Bribes, borders and middlemen: Why GST is a game changer
GST will help reduce the immense power India’s myriad middlemen wield at state borders, free up internal trade, make it easier to do business and widen the tax base
New Delhi/Hong Kong: Seized vehicles. Bribes. Days-long delays. Moving goods across Indian states isn’t exactly easy—and that’s a major barrier to economic growth.
Rolling a truck of vegetables into Gujarat, the state once governed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, requires a bribe of Rs500 to Rs2,000 even with your papers in order, according to Rakesh Kaul, vice-president of Caravan Roadways Ltd, which has about 400 trucks plying India’s pot-holed roads.
But getting past the state tax collectors into Uttar Pradesh, India’s most populous state, will cost you more: Upwards of Rs20,000, Kaul says. The penalty for not paying off the right people is steep fines from factories whose raw materials are stuck at state borders—sometimes for as long as five days.
That’s why he and other companies are cheering the 1 July implementation of India’s biggest tax reform since independence in 1947. The move will replace more than a dozen levies with a new goods and services tax. That should help reduce the immense power India’s myriad middlemen wield at state borders, free up internal trade, make it easier to do business and widen the country’s tiny tax base.
“Even if your documents are correct, they will find some small error and hold your vehicle,” Kaul says in his New Delhi office, located in a dusty trucking depot where hundreds of drivers sit near their brightly painted trucks in the 42-degree Celsius (108-degrees Fahrenheit) heat. “Once GST is there, all that is gone.”
The new tax would be Modi’s most significant economic reform since coming to power in 2014. Yet with less than two weeks to go before its implementation, the government is still refining the details, announcing on Sunday it would relax initial filing requirements for July and August amid concerns businesses were not ready. Despite the last-minute tweaks, finance minister Arun Jaitley confirmed Wednesday the tax would roll out on 1 July.
While India already boasts one of the world’s fastest growing major economies, architects of the reform say it will stoke efficiency and growth by creating a common market of 1.3 billion consumers—a population greater than the US, Europe, Brazil, Mexico and Japan combined.
Take the border crossings: Lorry drivers in India lose 60% of transit time to road blocks, tolls and other stoppages, which means logistics costs are up to three-times higher than international benchmarks. While truck drivers may still need to stop to have their goods checked, cut that time in half, and logistics costs could fall by up to 40%, according to a 2014 World Bank report.
There’s no shortage of hyperbole when it comes to describing the GST changes, which took more than a decade of protracted negotiations before Parliament pushed it through. The government’s chief economic adviser Arvind Subramanian described it as “transformational.”
“The GST is super important,” he said in an April interview. “It is also a daring, bold experiment in what I call the good governance of cooperative federalism.”
The GST rollout comes less than a year after the government’s surprise move in November to remove 86% of currency in circulation—a decision that contributed to a sharp slowing in growth during the January to March quarter. While the GST is seen as a leap forward in simplifying India’s system, getting the reform across the line has required compromises: India will have four tax brackets instead of the flat rate many other countries have.
Air conditioners, refrigerators and makeup will be taxed at 28%, for example, while toothpaste lands at 18%. Plane tickets attract a 5% GST rate, but business class tickets are 12%. Staples such as food grains and fresh vegetables are not taxed, while education and health services will continue to be exempted.
“India is obviously a huge and complex country in which governments’ ability successfully to implement major reforms is limited,” said Ian Hall, acting director of the Griffith Asia Institute.
The incoming GST will also force companies to consolidate their supply chain among fewer, larger facilities, says Vineet Agarwal, the managing director of Transport Corp. of India Ltd, which has about 10,000 trucks and around 11 million square feet of warehouses.
Currently, companies operate smaller factories and warehouses to take advantage of tax breaks offered by various states, as well as to avoid transporting goods over too many borders. “Literally, almost all states act like different countries,” Agarwal said.
One of the biggest goals of the GST is to widen the tax net in an economy where more than 90% of workers are employed informally. Companies will need to be in the tax system and prove they paid taxes to claim a credit against their costs. Pressure to comply will increase along the line and the black economy should shrink.
Still, the tax may throw up losers. Manufacturing states may initially suffer as the extra revenue is generated in more populous consuming states. There are also sectors untouched by the new tax, including alcohol and real estate. Thousands of tax staff will also need to be trained and complex new IT systems adopted.
“There will inevitably be disruption as a result of the implementation of the GST,” said Samir Saran, vice-president of the New Delhi-based Observer Research Foundation.
To be sure, India isn’t alone in introducing a new tax that crosses jurisdictions and territories. More than 150 countries have a value added tax or GST including Canada, Australia and the European Union, according to Deloitte.
The optimistic case is that initial ruffles are soon smoothed over, according to Eswar Prasad, a professor at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. “As in the case of the recent demonetisation gambit, any disruption in commerce and economic activity is likely to be short-lived, while the longer-term benefits could be significant,” he said.
Big companies will be prepared, Agarwal at Transport Corp. says, but he frets about the smaller, informal businesses. “There’s going to be chaos,” he says.
That informal workforce includes Babu Ram Rajput, a 28-year-old trucker in jeans and sandals who regularly drives goods across a vast swathe of north India. “I have not got any training,” he says, holding up a sheaf of tattered, dirty documents related to his current cargo. “I only know that GST is coming.” Bloomberg