Whose finger on the nuclear trigger at sea?

India has taken its own sweet time to imbibe the skills and technology that has been around since at least the 1950s

W. P. S. Sidhu
Updated4 Aug 2013, 09:13 PM IST
A file photo of the launch of INS Arihant. The nuclear submarine programme was reportedly conceived in 1970. It took another thirty years before INS Arihant was launched in 2009 (and not without a little help from Russia). Photo: PTI<br />
A file photo of the launch of INS Arihant. The nuclear submarine programme was reportedly conceived in 1970. It took another thirty years before INS Arihant was launched in 2009 (and not without a little help from Russia). Photo: PTI

On 17 January 1955 when the USS Nautilus—the world’s first nuclear submarine—sailed out deploying the rector for propulsion for the very first time its captain, Commander Eugene Wilkinson (who died last month at the ripe age of 94), radioed the historic message: “Underway on nuclear power”.

Nearly 60 years later INS Arihant—India’s first nuclear-powered and nuclear-armed submarine—will accomplish a similar feat in coming weeks and its commander, Captain Sanjay Mahendru may well mark the epoch-making event with his own memorable message.

India has taken its own sweet time to imbibe the skills and technology that have been around since at least the 1950s. The nuclear submarine programme was reportedly conceived in 1970 (even before the 1974 nuclear test) but gathered momentum only in the 1980s. It took another thirty years—and several dramatic twists and turns worthy of a Bollywood potboiler—before INS Arihant was launched in 2009 (and not without a little help from Russia).

In contrast, the keel of Nautilus was laid in 1952 and within three years it was sailing on nuclear power. Even China, which began its programme in 1958, was able to get its first nuclear propelled submarine underway by 1971.

Its belated arrival notwithstanding, INS Arihant marks a sea change in India’s nuclear arsenal and strategic reach. First, it completes the nuclear triad—the ability to launch nuclear weapons from the air, land and subsea. Second, the sea-leg of the triad also strengthens India’s second-strike capability (i.e. the ability to launch a retaliatory nuclear strike if an enemy first strike takes out the air and land launch capabilities). This lends greater credibility to India’s nuclear deterrence; assuming, of course, that the submarine is quiet enough to remain undetected. Finally, it provides India with a truly global reach. With its ability to traverse the oceans without having to surface or refuel, the “boomer” puts almost every country of concern (even with the limited 700km range of the present K-15 submarine-launched ballistic missile—SLBM) within range.

However, the operationalization of INS Arihant’s nuclear weapons also raises a crucial question: whose finger is on the nuclear trigger at sea? A related issue is the so-called “always/never dilemma” which on the one hand is concerned that nuclear weapons always detonate in a prescribed manner when directed by the political leadership and on the other that nuclear weapons never detonate when their use has not been authorized by the political leadership.

In the case of India’s land-based and air-deliverable nuclear weapons this concern has largely been dealt with by keeping the nuclear warheads separated from the delivery systems—aircraft and missiles. The former are under the custody of Defence Research and Development Organisation officials while the latter are under the control of the armed forces. This de-mated state of the arsenal ensures that these weapons can never be used without the proper authorization.

However, it will be nearly impossible to keep the SLBMs and the warheads de-mated on INS Arihant. This raises the prospect of unauthorized use of the nuclear-tipped SLBMs, in addition to the danger of inadvertent or accidental launch and highlights the never dilemma. All other nuclear weapon states with SLBMs have resolved these concerns through various means. The US initially followed a two-man rule, similar to India’s, but replaced it with a technological fix—the permissive action links. Similarly, British prime ministers gave “beyond the grave” pre-planned instructions to their submarine commanders in case all communication ceased.

India will have to address this crucial issue to ensure the credibility of its nuclear deterrence. Hopefully, it will not take as long getting INS Arihant underway on nuclear power.

W.P.S. Sidhu is a senior fellow at the Center on International Cooperation, New York University. He writes on strategic affairs every fortnight.

Comments are welcome at otherviews@livemint.com

Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

MoreLess
First Published:4 Aug 2013, 09:13 PM IST
Business NewsOpinionWhose finger on the nuclear trigger at sea?

Get Instant Loan up to ₹10 Lakh!

  • Employment Type

    Most Active Stocks

    NTPC share price

    392.45
    03:59 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -5.25 (-1.32%)

    Tata Motors share price

    804.75
    03:59 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -0.95 (-0.12%)

    ICICI Bank share price

    1,269.15
    03:58 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    9.8 (0.78%)

    Tata Steel share price

    144.95
    03:42 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -2.6 (-1.76%)
    More Active Stocks

    Market Snapshot

    • Top Gainers
    • Top Losers
    • 52 Week High

    Wipro share price

    572.25
    03:59 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    3.4 (0.6%)

    Federal Bank share price

    207.75
    03:51 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    1 (0.48%)

    Indian Hotels Company share price

    729.45
    03:59 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -3.6 (-0.49%)

    Page Industries share price

    47,349.95
    03:29 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -637.85 (-1.33%)
    More from 52 Week High

    Asian Paints share price

    2,542.65
    03:44 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -226.6 (-8.18%)

    CE Info Systems share price

    1,890.15
    03:53 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -165.65 (-8.06%)

    UPL share price

    515.10
    03:47 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -42.5 (-7.62%)

    Aarti Industries share price

    439.55
    03:58 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    -35.2 (-7.41%)
    More from Top Losers

    Biocon share price

    348.85
    03:58 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    27.6 (8.59%)

    Borosil Renewables share price

    503.10
    03:40 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    37.5 (8.05%)

    ITI share price

    327.40
    03:59 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    23.8 (7.84%)

    Power Finance Corp share price

    481.60
    03:58 PM | 11 NOV 2024
    32.15 (7.15%)
    More from Top Gainers

    Recommended For You

      More Recommendations

      Gold Prices

      • 24K
      • 22K
      Bangalore
      78,775.00-600.00
      Chennai
      78,781.00-600.00
      Delhi
      78,933.00-600.00
      Kolkata
      78,785.00-600.00

      Fuel Price

      • Petrol
      • Diesel
      Bangalore
      102.92/L0.00
      Chennai
      100.80/L0.00
      Kolkata
      104.95/L0.00
      New Delhi
      94.77/L0.00

      Popular in Opinion

        HomeMarketsPremiumInstant LoanMint Shorts