×
Home Companies Industry Politics Money Opinion LoungeMultimedia Science Education Sports TechnologyConsumerSpecialsMint on Sunday
×

The doctor’s hands are germ-free. But what about the scrubs?

The doctor’s hands are germ-free. But what about the scrubs?
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Wed, Nov 12 2008. 11 09 PM IST

Updated: Wed, Nov 12 2008. 11 09 PM IST
Amid growing concerns about hospital infections and a rise in drug-resistant bacteria, the attire of doctors, nurses and other health care workers—worn both inside and outside the hospital—is getting more attention. While infection control experts have published extensive research on the benefits of hand-washing and equipment sterilization in hospitals, little is known about the role that ties, white coats, long sleeves and soiled scrubs play in the spread of bacteria.
Dress code
The discussion was reignited this year when the British National Health Service imposed a “bare below the elbows” rule, barring doctors from wearing ties and long sleeves, both of which are known to accumulate germs as doctors move from patient to patient. In the US, hospitals generally require doctors to wear “professional” dress but have no specific edicts about ties and long sleeves.
But while some data suggest that doctors’ garments are crawling with germs, there’s no evidence that clothing plays a role in the spread of hospital infections. And some researchers report that patients have less confidence in a doctor whose attire is casual.
Last month, the medical journal BJU International cited the lack of data in questioning the validity of the new British dress code. Still, experts say the absence of evidence doesn’t mean there is no risk—it just means there is no good research. A handful of reports do suggest that the clothing of health workers can be a reservoir for germs.
In 2004, a study from the New York Hospital Medical Center of Queens compared the ties of 40 doctors and medical students with those of 10 security guards.
It found that about half the ties worn by medical personnel were a reservoir for germs, compared with just one in 10 of the ties taken from the security guards. The doctors’ ties harboured several pathogens, including those that can lead to staph infections or pneumonia.
Another study at a Connecticut hospital sought to gauge the role clothing plays in the spread of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). It found that if a worker entered the room where the patient had MRSA, the bacteria would end up on the worker’s clothes about 70% of the time, even if the person never actually touched the patient.
“We know it can live for long periods of time on fabrics,” says Marcia Patrick, an infection control expert in Tacoma, Washington, and co-author of the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology guidelines for eliminating MRSA in hospitals.
Hospital rules typically encourage workers to change soiled scrubs before leaving, but infection control experts say enforcement can be lax. Doctors and nurses can often be seen wearing scrubs on subways and in grocery stores.
Patrick, director of infection prevention and control for the MultiCare Health System in Tacoma, says it’s unlikely that brief contact with a scrub-wearing health care worker on the subway would lead to infection. “The likelihood is that the risk is low, but it’s also probably not zero,” she says.
Hygiene costs
While the role of clothing in the spread of infection hasn’t been well-studied, some hospitals in Denmark and other European countries have adopted wide-ranging infection-control practices that include provisions for the clothing that health care workers wear both in and out of the hospital.
Workers of both sexes must change into hospital-provided scrubs when they arrive at work and even wear sanitized plastic shoes, also provided by the hospital. At the end of the day, they change back into their street clothes to go home. The focus on hand-washing, sterilization, screening and clothing control appears to have worked: In Denmark, fewer than 1% of staph infections involve resistant strains of the bacteria; in the US, the numbers have surged to 50% in some hospitals.
But American hospitals operate on tight budgets and can’t afford to provide clothes and shoes to every worker. In addition, many hospitals don’t have the extra space for laundry facilities.
Ann Marie Pettis, director of infection prevention for the University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, says most hospitals are focusing on hand-washing and equipment sterilization, which are proven methods known to reduce the spread of infection. But she adds that her hospital, like many others, has a policy against wearing scrub attire to and from work, even though there is no real evidence that dirty scrubs pose a risk to people in the community.
“Common sense tells us that the things we are wearing as health care providers should be freshly laundered,” says Pettis. After all, she adds, wearing scrubs in public “raises fear” among consumers. “I don’t think we should feed into that. Scrubs shouldn’t be worn out and about.”
©2008/THE NEW YORK TIMES
Write to us at businessoflife@livemint.com
***************
Alert
Cancer drugs are given in unapproved ways as often as a third of the time. Unapproved, or off-label, use is frequent when regulatory agencies such as the European medicines agency or US food and drug administration have cleared a product for a specific treatment, says a review of studies from the US, UK, France and Australia, published in ‘Lancet Oncology’. Adults took the drugs mainly to relieve symptoms. In many cases, children were given medicines cleared only for adults. While off-label prescribing is permitted, it raises the risk of side effects. Bladder cancer saw 38% off-label use; prostate cancer, 58%. Bloomberg
Do
The traditional Chinese form of exercise known as ‘tai chi’ can help reduce pain and physical impairment in people who have knee arthritis. In a study led by Chenchen Wang of Tufts Medical Center, Boston, US, one group of people in their 60s, with severe knee osteoarthritis, performed ‘tai chi’ for 1 hour, twice a week, for 12 weeks; another group did conventional stretching exercises. Those who did ‘tai chi’ experienced greater pain reduction, less depression and improvement in physical function and overall health, the researchers reported. The Arthritis Foundation advocacy group already recommends it for improving the quality of life for people with arthritis. Reuters
Know
Osteoporosis, the bone-wasting disease that affects one in three women and one in five men above 50, is growing rapidly in Asia as higher incomes spur longer, less active lives and more unhealthy diets. Almost 100 million people suffer from the disease in China alone, Daniel Navid, outgoing chief executive officer of the international osteoporosis foundation, says. That’s about 10 times the number of sufferers in the US, according to the US National Osteoporosis Foundation. The number of osteoporosis sufferers in Asia will probably overtake those in Europe and the US “in the very near future”, says Navid. Bloomberg
Prevent
Patients treated for heart failure were four times as likely to have a fracture in the next year as those with other heart conditions (such as heart attack or chest pain), says a Canadian study in the journal ‘Circulation’. Heart failure patients were six times as likely as others to sustain a hip fracture. Lead researcher Justin Ezekowitz, director, Heart Function Clinic, University of Alberta, says these patients may not be getting enough calcium or vitamin D, or may be more frail overall. Heart failure can lower bone density and quality, he added. “From a clinical perspective, I think we can really turn around and immediately start making sure our patients are adequately screened for osteoporosis,” says Dr Ezekowitz. Reuters
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Wed, Nov 12 2008. 11 09 PM IST
More Topics: Doctor | Scrubs | Hospital | Infections | Health Care |