The 53-45 vote fell short of the 60 votes needed to advance the measure as Republicans rejected Senate majority leader Harry Reid’s approach.
The vote came just hours after House Speaker John Boehner told fellow Republicans that President Barack Obama rejected his latest fiscal offer. Reid and Senate minority leader Mitch McConnell are talking to each other and Reid rejected the Republicans’ first offer because it ties conditions to the debt limit, said a Democratic aide speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss the private meeting.
“It’s been clear to me for a while we can’t wait for the House to save us," said Richard Durbin of Illinois, the second- ranking Senate Democrat. “We have to find our own bipartisan path forward, and we haven’t done that yet."
The emerging Senate talks have been focusing on a plan from Republican Susan Collins of Maine and Democrat Joe Manchin of West Virginia, which faces obstacles in both parties and both chambers of Congress.
That plan would delay a tax on medical devices for two years, while making up lost revenue through pension-rule changes and extend government funding for six months. It would push the next debt-limit fight to the end of January and give agencies more flexibility to allocate funds, said two Senate aides with knowledge of the proposal who sought anonymity to discuss the private talks.
The plan would require the Obama administration to verify income levels for enrolment in health-care benefits, and set a mid-January deadline for longer-term budget talks, they said.
The detailed text of Collins’ proposal could be released later on Saturday, said a Democratic aide familiar with the plan who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss the proposal.
“I think elements of my plan will be in the final compromise that brings an end to this impasse," Collins told reporters as she entered a meeting of fellow Senate Republicans on Saturday.
For the past two days, the prospects for a potential deal had focused on talks between Boehner and Obama that would push the lapse of borrowing authority to 22 November from 17 October. Republicans also wanted to attach policy conditions to a separate spending bill that would end the government shutdown.
Reid, a Nevada Democrat, said talks between the White House and House Republicans were done.
The White House on Saturday declined to comment on the budget situation.
Boehner also told members that talks are continuing with the White House, according to another person in the room who sought anonymity to discuss the private meeting.
Still, Representative Bill Flores of Texas said the “president is not talking to us". He said Obama “is trying to talk to the Senate Republicans and trying to split them up so that Reid can jam a deal together".
House Republicans oppose several aspects of Collins’ plan. They want a larger dent in the 2010 health care law such as a delay of the mandate for individuals to purchase health insurance. Representative Hal Rogers, chairman of the House Appropriations Committee, also rejected the idea of a six-month spending bill.
Obama has insisted that he wouldn’t accept policy conditions attached to a debt-limit increase or a spending bill, though Jay Carney, the White House press secretary, hedged on the spending bill on Friday.
“The president has a number of concerns about Boehner’s proposal," Carney told reporters on Friday after Boehner and Obama spoke by telephone about the speaker’s offer.
Extending the debt ceiling for a short period while budget talks occur may lead to a replay of the same brinkmanship the US is experiencing now, Carney said.
The emerging Senate plan has no chance in the House, said Representative John Fleming of Louisiana after a party meeting on Saturday. He said there was no reason for the House to pass a short-term debt-limit increase. The House completed voting today and isn’t scheduled to return until late on 14 October.
“Every offer we’ve made they just flat turned us down without any counter-offer," Fleming said. “Our level of expectations for the president has gradually dropped over the years to a point where we don’t expect anything from President Obama."
White House officials opened the door to talks on ending the government shutdown, even as they held firm on raising the debt ceiling without conditions. When asked whether the White House was shifting its position, Carney said the administration was encouraged by constructive signs coming from the Republicans.
The indications of progress bolstered financial markets on Friday. US shares rallied for a second day following the biggest jump since January and gold plunged to a three-month low while the yen weakened and oil slid. The Standard and Poor’s 500 Index rose 0.6% to 1,703.20 on Friday in New York after jumping 2.2% the previous day.
The rate on $93 billion in treasury bills due 24 October was at 0.26%, according to Bloomberg Bond Trader data, after climbing as high as 0.50% on 10 October. It was zero as recently as 19 September. The rate on bills due 29 November was at 0.16%, the highest since the security was issued.
The shutdown has led to hundreds of thousands of federal employees being furloughed or receiving partial paychecks. It has also closed federal services such as national parks.
The medical device tax is potentially attractive to lawmakers in both parties. It has drawn opposition from Democrats who represent states with device makers, including Massachusetts and Minnesota.
Republicans could say they made a change to Obamacare, because the medical-device tax was passed as part of the 2010 law. Obama could say he didn’t negotiate on the principles of the health-care law, because eliminating the tax wouldn’t end the individual mandate or other main components of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
Durbin said he was open to changes in the device tax, though he had concerns about other industries taxed in the law seeking similar treatment.
“I don’t want to pay dearly for short-term relief," he said. “Open the government first, pay our bills. Then we negotiate."
If the US fails to raise the debt limit by 17 October, the government will have $30 billion plus incoming revenue to pay its bills. It would start missing scheduled payments, including benefits, salaries and interest, between 22 October and 31 October, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
Republicans, who have called for defunding or delaying Obamacare, have reduced their demands over the past few weeks. The House has demonstrated an incredible amount of flexibility, Representative Peter Roskam of Illinois said on Bloomberg Television’s Capitol Gains airing this weekend. He is the House Republicans’ chief deputy whip.
A deal built around repealing the medical-device tax would be a hollow victory and further divide Republicans, said Representative Tim Huelskamp of Kansas, one of the House Republicans still pushing to dismantle the health-care law.
“It would still fund 98% of Obamacare," Huelskamp said of the latest Republican proposal. “That won’t be sufficient for conservatives and will be seen as capitulating to the left."
Any prospective deal faces questions, including whether Boehner can come to an agreement with Obama and not lose the support of his hardline members. They’ve sought to use the debt ceiling and government shutdown to force curbs on Obamacare and federal spending. Bloomebrg
Chris Strohm, Julianna Goldman, Caitlin Webber, Lisa Lerer, Terry Atlas and Richard Rubin in Washington contributed to this story.