Edward Snowden still in Moscow despite Bolivian plane drama4 min read . Updated: 04 Jul 2013, 01:52 PM IST
Bolivia enraged by plane incident; Austria says Edward Snowden was not on Evo Morales’ plane
Vienna/Geneva: Bolivia accused the US on Wednesday of trying to “kidnap" its president, Evo Morales, after his plane was denied permission to fly over some European countries on suspicion he was taking fugitive former US spy agency contractor Edward Snowden to Latin America.
Bolivia said the incident, in which the plane was denied permission to fly over France and Portugal before making a stop in Vienna, was an act of aggression and a violation of international law.
Snowden was not on the plane when it landed in Vienna, an Austrian official said. He is believed to be stranded in the transit lounge of a Moscow airport and the US has been trying to get its hands on him since he revealed details of its secret surveillance programmes last month.
The White House declined to comment on the Bolivian assertion.
Latin American countries were also fuming over the plane incident, with heads of state in the 12-nation South American bloc Unasur denouncing the “unfriendly and unjustifiable acts".
The bloc said a group of leaders from member countries would hold an emergency summit in Bolivia on Thursday to discuss the matter. Unasur includes close leftist allies of Bolivia like Venezuela, Ecuador and Argentina as well as more centrist governments like those in Chile and Brazil.
The furore was the latest twist in a saga that has raised debate over the balance between privacy rights and national security. Revelations of US surveillance on European countries have also strained transatlantic relations.
France said on Wednesday that free-trade talks between the European Union and the US should be delayed by two weeks given tensions over media reports, stemming from the Snowden case, that Washington is spying on the 28-nation bloc.
‘No one else on board’
The Bolivian plane was taking Morales home from an energy conference in Moscow when it landed at Vienna airport on Tuesday evening. Austrian Deputy Chancellor Michael Spindelegger said Morales personally denied that Snowden was aboard his jet and agreed to a voluntary inspection.
“Based on this invitation from Bolivia, a colleague boarded the plane, looked at everything and there was no one else on board," Spindelegger told reporters.
But Bolivian defence minister Ruben Saavedra said Morales’ plane was not searched because Morales had refused Austrian authorities entry.
Bolivia’s ambassador to the United Nations, Sacha Llorenti Soliz, expressed outrage at the chain of events.
“We’re talking about the president on an official trip after an official summit being kidnapped," he said in Geneva.
“We have no doubt that it was an order from the White House. By no means should a diplomatic plane with the president be diverted from its route and forced to land in another country."
Morales’ plane eventually left Vienna and landed in Spain’s Canary Islands for refuelling before heading back to Bolivia. Morales was expected back in Bolivia Wednesday night.
The Bolivian government said it had filed a formal complaint with the United Nations and was studying other legal avenues to prove its rights had been violated under international law.
The United Nations said in a statement that the secretary-general understood the Bolivian government’s concerns and urged the countries concerned to discuss the matter.
The Obama administration has advised foreign governments that allowing Snowden to land on their territory could seriously damage their relations with the US, European and US national security sources said.
The sources said the administration believed such lobbying played a role in persuading countries to which Snowden had applied for asylum to reject or not respond to his bid. The US believes its diplomacy also has caused countries whose leaders publicly expressed sympathy for Snowden to have second thoughts about the matter in private, they said.
A spokesman at France’s foreign ministry blamed the incident on “an administrative mishap," saying France never intended to ban Morales from its airspace and that there were delays in getting confirmation that the plane had fly-over permits.
International agreements allow civilian airplanes to overfly countries without obtaining permission before every flight. But state aircraft, including Air Force One, which carries the US president, must obtain clearance before they cross into foreign territory.
Demanding an explanation
The treatment of the Bolivian military aircraft hit a nerve in Latin America, which has a history of US-backed coups.
In a statement from Peru’s government, which holds the group’s presidency, Unasur expressed outrage and indignation that the plane was not allowed to land in Portugal and France.
“(These are) vestiges of a colonialism that we thought were long over. We believe this constitutes not only the humiliation of a sister nation but of all South America," Argentine President Cristina Kirchner said in a speech in Buenos Aires.
“Latin America demands an explanation," tweeted Ecuadorean President Rafael Correa. “If what happened to Evo does not merit a Unasur summit, I don’t know what does."
In the Bolivian capital, La Paz, the US Embassy said late on Wednesday its Independence Day party on Thursday had been put off “until further notice."
Bolivia is among more than a dozen countries where Snowden has sought asylum and Morales has said he would consider granting the American refuge. But he said earlier this week no request had been made.
The 30-year-old Snowden, who worked for the National Security Agency as a contractor in Hawaii, has been trying since 23 June to find a country that will offer him refuge from prosecution in the US on espionage charges.
But his options have narrowed since he arrived in Moscow from Hong Kong with no valid travel documents after the US revoked his passport.
Five countries have rejected granting Snowden asylum, seven have said they would consider a request if made on their soil, and eight said they had either not made a decision or not received a request.
Russian President Vladimir Putin is unwilling to send Snowden to the US, with which Russia has no extradition treaty. But he is also reluctant to damage ties over a man for whom Putin, a former KGB spy, has little sympathy.