Under fire, Europe works to bolster debt crisis fund4 min read . Updated: 26 Sep 2011, 10:35 AM IST
Under fire, Europe works to bolster debt crisis fund
Under fire, Europe works to bolster debt crisis fund
Washington: European policymakers, stung by criticism for failing to stem the euro zone debt crisis, began working on new ways to stop fallout from Greece’s near-bankruptcy from inflicting more damage on the world economy.
After a weekend of being told by the United States, China and other countries that they must get more aggressive in their crisis response, European officials focused on ways to beef up their existing €440 billion rescue fund.
Deep differences remained over whether the European Central Bank should commit more of its massive resources to shoring up Europe’s banks and help struggling euro zone member countries.
Financial markets have plunged on concerns about the ability of Europe to get a grip on the crisis.
US treasury chief Timothy Geithner, in unusually blunt comments, said the risks from Europe were enormous.
“The threat of cascading default, bank runs, and catastrophic risk must be taken off the table," he said in speech to the International Monetary Fund on Saturday.
Europe came under more pressure on Sunday when a top IMF official said the ECB was the only player big enough to “scare" financial markets which have punished many euro zone members.
“The ECB is the only agent that can really scare the markets," Antonio Borges, the IMF’s top official for Europe, told top economic policymakers from around the world.
However, Germany and many top officials within the ECB itself are wary about the central bank being drawn more deeply into supporting Greece and other debt-stricken states.
“It is not helpful that we have an avalanche of new proposals every week," ECB governing council member Ewald Nowotny said.
Markets fear that European banks could be dragged down by their exposure to Greece and other debt-strapped euro zone nations, and analysts say a bailout fund of around €2 trillion would be needed if the crisis spread to Italy and Spain.
A senior European official hinted that kind of firepower was being contemplated. “We need to find a mechanism where we can turn one euro in the EFSF into five, but there is no decision on how we could do that yet," the official said.
Markets showed little reaction to the new push by Europe to tackle the crisis. The euro was little changed in trading in Asia and US S&P stock futures were down about 0.3%.
“For all the reassurances that you can get from the Europeans, I think that we’re very, very far away from getting a huge announcement of a very large amount of money," said Enrique Alvarez, head of research at IDEAglobal in New York.
Greece meets IMF in bid for more cash
Greece, the country at the epicenter of the crisis, is trying to secure its latest wad of cash from international lenders including the IMF next month to avoid a default.
Finance minister Evangelos Venizelos, speaking to bankers in Washington, said Greece was determined to stay the course of its tough austerity plan to meet terms of its bailout package.
He complained the outside world did not understand the severity of the measures that Greece is taking by cutting pensions, salaries and public spending but he insisted the country will “make it" through the crisis.
In Athens, Greek riot police fired tear gas at anti-austerity protesters pelting them with bottles outside parliament in the first such unrest after a summer lull.
“Greece is not the scapegoat of the euro area or the international economy," Venizelos said.
But IMF and European negotiators are frustrated at what they say is Greece’s slow reform pace.
Venizelos met IMF chief Christine Lagarde on Sunday and afterward the IMF said a mission would head back to Greece possibly as soon as this week to assess progress.
The European Union and IMF have already bailed out Greece, Portugal and Ireland, and officials want to stop the crisis from spreading to Italy, Spain and possibly beyond.
The European Union’s top economic official, Olli Rehn, said on Saturday that as soon as the region’s governments confirm new powers for the bailout fund -- the European Financial Stability Facility -- attention would turn to how to get more impact from the existing money.
The new powers are expected to be ratified by mid-October. Germany’s parliament votes this week on them.
Germany opposes contributing more money to help countries it sees as profligate and the focus has now turned to ways to leverage the existing bailout fund, possibly through the ECB.
Klaus Regling, who heads Europe’s bailout program, said leveraging the fund’s resources did not necessarily need to involve the ECB.
One top ECB official said Europe might follow the lead of the United States, which rewrote its financial rule book to cope with the 2007-2009 credit crisis.
ECB executive board member Lorenzo Bini Smaghi said there could be a European equivalent of the US TARP program, which helped shore up the shaky banking system, or the TALF, which provided some liquidity to parched US credit markets.
“I think both scenarios can be followed.... I think that these two options could solve the problem," he said.
A former US policymaker summed up the frustration voiced by many investors and commentators.
“In Europe, they’ve kind of turned this into a bad Monty Python skit, where, you know, the guy comes out and says, ‘We need to act,’ and the next one says, ‘You’re right, let’s draft -- no more talking..., ‘I second the motion. Let’s start doing something,’" said Austan Goolsbee, formerly chief White House economic advisor.
“I mean, they’re not actually doing anything. They just keep agreeing that they’re going to work in concert."