Bengaluru flyovers poorly designed: Brazilian expert Paulo Sergio Custodio

Metro may be the most effective means of conveyance in a rapidly-expanding city such as Bengaluru, says Brazilian public transport expert Paulo Sergio Custodio

Rahul Chandran
Updated16 Sep 2016, 05:42 PM IST
A file photo of a Bengaluru flyover. Photo: Hemant Mishra/Mint<br />
A file photo of a Bengaluru flyover. Photo: Hemant Mishra/Mint

Bengaluru: Traffic police are often blamed for not doing enough to keep vehicles moving during rush hour. But bad traffic is often an engineering problem and not always an enforcement problem, said Paulo Sergio Custodio, an international public transport expert who has worked with many countries, including his native Brazil, to come up with better ways to solve transport-related issues.

In an interview with Mint, he suggested a few solutions to decongesting Indian cities and why the Metro might not be the most effective means of public transport in all parts of Bengaluru.

Edited excerpts:

Why is traffic management more of an engineering problem and not a problem for the cops?

You are making this building. If you have bad engineers, they build in the wrong way. Like what happened with the Delhi BRT (Bus Rapid Transit). It was bad. Bad design and bad construction. You cannot do things in the wrong way and want them to work well. Why (is) the Ring Road (in Bengaluru) congested? Because all of those flyovers have bad design. (You) don’t have one single flyover that is well-designed.

Have you ever done a cost benefit analysis of a BRT versus a metro?

Yes. In most of the cases, if you have the space, BRT wins, clearly. Before the BRT was invented, I used to call it Metro with buses.

Would you say imposing a congestion charge is a good way to disincentivize people from using personal transport? Or are there better ways such as developing dedicated lanes where personal transport cannot enter?

It is not a question of what is better. You need to do both. Because (if) you charge the guys (but) don’t have good transportation, you are pushing them to go where? You need to give them the alternative.

Have they told you how long an average trip length is in Bengaluru?

They say it is 10.9 kilometres. Now, it takes 40 minutes. But this means this city is not a healthy city. In São Paulo (Brazil), for example, it is 8km. It means that we have much more probability that a person finds a job nearer to home than here in Bengaluru. And São Paulo is a 20 million city. Hence, São Paulo is much more better distributed than here in Bengaluru. We need to rethink the city. And this takes time. You need to think (what) the city wants to have in 20 years time.

Is it the same way in say Mexico? Here the city doesn’t do as much to regulate development. So there is all kinds of development everywhere.

Yes. But its changing. Because there was a sense that you need to control. So we have, like in other places, started having land use laws. And these land use laws are strictly enforced. You don’t have (land use regulations). Mexico started having this from the last 20 years. São Paulo had this for the last 40 years. But you need to start someday, somewhere.

You think BRT will ever work in Bengaluru?

Yes. I am sure it will.

And should it ever be a BRT versus Metro (rail decision on which to implement?

No. I think, according to the situation, one option is better than the other. Where you have space, BRT is better, because it costs six times less, maybe 10 times less (than a Metro).

Catch all the Politics News and Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.

MoreLess
First Published:16 Sep 2016, 05:42 PM IST
Business NewsPoliticsPolicyBengaluru flyovers poorly designed: Brazilian expert Paulo Sergio Custodio

Get Instant Loan up to ₹10 Lakh!

  • Employment Type

    Most Active Stocks

    Tata Steel share price

    147.55
    03:59 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    -3.35 (-2.22%)

    Tata Motors share price

    805.70
    03:58 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    -14.1 (-1.72%)

    Indian Hotels Company share price

    733.05
    03:51 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    49.45 (7.23%)

    Ashok Leyland share price

    222.00
    03:59 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    6.2 (2.87%)
    More Active Stocks

    Market Snapshot

    • Top Gainers
    • Top Losers
    • 52 Week High

    Aarti Industries share price

    474.75
    03:59 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    -40.3 (-7.82%)

    Signatureglobal India share price

    1,274.45
    03:29 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    -107.95 (-7.81%)

    Great Eastern Shipping Company share price

    1,200.50
    03:29 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    -90.45 (-7.01%)

    GMM Pfaudler share price

    1,282.90
    03:29 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    -92 (-6.69%)
    More from Top Losers

    Indian Hotels Company share price

    733.05
    03:51 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    49.45 (7.23%)

    Vijaya Diagnostic Centre share price

    1,098.90
    03:29 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    71.45 (6.95%)

    Motilal Oswal Financial Services share price

    996.05
    03:59 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    61.85 (6.62%)

    One 97 Communications share price

    848.15
    03:58 PM | 8 NOV 2024
    52.35 (6.58%)
    More from Top Gainers

    Recommended For You

      More Recommendations

      Gold Prices

      • 24K
      • 22K
      Bangalore
      79,375.000.00
      Chennai
      79,381.000.00
      Delhi
      79,533.000.00
      Kolkata
      79,385.000.00

      Fuel Price

      • Petrol
      • Diesel
      Bangalore
      102.92/L0.00
      Chennai
      100.80/L0.00
      Kolkata
      104.95/L0.00
      New Delhi
      94.77/L0.00

      Popular in Politics

        HomeMarketsPremiumInstant LoanMint Shorts