Home Companies Industry Politics Money Opinion LoungeMultimedia Science Education Sports TechnologyConsumerSpecialsMint on Sunday

Ask Mint | Fiscal stimulus: it’s all about timing

Ask Mint | Fiscal stimulus: it’s all about timing
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Sun, Jun 01 2008. 11 26 PM IST

Updated: Sun, Jun 01 2008. 11 26 PM IST
Recession is the best time for some people to go on a vacation. They simply pack their bags and head for the South Pole. They assume that by the time they will come back, things will be back to normal. But for the saviours of the world economy, recession is the time to work overtime. They test all their formulas to get the economy back on its feet. Interest rates, fiscal stimulus, grand speeches, use
whatever else comes handy. Some of these will work and some will not. But time, as South Pole vacationers claim, always takes good care of every problem.
Johnny: Hello, Jinny. I see that today you are here with bag and baggage. Are you heading for some trip?
Jinny: No trip right now. But I may soon go if the fiscal stimulus package fails to stop recession in the world economy.
Johnny: Fiscal stimulus package? How can it stop recession?
Jinny: Well, you may have heard the name of John Maynard Keynes, the well-known British economist of the 20th century. The whole idea of fiscal stimulus is based on his analysis of factors that cause recession. Keynes always looked for new answers to old questions. During the Great Depression of the 1930s, he wrote his seminal work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money.
Keynes focused his analysis on factors affecting output and growth in an economy. He asked, what decides the output in an economy?
This could be answered in many ways. You can say that some invisible force gets up in the night and decides how much we should produce.
Illustration: Jayachandran / Mint
But Keynes gave a more convincing and simple answer. He said that output in any economy is decided by people who spend money. People like you and me who earn money with one hand and spend it with the other ultimately decide how much goods and services are going to be produced in our economy.
Keynes explained how fluctuation in spending or aggregate demand may lead to short-term fluctuations in output and employment. His entire analysis is based on the assumption that firms try to meet the demand for goods and services at the preset price by cutting the supply.
Johnny: How does meeting the demand at the preset price work?
Jinny: If the demand of a product is less, then by the simple logic of demand and supply, the price of that product should fall. But it is difficult for firms to vary the price of their products frequently. Your baker may have to change the price of his bread every day if he goes strictly by demand and supply.
Changing the price of goods every day is not a very happy way of doing business. Neither the baker nor his customers would be happy if prices just kept on changing forever.
Further, the input cost of flour that the baker uses for baking cakes may not remain the same, making it difficult for him to recover even his cost of production if he sells below a certain price.
What options, then, does the baker have? He can let the price of the bread remain the same and curtail his production in response to lower demand. He meets the demand at the preset price by matching his supply with the demand. This is how demand affects output and growth in our economy.
Johnny: How can we use this understanding to fight recession?
Jinny: As per Keynesian analysis, the problem of recession is not due to lack of productive capacity in the economy. The factories have not lost their ability to produce goods, the real problem is due to insufficient spending to support the normal level of production.
So, the solution is obvious. If the fall in demand leads to fall in production, then we need to do something that can push up demand.
What can we do for that? We have two options. The first option, as recommended by Keynes, is to increase government spending, which works as the most effective way of increasing the aggregate demand of goods and services.
The second option is to increase the disposable income in the hands of people by cutting taxes. Put money in the hands of people and even the most pessimistic person starts making new plans.
It is believed that people will use part of their extra income on consuming extra goods and services. This creates what is known as a multiplier effect.
You buy the bread of the baker, your baker in turn buys milk, and the milkman buys something else — in this manner, the game of passing the penny keeps going.
Fiscal stimulus works as an instant source of energy.
However, the timing of a fiscal stimulus and its size is most crucial for its success.
It is very difficult to pinpoint exactly the beginning and end of a recession, making it more difficult to time the stimulus package.
Wrong timing could make things worse by increasing fiscal deficit and inflation.
Johnny: That’s true, Jinny. Wrong timing can make the solution part of the problem.
What:Fiscal stimulus can be used as a tool for fighting recession.
How: Increase in government spending coupled with tax cuts can lead to increase in aggregate demand and growth in the economy.
Who: John Maynard Keynes, the well-known British economist, was a prominent advocate of the use of fiscal stimulus.
Shailaja and Manoj K. Singh have important day jobs with an important bank. But Jinny and Johnny have plenty of time for your suggestions and ideas for their weekly chat. You can write to both of them at realsimple@livemint.com
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Sun, Jun 01 2008. 11 26 PM IST