BackWhy Canada is dumping gold
Countries with significant gold reserves have some history as global hegemons, imperial powers, economic powerhousesor aspirations to such status
Premium
Canada, home to some of the world’s largest gold-mining companies, recently announced that it had effectively liquidated all of the country’s holdings of the shiny metal and is moving to what a government spokesperson described as “easily tradable" assets.
It has been a long process. Canada held 1,088 tonnes of gold in 1955. By 2000, it was down to 46 tonnes. Today, just 77 ounces remain. This puts Canada in last place in the most up-to-date compilation of data on gold reserves compiled by an industry group, the World Gold Council.
Canada’s explanation for the sell-off is reasonable enough: Actual bullion bars cannot be liquidated as easily as, say, government bonds. And over the long term, central banks and governments have generally gotten a better return by investing in safe assets such as US Treasuries. But the real question is not why Canada has sold its gold; it’s why other countries remain so wedded to maintaining—even accumulating—stocks of the precious metal despite the fact that it no longer plays any role in money supply.
The reason some countries hold on to gold may have little to do with sound fiscal policy. Instead, the practice reflects the less tangible or rational weight of history. A look at which countries own the metal—and which countries do not— presents an unexpected pattern. Countries that possess significant reserves have some history as global hegemons, imperial powers or economic powerhouses—or aspirations to such status.
In a fascinating paper from 2012, two economists at the University of Santa Cruz —Joshua Aizenman and Kenta Inoue—crunched some numbers and found that “the intensity of holding gold is correlated with ‘global power’— by the history of being a past empire". This, they said, is especially true of “countries that are or were the suppliers of key currencies".
The US remains no. 1, just as it remains the world’s biggest economy and the issuer of the most common reserve currency. But the pattern reaches into the distant past. The Netherlands was an imperial heavyweight in the 17th century, but it lost that status long ago. Nonetheless, it holds the 10th largest gold reserves, even though it has a population of only 17 million.
Portugal, a country that once possessed an empire that stretched from Brazil to Angola to Macau, has 382 tonnes of gold, yet only has a population of about 11 million. The better-known imperial powers—Germany, Italy, France, Russia, and the UK, all have gold holdings in the global top 20.
The trend extends beyond Europe. Japan, which sought to conquer much of the Pacific in the 20th century, and later became the world’s second-largest economy, is ranked no. 9 in gold holdings. Taiwan, which became an economic powerhouse in the second half of the 20th century, is ranked 14.
Likewise, European powers without a significant history of imperial ambition don’t seem to have much interest in gold. Finland, for example, is stuck between Argentina and Bolivia in its current holdings of gold. Ireland is even lower, sandwiched between Latvia and Lithuania. These nations are used to living in the shadow of a much bigger imperial power, and share a common history of having been conquered by bigger neighbours.
But there are newcomers in the top 20, too. As Aizenman and Inoue point out, it’s no accident that two countries that have moved from bit players to powerhouses have been buying up gold. China is now ranked no. 6, having accumulated 1,762 tonnes. India is ranked no. 11, having amassed 557 tonnes.
China and Indian’s gold reserves, they note, “increased in tandem with the sharp rise of their economic power". In other words, they are the latest countries to buy into an unspoken dogma that if you are going to be a heavyweight, you need some heavy metal.
Which brings us back to Canada. It has been the plaything of empires, but has never harboured imperial ambitions. And its policymakers have never felt a need to proclaim their greatness by accumulating piles of gold. As they would say to the rest of us who cling to this imperial relic: it’s all in your head.
BLOOMBERG
Stephen Mihm is an associate professor of history at the University of Georgia.
Comments are welcome at otherviews@livemint.com
Unlock a world of Benefits! From insightful newsletters to real-time stock tracking, breaking news and a personalized newsfeed – it's all here, just a click away! Login Now!
