Opinion | India dodges a Lehman moment. That was the easy part
It was only when the fish (IL&FS) was dead to the markets that the authorities took note of the risk to Indian finance
Even before it went belly up, India’s IL&FS Group was a strange fish: A private infrastructure financier that lent to risky projects it also owned, while throwing around the weight of non-existent state connections to mask a multi-year liquidity squeeze.
It was only when the creature was dead to the markets that the authorities took note of the risk to Indian finance. As investors were repelled by the lender’s insolvency, New Delhi moved decisively Monday to clean up the mess. Unless the government-supervised rescue comes unstuck for some reason, it’s safe to say that India’s mini-Lehman moment has been averted.
IL&FS isn’t being nationalized, at least not yet. Existing shareholders, including India’s Life Insurance Corp., Japan’s Orix Corp. and Abu Dhabi Investment Authority, continue to own Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services Ltd., the unlisted parent. However, the old board has been replaced by new government-nominated directors. Among them is banker Uday Kotak, who’ll most likely lead the unscrambling of a group that has 169 subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures.
When New Delhi says it aims to “immediately stop further financial defaults and also take measures to resolve defaulted dues to the claimants,” it’s hoping taxpayers’ money won’t actually be needed. The commitment alone should be enough for the debt market to treat IL&FS’s obligations as implicitly sovereign-backed.
That assumption may get tested. Before the government stepped in, it was pretty clear that IL&FS wasn’t going to be trusted by the markets with even a cent in new loans. As for a Rs 4,500 crore ($600 million) rights issue, proposed by the old management and cleared by the shareholders on Saturday, that money would also have disappeared into a black hole, given that the equity infusion required to steady the ship is around $4 billion, according to a 27 September report by REDD Intelligence.
Now that the government is backing its liabilities, IL&FS presumably can survive on a thinner layer of equity than it would have otherwise needed. There will be less pressure from markets to sell assets like roads, tunnels and power plants at throwaway prices, and time for the group to fix its bloated balance sheet more sensibly.
Some deleveraging will still be required, particularly for nonperforming energy and transport projects already facing bankruptcy proceedings. Writing off 20% of the group operating companies’ non-financial assets of $10 billion would mean a $2 billion hit, in REDD’s estimates, when the current equity cushion to support the infrastructure business is not even half as thick.
That raises the possibility of a bigger rights issue. If national champions like Life Insurance Corp. and State Bank of India were to play a disproportionately large role in filling that capital hole, nationalization of IL&FS would be complete.
With general elections due next year, and the opposition Congress Party already attacking the government over the bailout, the scope to utilise state-run institutions’ funds may be limited. Besides, forcibly diluting international investors won’t make it easy to tap them for future projects.
Keeping the market for Indian infrastructure assets open and attractive will be Kotak’s bigger task. But that must wait until the tanks are clean of the mess IL&FS has left behind.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Andy Mukherjee is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering industrial companies and financial services. He previously was a columnist for Reuters Breakingviews. He has also worked for the Straits Times, ET NOW and Bloomberg News.
Editor's Picks »
- Boards that lead: How competent are corporate India’s boards
- A big gap between the sci-fi side of things and achieving reality: Sethu Vijayakumar
- Will Microsoft Kaizala really do more for the enterprise workforce and expand footprint?
- Opinion | Industry 4.0 and its adoption in connected cars
- Solving enterprise problems with AI
- Markets yet to warm up to KEC International’s record order book
- Indraprastha Gas and Mahanagar Gas shares are low on fuel
- Overhang of capacity constraints lifts for ACC, Ambuja Cements
- Stock market traders fall for the ‘buy rural’ narrative, once again
- Continuing volume momentum puts Indian ports in a good position