Brussels: Euro zone leaders agreed on a second rescue package for debt-stricken Greece that risks triggering a temporary default and will give their financial rescue fund broader powers to try to prevent market instability spreading through the region.
An emergency summit of leaders of the 17-nation currency area on Thursday pledged to conduct a second bailout of Greece with an extra €109 billion ($157 billion) of government money, plus a contribution by private sector bondholders estimated to total as much as €50 billion by mid-2014.
The leaders also made detailed provisions for limiting the damage if, as seems likely, credit rating agencies declare Greece to be in temporary default -- the first such event in the 12-year history of the euro.
The package boosted stocks and the euro because it suggested for the first time since the Greek debt crisis erupted early last year that the euro zone was taking a comprehensive, long-term approach to the problem, rather than simply lending Greece more money to avoid disaster in the near term.
“We have thus sent a clear signal to the markets by showing our determination to stem the crisis and turn the tide in Greece, thereby securing the future of the savings, pensions and jobs of our citizens all over Europe,” Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte said after eight hours of talks.
But some of the details remained sketchy and doubts lingered about whether the plan went far enough to assure not only Greece’s debt sustainability but that of Ireland, Portugal and other debt-burdened nations.
The package yielded “more than expected but not enough to make us sleep comfortably”, Barclays economists said. They were disappointed that European leaders did not agree to expand a euro zone rescue fund.
If market conditions deteriorate and a larger European economy -- Italy, for example -- struggles to shoulder its debt burden, the rescue fund could be quickly wiped out.
French President Nicolas Sarkozy said measures agreed at the summit, the fifth this year on the crisis, would together reduce Greece’s debt by 24 percentage points of gross domestic product from about 150% today.
Greek Prime Minister George Papandreou said the deal would cover his country’s funding needs until 2020 and make its debt sustainable, but analysts questioned whether the reduction would be enough to avoid a restructuring in the medium term.
The second bailout of Greece, details of which are likely to be set formally in September, will supplement a €110 billion rescue plan for the country launched by the European Union and the International Monetary Fund in May last year.
Among other steps, the leaders agreed on Thursday to ease terms on bailout loans to Greece, Ireland and Portugal; maturities will be extended to 15 years from 7.5 and interest cut to around 3.5% from 4.5-5.8% now.
Banks and insurers will voluntarily swap their Greek bonds for longer maturities at lower interest rates to help Athens.
Acknowledging that the swap scheme may lead to Greece being declared in selective default , Sarkozy said euro zone nations stood ready to protect Greek banks from the fallout, by providing credit guarantees if needed to ensure they can still obtain liquidity from the European Central Bank.
The region’s rescue fund, the European Financial Stability Facility, will be allowed to buy bonds in the secondary market if the ECB deems that necessary to fight the crisis.
It will also be allowed for the first time to give states precautionary credit lines before they are shut out of credit markets, and lend governments money to recapitalise banks -- both moves which Germany blocked earlier this year.
The expanded EFSF role is designed to prevent bigger euro zone states such as Spain and Italy from being excluded from markets because of fears of a weaker country defaulting.
“We have agreed to create the beginnings of a European Monetary Fund,” Sarkozy said of the EFSF’s new powers.
Japanese Finance Minister Yoshihiko Noda expressed hope that the bailout plan would stabilise the euro, and said Tokyo was prepared to continue buying EFSF bonds. Japan’s yen has risen sharply in recent weeks as the euro fell, straining exporters.
“If it leads to stability in the EU’s economy and finance, we would like to continue making contributions at levels similar to what we have been doing,” Noda said.
The European leaders also promised a “Marshall Plan” of European public investment to help revive the Greek economy, which is in a deep recession due to draconian austerity steps imposed by the EU and the IMF. They did not give details.
The euro and European stocks rallied on news of the deal. The Stoxx European banking index closed Thursday up 4.1% and the insurance index gained 3.0 percent. Italian and Spanish shares rose strongly.
The risk premiums which investors demand to hold peripheral euro zone government bonds rather than benchmark German Bunds fell to two-week lows as expectations of a bolder-than-expected Brussels deal took hold.
The euro rose to a two-week high in Asian trade on Friday and world stocks also reached a two-week high.
“It really shows, in the 11th hour, leadership from the euro zone leaders,” said Niels From, chief analyst at Nordea.
But Win Thin, global head of emerging markets strategy at Brown Brothers Harriman in New York, said: “This is really just kicking the can down the road.
“These countries need a serious hard restructuring. I do not think this is going away, and debt swaps rarely work.”
Four options will be offered to private sector creditors taking part in the plan: three offers to exchange Greek government bonds and one offer to roll over Greek bonds into debt with maturities of up to 30 years. In addition, there will be a bond buyback scheme.
The Institute of International Finance, which represents over 400 firms and led talks for the private sector, said the bond exchanges would help reduce Greece’s 340 billion euro debt pile by €13.5 billion.
It predicted a 90% take-up rate by investors; several sources said the resulting net contribution would mean a write-down of about 20% on the value of banks’ Greek bond holdings.
The summit accord was based on a common position crafted by German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Sarkozy in late night talks in Berlin on Wednesday with ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet.
In an apparent trade-off for Merkel’s willingness to embrace new powers for the EFSF, Sarkozy agreed that private sector bondholders should take a hit and dropped a French call for a tax on banks to help fund the second Greek bailout.
The ECB relented and signalled it was willing to let Greece default temporarily under the plan, although Trichet told reporters he did not want to prejudge whether that would occur.
The expansion of the EFSF’s role will have to be endorsed by national parliaments in the euro zone, but diplomats said critical lawmakers in Germany, the Netherlands and Finland were likely to back it since the private sector will share the burden of the new Greek rescue.
Thursday’s summit is unlikely to mark a quick or complete resolution of the Greek crisis, however, as Merkel herself acknowledged earlier this week. Unless the country returns quickly to strong economic growth, which analysts believe is unlikely, a tougher decision may have to be made down the road on writing off more of its debt.
Analysts also believe Ireland and Portugal may eventually have to restructure their sovereign debt, although EU officials insisted on Thursday that the Greek bond swap would not be used as a model for those two countries.
Many economists believe the only way out of the euro zone’s debt crisis in the long run may be closer integration of national fiscal policies -- for example, a joint euro zone guarantee for countries’ bonds, or issuance of a joint euro zone bond to finance all countries. Germany has opposed this.
The path to Thursday’s agreement was made more difficult by competing national interests and domestic political agendas, and the unwieldy nature of euro zone decision-making.
Sarkozy said after the summit that France and Germany would make proposals by the end of August on how to improve the governance of the bloc, to “clarify our vision of the future of the euro zone”.