Five charts on the case for an RBI rate cut
- Tata Communications’s 15-year wait to spin off land assets nears end
- Parliament winter session: YSRCP to raise special category status for Andhra Pradesh
- Gujarat elections 2017: Pakistan tells India ‘don’t drag us into your domestic politics’
- Gujarat elections 2017 LIVE: Modi, Rahul Gandhi back on campaign trail
- Supreme Court to hear Unitech plea against NCLT order tomorrow
Should the policy rate be cut? What does history tell us? Here are five charts that consider the case for a rate cut:
CHART 1: The chart plots the Wholesale Price Index (WPI) with the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) repo rate from January 2009. Note that when the wholesale price inflation had last slipped into negative territory—in June and July 2009—the repo rate was a mere 4.75%. In sharp contrast, with wholesale inflation negative at present, the repo rate is at 7.5%. If RBI had continued to follow wholesale price inflation, the contrast between 2009 and now would be glaring. But then, it has long given up using the metric to determine its policy stance.
CHART 2: The chart looks at inflation measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for industrial workers, or CPI (IW), against the repo rate. The new CPI hasn’t been taken because it doesn’t go back all the way to 2009. The chart shows that the repo rate was much lower and inflation according to the CPI (IW) much higher in 2009. On the other hand, with inflation slowing in late 2011 and early 2012, the repo rate was a high 8.5%. In general, though, we can say that while consumer price inflation for industrial workers has fallen quite a bit since December 2013, the repo rate has not.
CHART 3: The chart shows the relationship between industrial growth and the repo rate. The repo rate was very low in early 2009, when industrial production contracted sharply in the aftermath of the Lehman crisis. Note that when industrial production growth was falling in 2010 and 2011, the repo rate was rising. But the argument would perhaps be that the central bank had its hands full containing inflation and didn’t give much attention to growth. In spite of very weak industrial growth, the repo rate has hardly moved.
CHART 4: The chart compares the current consumer price inflation in various countries with their central bank policy rates. With inflation at 4.9% and the repo rate at 7.5%, that gives a real policy rate of 260 basis points (bps). The Reserve Bank governor has said his aim is to keep the policy rate at 150-200 bps. Note that India’s real policy rate is now higher than that of most countries. One basis point is one-hundredth of a percentage point.
CHART 5: A decent real interest rate is also needed for savers. The chart looks at the annual average inflation computed by the CPI(IW) and the interest rate payable on bank term deposits of 1-3 years tenor. The lowest rate of five major banks has been taken, except for the current rate, which is that of State Bank of India’s one-year term deposit. The chart shows that real interest rates were negative from 2008 to 2011 and again from 2012 to 2014. Today’s real interest rate, at 1.7%, is higher than in most years except during 2000-02, when they were even higher.
Manas Chakravarty looks at trends and issues in the financial markets. Your comments are welcome at firstname.lastname@example.org