Alok Verma’s two-year tenure ends on January 31. Photo: HT
Alok Verma’s two-year tenure ends on January 31. Photo: HT

Fight between CBI bosses exposed agency to ridicule, SC told

The fight between two CBI officers created an extraordinary situation and the government watched with 'amazement' as to what these two were doing: Attorney general K.K. Venugopal

New Delhi: The Centre on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that the fight between two top officers of the CBI — director Alok Verma and special director Rakesh Asthana — in public exposed the premier probe agency to ridicule.

Attorney general K.K. Venugopal told a Bench headed by chief justice Ranjan Gogoi that the fight between the two officers affected the image of the CBI.

The Centre’s main aim was to see that confidence of the public in this premier institution was restored, he said. “Dispute between CBI director and special director was pulling down integrity and respect of the premier institution," he told the Bench, also comprising justices S.K. Kaul and K.M. Joseph.

“Two top officers, Alok Kumar Verma and Rakesh Asthana, were fighting against each other and went public, which exposed CBI to ridicule," Venugopal told the Bench.

He said the fight between them had created an unprecedented and extraordinary situation and the Government of India was watching with “amazement" as to what these two officers were doing.

“They were fighting like Kilkenny cats," Venugopal said, adding, it was absolutely essential for the Centre to step in and act in the tussle between two officers.

He also submitted that the Centre acted within its jurisdiction on complaints made in July and October this year. “If the government had not done so, only God knows where and how this fight between the two top officers would have ended," Venugopal told the Bench.

The attorney general concluded his arguments and now solicitor general Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC), started making the submissions.

The Centre had perused the report of the CVC, which on Asthana’s complaint against Verma had made some recommendations. After that two officers were sent on leave.

Later, the apex court had directed the CVC to probe the complaint against Verma. The report was submitted to the court in a sealed cover.

After a brief submission by Mehta, the apex court concluded the day’s hearing and posted the matter for further arguments for Thursday.

The Supreme Court on November 29 had said it would first consider whether the government had the power to divest the CBI director of his duties under whatever circumstances, or whether the selection committee headed by the Prime Minister should have been approached before moving against Verma.

The court had taken this stand after making it clear that for now it was not going into the allegations and counter-allegations involving Alok Verma and CBI’s No.2 officer Rakesh Asthana. Both Alok Verma and Rakesh Asthana had been stripped of their powers and sent on leave following their bitter feud.

Verma’s two-year tenure ends on January 31. He has challenged the Centre’s decision.

This story has been published from a wire agency feed without modifications to the text. Only the headline has been changed.

Close