Apple’s rain of cash washes away doubts about its debt
Apple produces enough cash to do everything a business is supposed to do— reward its owners, support its existing products and plan for the future
New York: Apple Inc. can do no wrong in either stock or bond markets. Just witness its share price.
Or look at its growing debt pile, which has managed to leave its credit grade untarnished.
But perhaps the iPhone maker ought to be treated with a touch more scepticism. Specifically, analysts ought to be asking whether Apple is acting prudently with its plan to return loads of cash to its shareholders by leveraging up its balance sheet. It’s already three-quarters of the way through its plan to give back $300 billion of capital to shareholders by March 2019, and it’s financing the bulk of it through an exceptionally pliant bond market.
Stock investors love it, of course. Why wouldn’t they? Apple is the third-biggest dividend payer in the US behind Fannie Mae and Exxon Mobil Corp., which is music to any investor’s ears when bonds are paying historically little. And debt investors seem to be just fine with forking their money over to the company; they’ve eagerly bought up multiple debt offerings from Apple so far this year, with the seventh 2017 bond sale on track to get the company’s usual warm reception.
This raises longer-term risks and threats to the company that aren’t highlighted often, if ever.
As long as Apple keeps churning out loads and loads of cash, all this is fine. Apple generates more cash than any other public US company, and it’s spending its money both to invest in its business and to return money to stockholders. Apple’s spending on research and development has also increased sharply in recent years, as have its capital expenditures on things like manufacturing equipment, computer centers and its retail stores. In short, Apple produces enough cash to do everything a business is supposed to do: reward its owners, support its existing products and plan for the future.
But can the company keep doing this over the next three decades? That’s less certain. The borrowings are already affecting Apple’s finances. The company’s cash minus debt stands at an impressive $153 billion, but the level has grown more slowly than revenue. Net cash has increased by 15% in the three years ended 1 July, while sales have increased 21%. And its growing debt pile raises the risk of losses to many more individuals if it loses momentum over the next three decades.
Meanwhile, Apple is on the hook for about $2.6 billion a year in interest payments to bondholders, according to Bloomberg estimates, which is negligible now but in any normal universe would be considered a significant cost. That’s substantially less than the cost of repatriating the money Apple is keeping overseas back to the US But at some point, it may have a less-robust flow of cash and profits and may look to that stash of liquid assets for help. US lawmakers say they want to make it easier for companies to bring money back home, but they’ve shown a remarkable knack this year for accomplishing nothing.
IBM is the cautionary tale of a tech company that went too far in rewarding its shareholders. The company was for years among the most active buyers of its own shares. A few years ago, however, investors turned on the company’s tactic and said it propped up IBM’s earnings per share and diverted cash that could have been better used to invest in the business.
Apple is no IBM, but it’s worth noting that investors didn’t gripe about IBM’s share repurchases until it was clear the company’s revenue was consistently shrinking. Apple isn’t in that position. Yet. While Apple is a technology Goliath now, there are real questions about whether it can continue to dominate in the same way over the next three decades. Its current plan makes sense, but investors ought to question the prudence of packing debt onto a company that operates in a highly competitive and mercurial industry that hasn’t been tested over a far-reaching horizon. Bloomberg Gadfly
Editor's Picks »
- Why Indian paint makers are shifting to water-based paints
- 2019 elections still some time away but defence stocks get the jitters
- Complan and Horlicks sale signals low energy in health drinks market
- With fall of the last dove, MPC minutes portend more than one RBI rate hike
- RITES IPO ticks the valuations box, but not the growth one