Smith & Nephew jumps 13% on reported J&J bid

Smith & Nephew jumps 13% on reported J&J bid

London: Shares in Smith & Nephew, Europe’s largest maker of replacement knees and hips, hit a record high on Monday on a report it received a bid last month, which it had not disclosed to shareholders.

US rival Johnson & Johnson made a £7 billion ($10.9 billion) takeover approach that was turned down as inadequate by the British group, Sky News said at the weekend, without citing sources.

Johnson & Johnson (J&J) was considering whether to return with a higher offer, after its indicative bid of more than 750 pence a share was spurned as too low, Sky added.

Smith & Nephew (S&N) declined to comment on the report but the company may now come under pressure to issue a statement, following the sharp rise in its shares.

Companies are obliged by British takeover rules to inform the market of an approach if the news leaks and influences its shares.

Some shareholders of bank-note printer De La Rue criticised its management in December for a delay in disclosing an approach from France’s Oberthur Technologies.

J&J said that as a matter of policy it did not comment on “rumours and speculation."

S&N has been regularly tipped as a bid target for US rivals, such as privately owned Biomet and J&J. It also competes with orthopaedics firms Stryker and Zimmer. Takeover speculation has gained traction recently, fuelling a run-up in the shares since December.

S&N is a fairly small player in the replacement joint industry and is seen as an attractive target for bigger rivals seeking a larger global presence.

The stock hit a record high of 739 pence on Monday—up 13.7% from Friday’s close—and it was 12.3% higher at 730p by 0940 GMT.

Competition Issues

Panmure Gordon analyst Savvas Neophytou said a long-awaited bid for S&N was more likely from J&J than a deal with rivals Zimmer or Stryker, given J&J’s track record of doing deals.

“If J&J put their considerable muscle behind what S&N do, they would be able to drive growth beyond what S&N could do as a stand-alone business," he said. “It would be a fairly attractive acquisition for J&J."

S&N has done a good job in improving both its profit margins and its product offerings, but it faces some challenges in its base business, he added. In order to win over management, however, J&J would have to increase its price idea.

“For a change of control premium I would look to have anything up to £10 on this," Neophytou said. “Anything short of £9, I find it difficult to see shareholders taking."

J&J and any other established orthopaedics group would, however, face potential competition problems in buying S&N.

“The key issue in this event is untangling the potential antitrust issues that will raise their head regarding the respective position in orthopaedic surgery both in the US and in Europe," said Mike Mitchell at stockbroker Seymour Pierce.

A bid for S&N from J&J or another rival would be latest in a growing trend of deal-making in the healthcare sector, where companies are seeking to achieve economies of scale to cope with an increasingly tough market environment.

Bankers believe the sector is on course for a robust year of mergers and acquisitions as a range of companies look to external sources of growth.

The dominant pattern is expected to be bolt-on acquisitions that won’t change the industry but will give individual companies a new business area or geography.

J&J is under particular pressure to improve its performance following repeated recalls of its consumer products in the past year.

The US group last month promoted the heads of its medical device unit and its pharmaceuticals division to vice chairmen, in a move that could put them in competition to succeed chief executive and chairman William Weldon.