
A high-impact recommendation of the Shome committee on General Anti-Avoidance Rules (GAAR) is to abolish income tax on gains arising from transfer of securities (equity shares and units of equity-oriented mutual funds), which has been subjected to securities transaction tax (STT), irrespective of whether the gains are characterized as capital gains or business income. The statement of the finance minister on the GAAR report does not talk of acceptance of this recommendation. This article outlines the win-win situation which would be created for stakeholders should this recommendation be accepted.
Asset management companies
As of December 2012, mutual fund asset management companies (AMCs) managed around 3 trillion of equities, primarily for domestic investors. The corresponding amount of investment in Indian equities by foreign institutional investors (FIIs) was around 4.8 trillion as of November 2012. However, very little, or perhaps none, of the latter is managed from India. While the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) amended the mutual fund regulations in August 2011 to extend the activities that an AMC could pursue—which now includes management of offshore broad-based funds—Indian income-tax remains a big hurdle in this regard. Essentially, even long-term capital gains which are otherwise exempt from tax could be subject to as high as a 40% tax rate if the income is characterized as business income. Apart from this, investors who would otherwise enjoy treaty protection may lose the benefit if the management from India results in them having a “place of effective management” in India.
Mutual fund AMCs consider themselves as having a better, if not equally good, track record in managing Indian assets as offshore managers. If the GAAR report recommendation were to be accepted, offshore funds could consider appointing Indian AMCs as managers without risk of the additional tax leakage. Given the extent of the investments by FIIs in equities alone, even a small shift of the management of these funds to Indian asset managers could result in a significant increase in the assets under management (AUMs) for such managers (that too equity and not debt), and avoid the need for AMCs to explore setting up offshore structures, at times cost ineffective, for carrying out such activities—a gamechanger indeed. There has been talk of looking at safe harbour rules for facilitating this growth of AMCs, however, this recommendation would achieve the same objective and more.
Qualified foreign investors
The qualified foreign investors (QFIs) route was announced in February 2011. Recently, the tax authorities came out with certain frequently asked questions (FAQs) as well. However, this is yet to take off in practice, one of the reasons for which is certain tax hurdles. Again, it is expected that the acceptance of the recommendation would provide clarity and certainty not only to QFIs, but also comfort to other stakeholders such as the qualified depository participants on whom onerous tax responsibilities have been cast under the FAQs.
Domestic investors
Domestic investors may get the benefit of good practices which the AMCs may have to adopt to service global investors. Besides, there are ongoing tax disputes on the question of whether income from equities is (exempt) capital gains or (taxable) business income for domestic investors, which can be eliminated if the recommendation is accepted.
Revenue implications
The government has a tough task of reining in the fiscal deficit and any discussion on growth motivated measures need to be necessarily fine-tuned keeping the revenue outflow in mind. The GAAR report mentions that about 3,000 crore are collected as income tax on short-term capital gains on equities. While this number may increase if one includes tax collected on equity gains characterized as business income, the number has to be balanced by a number of other receipts including the income tax collected on profits by AMCs on managing higher AUMs and service tax on AMC fees. Of course, the prime incentive would be to encourage capital inflows into the country—additionally, this would also beef up the asset management fees which would flow into revenue account.
Conclusion
The recommendation to abolish income tax contains a win-win situation. The exemption of gains from listed equities/equity-oriented mutual funds would put India in the same basket as other developed nations such as the US, the UK, Australia and Germany, and also other Asian countries such as Hong Kong, Indonesia, Korea, Malaysia and Singapore. If the recent bold moves of the government are a trend, the capital markets would be keenly hoping for the trend to continue with a positive announcement in the budget proposals—incidentally, the vision of Mumbai as a financial powerhouse was laid out by the same government in the budget of 2007.
Gautam Mehra is executive director and leader, asset management, PricewaterhouseCoopers.
Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
Oops! Looks like you have exceeded the limit to bookmark the image. Remove some to bookmark this image.