How Tata Nano became ammunition for Mistry’s broadside against Ratan Tata

Emotional reasons alone have withheld Tata Sons from pulling the plug on Tata Nano, Cyrus Mistry said in the email to the board of directors

Shally Seth Mohile
Updated27 Oct 2016, 05:22 PM IST
The Tata Nano, a product of Ratan Tata’s dream project of making a Rs1 lakh car, has consistently lost money, peaking at Rs1,000 crore, says Cyrus Mistry. Photo: Reuters
The Tata Nano, a product of Ratan Tata’s dream project of making a Rs1 lakh car, has consistently lost money, peaking at Rs1,000 crore, says Cyrus Mistry. Photo: Reuters

Mumbai: Tata Nano, a product of Ratan Tata’s dream project, is in the news once again for the wrong reasons. This time around, it is caught in the crossfire arising from a boardroom coup.

In a strongly worded five-page letter to the board of directors of Tata Sons Ltd, Cyrus Mistry, the ousted chairman of the group holding company, said Nano’s development costs were always above the threshold in the product concept, resulting in mounting losses.

“The Nano product development concept called for car below Rs1 lakh but the costs were always above this. This product has consistently lost money, peaking at Rs1,000 crore,” wrote Mistry, pointing out that “there is no line of sight to profitability for the Nano and any turnaround strategy for the company requires to shut it down. Emotional reasons alone have kept us away from this crucial decision”.

Under Mistry, Tata Motors made two bold attempts to revive the Nano. After failing to woo the original target customer, the two-wheeler owner who cannot afford a car, theauto maker repositioned Nano as a smart city car in March 2014. That did little to help. In May 2015, the car came full circle in terms of price and positioning. Renamed GenX Nano, it was relaunched at an aggressive price (the basic variant came at Rs1.99 lakh) as an entry-level car for the youth.

Neither helped. Nano sales dropped to 4,459 units in the first seven months of 2016-17 against 11,321 units in the year-ago period, according to the Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers.

Mistry said the historical practice of aggressive accounting to capitalize a substantial portion of product development expense is also creating a future liability for the firm.

Analysts said it’s not unusual of firms to do that. “Given the small share of the domestic entity in the overall business, no one has bothered to check the extent of capitalization. But it is not unusual for auto companies...,” said an analyst at a domestic brokerage who asked not to be identified.

Catch all the Corporate news and Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.MoreLess
First Published:27 Oct 2016, 05:22 PM IST
HomeCompaniesNewsHow Tata Nano became ammunition for Mistry’s broadside against Ratan Tata

Get Instant Loan up to ₹10 Lakh!

  • Employment Type

    Most Active Stocks

    Tata Steel

    157.75
    03:43 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    -8.6 (-5.17%)

    Tata Power

    414.15
    03:59 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    -15.85 (-3.69%)

    Bharat Electronics

    306.30
    03:45 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    -7.2 (-2.3%)

    Zee Entertainment Enterprises

    137.55
    03:57 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    -4.9 (-3.44%)
    More Active Stocks

    Market Snapshot

    • Top Gainers
    • Top Losers
    • 52 Week High

    Tata Teleservices Maharashtra

    102.11
    03:59 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    4.68 (4.8%)

    Rail Vikas Nigam

    614.00
    03:59 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    27.65 (4.72%)

    Jubilant Pharmova

    752.25
    03:43 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    25.3 (3.48%)

    One 97 Communications

    458.70
    03:55 PM | 19 JUL 2024
    13.65 (3.07%)
    More from Top Gainers

    Recommended For You

      More Recommendations

      Gold Prices

      • 24K
      • 22K
      Bangalore
      74,925.000.00
      Chennai
      74,558.000.00
      Delhi
      75,144.000.00
      Kolkata
      74,558.000.00

      Fuel Price

      • Petrol
      • Diesel
      Bangalore
      102.86/L0.00
      Chennai
      100.75/L0.00
      Kolkata
      104.95/L0.00
      New Delhi
      94.72/L0.00
      OPEN IN APP
      HomeMarketsCibilPremiumBudget