×
Home Companies Industry Politics Money Opinion LoungeMultimedia Science Education Sports TechnologyConsumerSpecialsMint on Sunday
×

Voices with vision

Voices with vision
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Fri, Dec 25 2009. 09 49 PM IST

Updated: Fri, Dec 25 2009. 09 49 PM IST
The Panel
Jeet Thayil is a Mumbai-based poet who edited ‘60 Indian Poets’, an acclaimed anthology of Indian poetry. He is also a literary critic and is currently at work on his first novel.
Soumya Bhattacharya is the author of a memoir, ‘You Must Like Cricket?’. His novel, ‘If I Could Tell You’, has just come out. He is editor of the Mumbai edition of the ‘Hindustan Times’.
Sanjay Sipahimalani is an executive creative director with Bates 141 Mumbai, and has reviewed books for the ‘Hindustan Times’, ‘The Indian Express’ and ‘Biblio’.
Chandrahas Choudhury has been the ‘Lounge’ book critic ever since the magazine’s first issue. His first novel, ‘Arzee the Dwarf’, came out this year to rave reviews.
*********
FICTION / POETRY
Half a Life
by V.S. Naipaul (2001)
One objection to Naipaul’s writing has always been that he skips things a novelist should not. It’s almost as if he’s bored of doing the David Copperfield kind of novel, and skips entire swathes of his character’s life. Even then, Half a Life is unputdownable. It brings up timeless subjects as well as Naipaul’s old obsessions; it’s the late work of a master. Naipaul is revered for his craft, he is a writer’s writer, and yet he is not a difficult writer to read.
Listen to the weekly Lounge podcast where we bring you a special behind- the- scenes edition of the Lounge decade-ender issue that hits the stands on 26 December, 2009.
Kala Ghoda Poems
by Arun Kolatkar (2004)
Kolatkar’s Jejuri has just been issued by the New York Review of Books Classics and he is likely to end up being the face of Indian poetry, whether that’s deserved or not. His works have been translated into several European languages and he’s had an incredible impact. Even if you were to read Kala Ghoda Poems in vacuum, as a book of poetry about a city, it has few parallels.
The Oxford India
Ramanujan
by Oxford University Press (2004)
Running to 200 odd pages, this volume is the distillation of a life’s work. A.K. Ramanujan received the McCarthy Award when he was in his 30s, and deservedly so. The poem The Black Hen that his wife rescued from his computer has 13 short lines, which allude to death and the fear of creative juices drying up. A scholar can easily write a chapter on the poem—it has all the allusions and mythological references. But that doesn’t take away anything from the pleasure of reading it. All of Ramanujan’s poetry has that beauty.
Salman Rushdie. AFP
Shalimar the Clown
by Salman Rushdie (2005)
After a string of indifferent novels, people wondered whether Rushdie’s talent had deserted him. He proved them wrong with Shalimar the Clown. In the sections on Kashmir, he went back to what made him a writer in the first place. It has become fashionable to say that the new Rushdie novel is bad, but his not-so-good also deserves to be in a “best of the decade” list.
Sacred Games
by Vikram Chandra (2006)
The breadth of ambition, the high-flown, lyrical English, yet a narrative grounded in the sediments of Hindi—there are many Hindi swear words—make Sacred Games a great book. Despite the bulk (900 pages), it is insanely readable. With some very memorable passages which one can revisit, the book aspires to be the great Bombay novel. It is also a subversion of the concept of the traditional crime novel; and yet it is a serious crime novel.
Red
by Allan Sealy (2006)
Sealy is an underrated writer even though his corpus is amazing—from Trotter-Nama to Everest Hotel, he has written many kinds of books. Written in an unabashedly literary style, Red is a particularly clever and brave work that can be read as art history and literature.
The Inheritance of Loss
by Kiran Desai (2006)
The remarkable attention to detail and the language make Desai’s second novel a great work. She explores the tension between the aspirational middle class and some of the big themes about India.
Jhumpa Lahiri. Photo courtesy Random House India Unaccustomed Earth: Jhumpa Lahiri, Random House, 352 pages, Rs450.
Unaccustomed Earth
by Jhumpa Lahiri (2008)
Lahiri’s last book qualifies because of its lyricism and attention to detail. In her understated fashion she looks at the minutiae of life, her fiction reminding you that a coaster or a table mat can be as important as Rushdie’s Saleem Sinai. Here she has perfected the craft of writing about the American Bengali milieu; you almost admire her for her stubborn refusal to leave home.
Between the Assassinations
by Aravind Adiga (2008)
In his second published book, which was written before the Booker-winning The White Tiger, Adiga doesn’t take short cuts. The short stories here have persuasive characters and a reader needs to work harder to get to the heart of the book. There is great attention to detail and there is a poise about the writing. There is also a corrosive rage and an unbuttoned-ness that shows Adiga’s comfort level with nasty characters. That is a useful quality to have when writing fiction about India.
Six Acres and a Third
by Fakir Mohan Senapati (in translation, 2005)
The original in Oriya was written about 100 years ago and then revived in this decade. The work should be read for its beauty of technique. Few novels speak in the first person plural and by doing this, the book instantly aligns with the village that it is set in. While Senapati has an eye on colonial rule, his work is not just an indictment of colonialism. It also looks inward at some of the things that bind the people of the village. His style is an offshoot of the Victorian novel.
Non-fiction:
Bihar is in the Eye of the Beholder
by Vijay Nambisan (2000)
Nambisan takes a subject like Bihar and manages to avoid all the cliches—of both technique and content. The book is about him and his wife living in a Bihar village, and in that tiny canvas, he brings in big things such as crime and politics. There are beautiful line drawings throughout that he has done himself, and the language is that of a poet.
Urban splendour: Mumbai is the backdrop of some of the best books since 2000. Kunal Patil / Hindustan Times
Maximum City: Bombay lost and Found
by Suketu Mehta (2004)
For a panoramic look at Mumbai, it’s hard to think of any previous work that has equalled this effort. It has ambition, a tremendous structure, and a great set of real characters reminiscent of Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood.
The Imam and the Indian
by Amitav Ghosh (2002)
A great book because of its breadth and depth, The Imam displays a kind of critical renaissance thinking on subjects as diverse as the Baburnama, the poet Aga Shahid Ali, and books from Ghosh’s grandfather’s shelf. He is a better non-fiction writer.
Step Across This Line
by Salman Rushdie (2003)
An inquisitive mind takes on the great books of the world. In this collection of essays, Rushdie also talks about subjects such as fundamentalism and a U2 concert. The work provides an insight into one of the great public intellectuals of our time. And, through this book, you can also get close to Rushdie—for the first time he writes about his personal reaction to the fatwa.
An End to Suffering: The Buddha in the World
by Pankaj Mishra (2004)
Commonly known as “the Buddha book”, it spans genres — memoir, travel writing, history and philosophy. It also has some very original thinking. Mishra manages to connect disparate subjects and makes the connections convincing. It is sad that he doesn’t have the cachet in India that he deserves.
Amartya Sen. Subhendu Ghosh/Hindustan Times
The Argumentative Indian
by Amartya Sen (2006)
One of the reasons you read Sen is that he is a gateway to other authors. He has rigour and doesn’t take short cuts. The style is his own; his is a gentle voice that never knocks you out with a point, and yet is persuasive. The book also displays a great depth of engagement with his subjects. The title is an invitation to a new kind of Indianness.
India After Gandhi
by Ramachandra Guha (2007)
It’s not easy to capture 60 years of history in a single volume. Unlike many books in this genre, this doesn’t have an ideological slant; everyone can find points of agreement with Guha. It’s a great one-stop history text about India the way it is today. Guha is also a polished stylist and the reader doesn’t get bogged down by details here.
Mohandas: A True Story of a Man, his People and an Empire
by Rajmohan Gandhi (2007)
Biographies of the most famous Indian abound, but this one is epic in its scope. Written by the Mahatma’s grandson in a fluid, beautiful style, this volume is a resource on Gandhi for the young, and one of the most thrilling stories on Indian politics.
The Ugliness of the Indian Male and Other Propositions
by Mukul Kesavan (2008)
Kesavan is the kind of essayist who can string together a series of striking thoughts in sparking prose, which is cerebral yet easy to read. He visits many territories in this book and it’s a joy to read.
Curfewed Night
by Basharat Peer (2008)
Peer has humanized the Kashmir conflict in this very consciously and beautifully crafted memoir. Although he is an insider, he does not let his emotions come in the way of his style. This is the first real look from the inside at the tangled situation in Kashmir and it is difficult to read it without feeling the state’s — and Peer’s — pain.
*********
The Process
(Left to right) Maximum City: Bombay Lost and Found: Suketu Mehta, Penguin, 600 pages, Rs399. Half a Life: V.S. Naipaul, Picador, 226 pages, Rs225. Sacred Games: Vikram Chandra, Penguin, 968 pages, Rs495.
A longlist of 40 odd books, the compilation of our panellist’s individual lists, got us started on the books panel discussion at Taj Lands End, Bandra, Mumbai. Some choices were unanimous: Vikram Chandra’s staggering Bombay crime novel, Sacred Games; the other great Bombay book, Suketu Mehta’s Maximum City; a collection of Arun Kolatkar’s best poetry, Kala Ghoda Poems; and Ramachandra Guha’s acute examination of contemporary India, India After Gandhi.
The collective buzz of dinner conversations around us faded as the panellists scrutinized the list and made passionate cases for and against some of the titles. Poet Jeet Thayil’s choice of the collected works of A.K. Ramanujan in translation aroused curiosity because none of the others on the panel had read it. Kiran Desai’s The Inheritance of Loss didn’t find favour with three panellists, yet it made it to the list.
Uniquely for this list, each vote didn’t matter as much as the case made out for a title. Among the questions thrown up during the conversation: Is Amitav Ghosh a better writer of non-fiction than fiction? Yes, said three panellists. Why is Arundhati Roy an important writer although she is primarily a polemicist? It is her iconic cultural status, said Soumya Bhattacharya.
The idea behind this list, as with the other lists in the issue, is to recommend to our readers titles they might have missed out on. The panellists consciously arrived at a selection that is inclusive—there is poetry, translated works, and books by young writers as well as the masters.
Sanjukta Sharma
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Fri, Dec 25 2009. 09 49 PM IST
More Topics: Books | Fiction | Poetry | Amartya Sen | VS Naipaul |