Poor planning, government apathy contributed to devastation in Bihar

Poor planning, government apathy contributed to devastation in Bihar
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Thu, Sep 11 2008. 10 27 PM IST
Updated: Thu, Sep 11 2008. 10 27 PM IST
Madhepura, Bihar: Most years, the Kosi river is a tranquil stream that flows gently into the Ganga. But every few years it becomes a raging torrent, wreaking disaster on everything in its path.
That’s what happened in August when, after monsoon rains, the Kosi burst its banks and flooded half of Bihar, wiping out villages and farms and displacing more than three million people.
The river is notorious for such cataclysmic events and, experts say, the government should have been prepared for such a scenario and taken preventive action such as reinforcing embankments and removing silt from the river bed.
“This is the mother of all floods,”?said?P.V.?Unnikrishnan of aid agency ActionAid, summing up the devastation.
The floods changed the course of the Kosi, a tributary of the Ganga, shifting it 120km towards a dry river channel it last flowed through 250 years ago.
“It looked angry, very angry and we could do nothing, absolutely nothing,” said Kashiram Singh, a farmer.
When Kadam Lal was a little boy, his grandfather would tell him stories about the terrifying floods unleashed by the Kosi. Now he has seen with his own eyes why the Kosi is called the “river of sorrow”.
“Over 100 acres of my land was gone within minutes,” said Lal, a now grey-haired farmer, pointing at a swirling barrage of muddy water powering down what were once lush green fields.
It is the Kosi’s worst flooding in 50 years, but not all of it is nature’s doing.
Poor planning, corruption and government apathy contributed to the devastating floods, which have left tens of thousands of villagers in relief camps, many with little food.
When the river first broke through the embankment intended to contain it on 18 August, the breach was about 1km long, but 24 hours later, it had widened to more than 15km.
Experts say the floods could have been avoided if the embankments in Nepal at the river’s mouth had been reinforced as recommended by engineers who sent letters to New Delhi in April urging that such measures be taken.
Flowing from the Nepalese Himalayas, the embankments are maintained by India under an agreement with Nepal.
As the Kosi’s waters began to rise, engineers faxed messages to the Bihar government desperately pleading that emergency measures be taken to alleviate the expected flooding.
Nothing was done, and now half of Bihar—one of India’s poorest states—is covered in water.
Engineers might only be able to plug the gap in December when the water flow decreases during the dry season, but the river may never return to its former route.
“It is an extremely difficult job at hand as the entire river is flowing through the new route,” Nitish Mishra, Bihar’s disaster management minister, said. “People should get away from its path now.”
In 1956, India and Nepal built a dam in the Himalayas to control the Kosi’s flow. It took seven years to build the dam and a 39km embankment to jacket the extremely turbulent river. Once completed, authorities virtually forgot all about it.
“The silt continued to deposit and the riverbed rose without anyone thinking about dredging and de-silting,” said Sunita Narain, director of Centre for Science and Environment, an activist environmental group.
The inevitable happened last month when the river flooded following heavy rains.
The damage is also economic. Bihar is the fifth largest producer of rice in India, and agriculture experts say it will take a long time for the region to recover. “The impact of the floods will have a much larger regional effect,” said B.P. Singh, president of the All India Grain Exporters.
Left with no means of earning a living, hundreds of farmers are migrating to western India in search of jobs.
“They don’t have any choice, but I will stay here and watch,” said the bespectacled Lal. “I am too old to join them now,” he said as 20 men left the village.
Comment E-mail Print Share
First Published: Thu, Sep 11 2008. 10 27 PM IST
More Topics: Planning | Bihar | Flood | Kosi | River |