The 20% world is here to stay
Look around the politics of the Western world, and you will see that a lot of once-unthinkable ideas and fringe candidates suddenly have a genuine chance of succeeding
If you want to pick a number for 2016, how about 20%? Look around the politics of the Western world, and you will see that a lot of once-unthinkable ideas and fringe candidates suddenly have a genuine chance of succeeding. The odds are usually somewhere around one in five—not probable, but possible. This “20% world" is going to set the tone in democracies on both sides of the Atlantic—not least because, as anybody who bets on horse racing will tell you, eventually one of these long-shots is going to canter home.
Start with President Donald Trump. Gamblers, who have been much better at predicting political results than pollsters, currently put the odds of the hard-to-pin-down-but-generally-right-wing billionaire reaching the White House at around 6-1, or 17%. Interestingly, those are roughly the same odds as the ones offered on Jeremy Corbyn, the most left-wing leader of the Labour Party for a generation, becoming the next British prime minister. In France, gamblers put the likelihood of Marine Le Pen winning France’s presidency in 2017 at closer to 25%, partly because the right-wing populist stands an extremely good chance of reaching the run-off. Geert Wilders, another right-wing populist previously described as “fringe," perhaps stands a similar chance of becoming the next Dutch prime minister.
Some unthinkable events are also distinctly possible. This year, perhaps as early as June, Britain may vote to leave the European Union. Bookmakers still expect the country to go for the status quo, though most pundits are less certain about this than they were about the Scottish referendum in 2014, which turned out to be an uncomfortably close race for the British establishment.
Investors are used to the political world serving up surprises. These surprises, however, have usually involved one mainstream party doing much better or worse than expected—and things continuing as normal. Not this time. With Trump in charge, America would have a wall along the Rio Grande and could well be stuck in a trade war with China. Le Pen wants to take France out of the euro and renegotiate France’s membership in the EU. It’s hard to tell what would do more damage to the City of London: a Brexit that could lead to thousands of banking jobs moving to the continent; or a Corbyn premiership, which could include a maximum wage and the renationalization of Britain’s banks, railways and energy companies.
Moreover, in the 20% world, some nasty possibilities make others more likely. If Britain leaves the European Union, Scotland (which, unlike England, would probably have voted to stay in) might in turn try to leave Britain. If Le Pen manages to pull France out of the euro, the union’s chances of dissolution increase.
The conventional wisdom from political elites is that voters will consider these possibilities, wise up and pull back from the unthinkable. But there’s also plenty of evidence that across the Western world, voters are furious with the established parties and choices—and much more willing to consider extreme solutions.
The unease that has brought us to this point is not going to abate. On both sides of the Atlantic, even when economies are growing, voters across the political spectrum are unnerved by broadly the same things, including inequality and globalization.
Corruption and inefficiency—whether in the form of America’s money politics or the EU’s lack of accountability—partly explain why the ills of the Western world have not been solved. But another reason is that problems like inequality don’t lend themselves to easy or swift resolution. A generation doesn’t become educated overnight; an economic realignment brought about by technology doesn’t resolve itself in short order. In other words, the 20% world is here to stay. Get used to it. Bloomberg
John Micklethwait is editor-in-chief of Bloomberg News.
Comments are welcome at otherviews@livemint.com
Unlock a world of Benefits! From insightful newsletters to real-time stock tracking, breaking news and a personalized newsfeed – it's all here, just a click away! Login Now!