A focus on one China debt metric risks missing the point

China’s credit-to-gross domestic product ‘gap’ is now at 30.1%, the highest in figures stretching back to 1995


Photo: Bloomberg
Photo: Bloomberg

Hong Kong: China has a bad-debt problem, that’s for sure. But is it really as dire as everyone makes out?

Data released by the Basel-based Bank for International Settlements over the weekend show a key warning indicator for banking stress rose to a record in the first quarter. The nation’s credit-to-gross domestic product “gap” is now at 30.1%, the highest in figures stretching back to 1995.

Naturally, a flurry of alarming headlines followed, and yes, China’s $26 trillion pile of public and private debt does present a threat to the global economy. Total borrowing soared to an estimated 247% of GDP at the end of 2015, from 164% in 2008, faster than the increase in the US and UK in the run-up to the 2008 financial crisis.

The BIS indicates a credit-to-GDP gap reading north of 10% signals an elevated risk of banking strain, but to take such a number in isolation would be misleading.

Authorities in Beijing have been making inroads in helping troubled state-owned enterprises restructure their debt, along with providing additional credit lines and lowering interest rates. According to an analysis of 765 banks by UBS, efforts to clean up the country’s debt-ridden financial system are well underway, while a shift in the sort of loans in China’s banking system has staved off any day of reckoning.

As Bloomberg Intelligence chief Asia economist Tom Orlik notes, total outstanding credit was up 11.2% year-on-year in August, slowing from a peak of 12.5% in March. Within that, though, there’s been a marked rotation from corporate to household loans, with the former up just 10%, versus a 21% expansion in loans to households. And in China at least, mortgage loans are much safer for banks because they generally require large down payments. Such advances are also seen as less risky because they’re typically secured by property.

A quick look back through the BIS data also shows that China isn’t necessarily the offender it might seem. Hong Kong is no stranger to really big gaps between credit and GDP, either. Its current 18.1% reading may look relatively benign but in the second quarter of 2015, it was as high as 41.3% and touched 46.1% in the first quarter of that year. Super-safe Singapore has a gap of 14.8%, down from 22.6% in 2013.

Of course, in China, a significant real-estate slump could prove banks’ undoing. But so far, home prices remain elevated, with increases in 64 cities in August compared with 51 in July suggesting local government attempts to cool the market are having limited impact. Besides, even when China’s property bubble did burst a few years back, banks were okay.

To argue everything is fine and dandy when it comes to debt and China would be foolish. But getting overexcited about one credit metric isn’t sensible either. Bloomberg

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Bloomberg LP and its owners.

READ MORE