Fiscal test: As India’s smaller firms struggle, Modi faces stimulus dilemma4 min read . Updated: 10 Oct 2017, 08:23 AM IST
Stepping up stimulus could reduce political damage for Narendra Modi ahead of a round of state elections beginning in December but shatter the confidence of investors worried about fiscal slippage
New Delhi/Mumbai: India’s festive season should be a time of celebration for textiles businessman Habib Ansari, who usually spends October counting a boom in profits from supplying retailers ahead of a month of peak shopping.
This year Ansari is grappling with losses, and blames a 50% drop in sales in the last three months on confusion wrought by the July launch of a national sales tax and the after-effects of a government crackdown on untaxed wealth.
“Small garment units are not buying due to weak demand. We have cut down our workforce to 600 from 1200," Ansari said from a textiles hub outside Mumbai, as laid off labourers napped in nearby warehouses.
Ansari’s woes highlight how Asia’s third-largest economy has cooled rapidly over five consecutive quarters as small and -medium-sized businesses across India report tumbling sales, undermining job creation and damaging sentiment in industries crucial to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s political powerbase. That has pushed Modi into a tight corner—stepping up stimulus could reduce political damage ahead of a round of state elections beginning in December but shatter the confidence of investors worried about fiscal slippage.
The government is considering spending between Rs40,000-50,000 crore ($7.7 billion) more this financial year than it had budgeted for, two senior finance ministry officials told Reuters.
New Delhi has already cut petrol and diesel taxes, but the focus now is on whether to spend more money on rural jobs, housing and recapitalisation of state-run banks, or to give targeted relief to sectors hit hardest by sliding growth, the officials said.
“We face our toughest challenge in three years," said a government official, adding fiscal consolidation was under pressure amid slowing revenue receipts.
The economy grew at an annual 5.7% year-on-year in the three months to end-June, its slowest in three years, while tax collection is falling—a turnaround from a year ago when India boasted the fastest growth among major economies.
People close to Modi, who romped to power in a landslide victory for his Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in 2014, say he wants to control the political damage and ensure the economic slowdown remains temporary.
Two BJP grandees, Yashwant Sinha, an ex-finance minister, and Arun Shourie, a former cabinet minister, have been critical of Modi’s recent handling of economic reforms.
But the prime minister has to walk a tight rope as pandering to populist policies could risk damaging investor confidence. The BJP has won praise from investors after trimming the fiscal deficit from 4.5% of GDP in 2013/14.
When the government last month hinted at more spending, India’s stock market skidded for seven consecutive days and the rupee dropped to its lowest level in six months as investors worried about the impact on public debt.
On 28 September , the government decided against announcing more borrowing and maintained a target for the 2017/18 financial year in line with a deficit of 3.2%, a move welcomed by markets.
Modi could seek parliament’s approval for up to Rs50,000 crore in extra spending over the budgeted spending, the two finance ministry officials said, which could widen the fiscal deficit to a three-year high of around 3.7% of GDP.
India’s former chief economist, Arvind Virmani, told Reuters there was no scope for additional spending.
Small business crunched
Acknowledging the slide in sentiment, Modi took the rare step last week of defending his record in a 90-minute speech, calling the economic slowdown a blip, and promising relief. Small and medium-sized businesses across India are meanwhile cutting staff because of falling demand.
The launch in July of the long-awaited goods and services tax (GST), which transformed India’s 29 states into a single customs union, has left firms at the bottom of the supply chain short of working capital.
That came on top of Modi’s “demonetisation" decision last November, in which he suddenly banned high-denomination banknotes to force people to declare illicit or untaxed wealth. Smaller enterprises accustomed to dealing entirely in cash are now required to register themselves under the GST and to file tax returns.
Rashid Tahir Momin, treasurer of the Bhiwandi Powerloom Weavers Federation, said more than 200,000 people have lost their jobs since July in the textiles hub outside Mumbai.
Previously exempt of tax or taxed at lower rates, the requirement to pay higher taxes and then claim them back has left the government owing $10 billion to the textiles, jewellery and other exporting industries.
On Friday, the government announced it would ease tax rules to help smaller businesses.
Narendra Jadhav, a lawmaker close to Modi, said the government was operating with “a great sense of urgency" to resolve the problems faced by the small and medium enterprises.
“Complaints are being noted and addressed. We are committed to bring about structural changes, create jobs and improve infrastructure,“ Jadhav said.
Finance minister Arun Jaitley had estimated a 16.4% rise in tax receipts to $188.7 billion this year, but the government faces a shortfall of up to Rs1 trillion following the GST launch, one of the two finance ministry officials said.
India’s fiscal deficit including federal and state borrowing is close to 6%, and the central bank governor, Urjit Patel, warned this month that further widening could hit fiscal stability.
Mahesh Vyas, head of the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy, said that Rs50,000 crore of extra spending would not be sufficient to turn the economy round.
“The government should send a clear message whether it wants to provide a stimulus or not," he said.
“The uncertainty is hitting markets and any small stimulus would just be a waste of money." Reuters