SC/ST verdict: Centre seeks constitution bench, says Supreme Court cannot legislate

Attorney general said the Supreme Court had stepped into the realm of legislation through its March verdict preventing automatic arrests on complaints filed under SC/ST Act 1989

Priyanka Mittal
Published3 May 2018, 10:30 PM IST
Attorney general K.K. Venugopal argued that the top court could not legislate and should observe the principle of separation of powers. Photo: Mint
Attorney general K.K. Venugopal argued that the top court could not legislate and should observe the principle of separation of powers. Photo: Mint

New Delhi: The Supreme Court had stepped into the realm of legislation through its March order preventing automatic arrests on complaints filed under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (SC/ST Act), attorney general K.K. Venugopal argued before the court today.

The attorney general sought the matter to be placed before a constitution bench comprising five judges.

“A complete new set of rules has to be observed in all cases now. The SC/ST Act and the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973, effectively stand amended. You cannot declare that the law in the country will be this, contrary to the existing law”, he said.

According to him, the top court could not legislate and should observe the principle of separation of powers.

The attorney general said members of the SC/ST community had been subjected to 1,000-2,000 years of suppression and the nature of atrocities against them demanded that they be amply protected under law.

Justice U.U. Lalit clarified that the judgment did not say that there should be no registration of crime against complaints by SC/ST member but there should be a filter placed on the arrests following the complaints to ensure that there is a need to arrest the person in question.

A similar clarification had been given by Justice A.K. Goel at an earlier hearing, where he said that the court was not trying to stand in the way of the rights of members of the scheduled castes and scheduled tribes and was concentrating on preventing the implication of an innocent person.

The court was hearing the Centre’s review petition challenging a ruling that prevented automatic arrests on complaints filed under the SC/ST Act.

The government’s decision to approach the court in a review petition came after the top court’s order passed in March raised concerns over a possible dilution of the law meant to protect the marginalised section of society.

The Centre sought a review of the judgement, saying it was vitiated by the fact that the court had proceeded on the basis that it can legislate and has the power to make law when none exists.

This is “wholly fallacious” as we live under a written Constitution, of which “separation of powers between the legislatures, the executive and the judiciary is the very basic structure and is inviolable”, it added.

The order “adversely affects a substantial portion of the population of India who are SC/ST members”. It is also “contrary to the legislative policy of the Parliament” as reflected in the Act, it said.

It is also the Centre’s stand that any dilution of the provisions of the amended SC/ST Act would result in depriving the community of its constitutional rights.

On 20 March, a bench of justices Lalit and Goel held a public servant could be arrested only after the approval of the appointing authority and a non-public servant only after the approval of the senior superintendent of police, if considered necessary, for reasons recorded.

The ruling triggered protests by Dalit groups across the country, with sporadic violence during a Bharat Bandh on 2 April.

On 3 April, the top court refused to keep in abeyance the order preventing automatic arrests on complaints filed under the SC/ST Act and asked the parties to file written submissions within two days.

The case will be heard next on 16 May.

Catch all the Politics News and Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.

MoreLess
First Published:3 May 2018, 10:30 PM IST
Business NewsPoliticsPolicySC/ST verdict: Centre seeks constitution bench, says Supreme Court cannot legislate

Get Instant Loan up to ₹10 Lakh!

  • Employment Type

    Most Active Stocks

    ITC share price

    481.55
    02:52 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    1.5 (0.31%)

    Tata Steel share price

    153.05
    02:52 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    0.75 (0.49%)

    Infosys share price

    1,821.75
    02:52 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    67.95 (3.87%)

    Larsen & Toubro share price

    3,636.50
    02:52 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    61.1 (1.71%)
    More Active Stocks

    Market Snapshot

    • Top Gainers
    • Top Losers
    • 52 Week High

    EPL share price

    273.30
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    11.3 (4.31%)

    Firstsource Solutions share price

    385.25
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    15.85 (4.29%)

    National Aluminium Company share price

    244.80
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    9.8 (4.17%)

    City Union Bank share price

    179.55
    02:42 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    0.85 (0.48%)
    More from 52 Week High

    Hindustan Zinc share price

    514.65
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    -44.8 (-8.01%)

    Five Star Business Finance share price

    655.15
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    -18.5 (-2.75%)

    Great Eastern Shipping Company share price

    1,259.10
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    -34.9 (-2.7%)

    Triveni Engineering & Indus share price

    406.65
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    -10.6 (-2.54%)
    More from Top Losers

    CCL Products India share price

    732.00
    02:43 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    63.6 (9.52%)

    Eclerx Services share price

    3,304.60
    02:43 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    272.7 (8.99%)

    Piramal Pharma share price

    298.00
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    24.4 (8.92%)

    Dixon Technologies (India) share price

    15,572.10
    02:44 PM | 6 NOV 2024
    1176.1 (8.17%)
    More from Top Gainers

    Recommended For You

      More Recommendations

      Gold Prices

      • 24K
      • 22K
      Bangalore
      80,365.00110.00
      Chennai
      80,371.00110.00
      Delhi
      80,523.00110.00
      Kolkata
      80,375.00110.00

      Fuel Price

      • Petrol
      • Diesel
      Bangalore
      102.92/L0.00
      Chennai
      100.80/L0.00
      Kolkata
      104.95/L0.00
      New Delhi
      94.77/L0.00

      Popular in Politics

        HomeMarketsPremiumInstant LoanMint Shorts