Mumbai: Despite the government asking the state-run general insurers to strictly follow underwriting norms, the insurers preparing for initial public offerings (IPOs) feel they will take at least two more years to start making underwriting profits.
Recently the department of financial services wrote to the chief managing directors (CMDs) of all the state-run non-life insurers to protect the interests of their policyholders, continue to be effective players in the market on a long-term basis and to ensure that their unhealthy underwriting practices do not cause unnecessary financial strain on their financial stability.
“It’s desirable that prudent underwriting practices suggested in government advisories are followed strictly," the government told the companies in the letter.
The four state-owned general insurers are New India Assurance Co Ltd, United India Insurance Co Ltd, The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd and National Insurance Co Ltd. GIC Re is the sole state-run reinsurer while Export Credit Guarantee Corporation (ECGC) of India Ltd and Agriculture Insurance Company are the public sector specialised insurers.
One such advisory had already been sent by government to these companies in 2012-13 which was followed by internal circulars. However, the department has found that these companies are violating the advisories leading to huge underwriting losses.
As a result, these companies are solely dependent on the investment income or profit from sale of investments, notes the letter.
“These are limited investments and are fast depleting as a result of indiscriminate disposal by companies to make up for the losses on underwriting premia. Such an arrangement is not sustainable in the long run and can permanently harm their competitiveness," the letter said.
Underwriting loss of National Insurance Company, which is preparing for IPO by the fiscal-end, remained almost at the same level at Rs3,680 crore in 2016-17 fiscal, marginally up from Rs3,633 crore in 2015-16.
“The recent advisory from the government is a part of general advisories on prudent underwriting, caution in operating in loss-making areas, and on corporate governance. After all, the government owns 100% in us unlike most of other PSUs (public sector undertakings) and banks," National Insurance Company chairman and managing director Sanath Kumar told PTI.
But he was quick to point out that even private players are booking underwriting losses for many years. “Both private and public insurers have been making losses in business, but are in overall profits due to investment income. So generating large cash flows is an important factor," he said.
“Though there have been a few exceptions, the general improvement in controlling losses, raising of capital and better data analytics will take time. I think we would turn around in another two years," Kumar said.
The industry’s underwriting losses jumped 42% to Rs14,962 crore, pulling down cumulative net profit by 30% to Rs3,238 crore in 2015-16.
State-owned players’ underwriting losses went up by 54.4% to Rs10,839 crore in 2015-16 from Rs7,019 crore in 2014-15, whereas private sector players’ underwriting losses also increased to Rs3,662 crore from Rs2,495 crore during the same period.
The figures for 2016-17 are not out yet.
Private player Bajaj Allianz is the only insurer to report an underwriting profit of Rs62 crore in 2016-17.
The insurers say they have to strike a balance between social commitment and commercial prudence. “We are adhering to careful underwriting of group mediclaim in line with the objective of commercial prudence. Our prudent underwriting practices are acknowledged by the whole market. So we are comfortable with the guidelines," Oriental Insurance Company chairman A.V. Girija Kumar said.
“Despite this, we are committed to actively participate in the mandated programmes like PMFBY (Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana) and PMSBY (Pradhan Mantri Suraksha Bima Yojana) and strive our best to marry commercial interests with our social obligations," he said.