What a difference three months makes. The September quarter results of US-based Novelis Inc., a subsidiary of Hindalco Industries Ltd, are a marked change from those of the previous quarter in more ways than one. A pre-tax profit of $62 million (about Rs299 crore) in the June quarter has given way to a pre-tax loss of $272 million in the September quarter. (In the September 2007 quarter, the company posted a pre-tax profit of $1 million).
Even more importantly, while announcing the company’s results for the June quarter in August, the company’s president and chief operating officer Martha Finn Brooks had said: “I am encouraged by the continued strength in demand for our products, particularly can stock, which is growing well in a number of markets.” Three months later, this is what she had to say: “The demand outlook is highly uncertain in at least three of our four regions. As needed, we will take suitable actions to adjust our production levels and otherwise appropriately manage our business.” While she said that lower metal prices in future would be good for the company, the demand slowdown is clearly what’s weighing on her mind.
In volume terms, shipments of rolled products rose by 1.6% in the September quarter compared with the year-ago period. That’s down only slightly from the 2.9% y-o-y volume growth in the June quarter. But growth in net sales halved from around 10% y-o-y in the June quarter to around 5% in the September quarter. The management has said the rise in input costs during the quarter was a challenge and it’s true that the cost of goods sold rose to 94% of net sales in the September quarter compared with 91% in the June quarter. But the real reason for the loss was the $185 million loss on derivative instruments.
As on 30 September 2008, the company’s total outside liabilities (debt and other current liabilities) amounted to a high 1.6 times its net orth. Net cash from operating activities was, however, negative to the tune of $390 million in the quarter. The management has said that with aluminium prices declining, its free cash flow position will improve.
Analysts have in any case been negative on the Hindalco stock, because they expect global aluminium consumption to fall sharply. The company’s extended balance sheet on account of the Novelis acquisition and its other capex plans are the other reasons for analysts’ negative sentiments. According to a Citigroup research note, “Novelis sells 70% of its volumes in the US and Europe and could be adversely impacted by the expected demand slowdown in these markets... Given the declining price scenario that we expect, there is likely to be an adverse impact on Novelis earnings.”
Nobody expects Novelis to start contributing meaningfully to Hindalco’s EPS before FY11, but its September results will add to the negative sentiment.