo lookalikes to an aquamarine sugar wave. Just desserts, these, at the World Pastry Cup in Lyon, France, held over 25-26 January. Twenty-two countries participated in the contest that is now 20 years old. Staff Writer