Paris: France’s biggest listed bank BNP Paribas slashed its exposure to Greece, Italy and Spain by more than €12 billion ($16.6 billion) in a bid to protect its balance sheet as the euro zone debt crisis threatens to deepen.
Losses on these bond sales, as well as a heftier-than-expected €2.26 billion charge on BNP’s Greek sovereign debt, contributed to a 72% slide in quarterly earnings at the bank, seen as one of the most exposed to Europe’s woes.
French bank BNP Paribas CEO Baudouin Prot. Photo: AFP.
Although the earnings hit was bigger than expected, shares of BNP rose more than 6% after investors praised the bank’s pragmatism in valuing its Greek debt more aggressively and in selling down its overall euro sovereign exposure.
“BNP has taken a cautious attitude on Greek debt,” said Marine Michel, a Paris-based fund manager at Montsegur Finance, which manages €200 million in assets. “Given the current developments it’s a bold move.”
BNP wrote down 60% of its sovereign exposure to the crisis-hit Greek economy, reflecting last month’s pledge from private-sector creditors to write off a bigger chunk of their Greek debt, the bank said in a statement, though it added the plan was still “shrouded by uncertainty”.
But even more striking was its reduction in exposure to Italy -- which the bank has always insisted had a handle on its debt crisis -- by €8.3 billion, or 40%, and to Spain by €2.2 billion, or 81.5%.
“It was a surprise ... But it means much less peripheral sovereign debt and that’s going to be taken well by the market,” a London-based bank analyst said.
BNP Paribas shares were up 5.4%, at 04:00 pm, higher than domestic rivals Credit Agricole and Societe Generale , up 3.3% and 2.1% respectively.
Greek Default “Manageable”
BNP chief executive Baudouin Prot did not rule out a Greek sovereign debt default, telling Reuters Insider TV it would be “unpleasant” but manageable.
“I think that (BNP’s provisioning) is adequate ... We will see as things go,” he said, adding the sovereign debt sell-off was a response to regulators’ demand that banks mark their holdings to market values.
Separately, Dutch financial services group ING Group said it would cut 2,700 jobs at its Dutch banking operations to cope with a deteriorating market, which led to Greek and other impairments.
BNP’s big balance sheet, its dependence on wholesale funding markets and its overwhelming European exposure make it among the most vulnerable to the euro zone sovereign debt crisis.
Following a 45% share-price drop since the end of June, the bank has announced sweeping asset sales that will be accompanied by job cuts, mainly at its investment bank.
“We will have some staff reductions as we implement the deleveraging plan,” he said, later telling BFM radio BNP’s cuts would be in the hundreds not thousands.
Banks such as JP Morgan Chase and Credit Suisse are shedding jobs worldwide as stricter regulations and a tough trading environment take their toll on investment banking units in particular.
The impact of disposals and the reduction in US-dollar funding needs -- down by $20 billion in the third quarter and due to go down by the same amount in the fourth -- will lead to one-off losses of €1.2 billion, BNP said.
Euro Zone Debt Slashed
Third-quarter net profit at BNP fell by 71.6% to €541 million, compared with a 991.9 million mean estimate of nine analysts polled by Reuters. Revenue fell 7.6% to 10.0 billion compared with a mean estimate of 10.48 billion.
The results bore the scars of a volatile quarter, with corporate and investment bank revenue down 39.8% to €1.75 billion. Capital-markets pretax profit was almost completely wiped out, while wealth and asset management pretax profit fell by nearly 50% in the quarter.
However, BNP’s retail operations benefited from growth in western European markets and others like Turkey. Retail pretax profit rose by 22.8%.
BNP’s quarterly numbers were peppered with other one-offs, including a revenue gain of €786 million on widening spreads on BNP’s own debt and a €299 million writedown on its 5.2% stake in Europe’s No. 2 insurer AXA.
The bank’s core tier 1 ratio, a closely watched metric of lenders’ loss-absorbing capital, stood at 9.6% at end-September, unchanged from end-June.
French banks including BNP have promised to boost their capital levels by €8.8 billion without government help to reach tougher targets set by European regulators for mid-2012.
Although bonuses will likely come down in line with capital-markets profits, BNP could be at 9.1% core tier 1 in mid-2012 without touching its dividend, CEO Prot said.