Will Modi 3.0 have to favour populism over big bang reforms?

Gireesh Chandra Prasad, Rhik Kundu
4 min read4 Jun 2024, 07:58 PM IST
logo
Congress Rahul Gandhi, NCP chief Sharad Pawar and CPI(M) general secretary Sitaram Yechury show victory signs after attending the INDIA Bloc meeting at the residence of Mallikarjun Kharge, in New Delhi. (Photo: ANI)
Summary
  • With the BJP dependent on its coalition partners to form the government, some populism could creep into policy making, experts said.

New Delhi: Freebies and populist welfare measures that the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government sidestepped in its interim budget for FY25 could make it to the agenda of the next government with a weakened Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP) having to rely on allies for a third term in office and to further build its political capital, said analysts and political observers.

That could get reflected in the full-year budget for FY25, as the government has benefited from a bigger-than-expected Reserve Bank of India dividend of ₹2.11 trillion for FY24, said a person informed about discussions in the Modi government. 

The dividend has to be accounted for in FY25, and some of this fiscal room could be utilized for new schemes, said the person, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

“Big-bang reforms will be difficult for some time as the political capital is limited. Also, populism could make a comeback,” said the person.

The BJP had accorded priority to fiscal prudence and macroeconomic stability in the last 10 years and resisted pressure for printing money during the pandemic years. It has also taken a serious view of state governments with limited fiscal room announcing freebies financed by debt.

“I think there would be a greater recognition of the rural distress, the acute and chronic unemployment problem and high food prices, which might require some adjustment in the full- year budget and then we might see some higher allocations for some subsidies and the rural job guarantee scheme (MGNREGS). Luckily the revenue position of the Central government is quite robust. So some of these additional expenditures may be easily accommodated without a significant compromise on the fiscal consolidation roadmap,” said D.K. Srivastava, EY’s chief policy advisor.

“While the overall focus on infrastructure and capex could continue, some fiscal room may need to be made for populist measures,” said UBS Securities India Pvt. Ltd. in an analysis on Tuesday.

At the time of publishing, BJP was on course to winning 238 seats, significantly short of the 272 seats needed to gain a majority in the Lok Sabha. But it was likely to form the government because the coalition it leads, the NDA, was leading or winning in about 290 seats. In the previous elections, BJP alone had won 303 seats, and the NDA, 352.

Meanwhile, the opposition INDIA coalition was on course to winning 234 seats in the 543-seat lower house. INDIA refers to the Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance comprising Congress and its partners.

Also read: Ignoring rural distress, jobs hurt BJP: Experts

In the past three years, the NDA has focused on sustaining and building upon the post-pandemic average growth rate of 8.3% while maintaining fiscal credibility and, at the same time, ensuring wealth redistribution through effectively administered welfare measures.

Populist measures were conspicuously absent in the interim budget presented by the NDA government on 1 February as it laid emphasis on infrastructure spending and macroeconomic stability.

Tax revenue buoyancy achieved because of reforms and formalization of the economy had provided the NDA administration resources for not only infrastructure building but also for social transfers.

This time, though, allies have become crucial in government formation—especially Chandrababu Naidu-led Telugu Desam Party (TDP) and Nitish Kumar's Janata Dal United—which could give them more influence in policy matters.

Once the NDA forms the government, some reforms measures can be introduced, but “nothing very controversial”, the person quoted above said. Inflation and unemployment, two campaign issues highlighted by the Congress party, are likely to remain high on the radar of policy makers.

A.K. Verma, director of the Centre for Study of Society and Politics, an independent think tank based in Kanpur, expressed surprise at BJP’s reduced poll returns despite its focus on development and effective welfare delivery. 

“The NDA government has not only been a provider for vulnerable sections of society, but also an enabler for their empowerment while also strengthening the economy. Somehow, the alliance could not capitalize on them.”

Issues on the table

A host of issues are vying for the next government's attention. Among top-priority ones, experts pointed to fixing weaknesses in the education system to improve learning outcomes; skilling people to ensure that a larger workforce adds to national income, tackling geopolitical uncertainties; boosting the manufacturing sector; sustaining public investments on infrastructure till private investments gains further momentum; and further strengthening the micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs). De-carbonization of the economy and climate action are also on the priority list.

Also read: Economic reforms may slow down as ruling BJP fails to get majority on its own

Rumki Majumdar, economist at Deloitte India said India must focus on resilience in the face of geopolitical challenges through trade diversification, strategic trade partnerships, and energy security initiatives.

Devendra Kumar Pant, chief economist at India Ratings and Research, said the issues before the new government are maintaining growth momentum of the past three years, fiscal consolidation, tackling unemployment and revival of consumption. The government should also increase the share of manufacturing in gross value-added, he added.

According to Sujan Hajra, chief economist at Anand Rathi Securities, the return of the NDA government led by the BJP signifies a continuation of the policies pursued over the past decade.

Industry leaders are pinning hopes on the new government for reforms in several areas including in the startup ecosystem and fintechs with soft-touch regulations.

“We expect the incoming government to give a lot of focus on employment generation, human resource development and increased workforce participation, especially women,” said Sanjay Nayar, president of industry body Assocham.

Also read: Mamata Banerjee asks PM Modi to 'immediately resign' as NDA heads for muted win

MSMEs, equipped with technology and adequate credit, can be a major multiplier for job creation while large enterprises should champion India’s imprint in the global economy, said Nayar.

Meanwhile, Deloitte’s Majumdar made a case for measures to boost growth in emerging sectors like semiconductors, electronics, pharmaceuticals, specialty chemicals, electric vehicles and defence, in addition to boosting manufacturing.

 

About the Author

Rhik writes about the Indian economy and its crucial indicators. He is constantly navigating corporates, decoding policies, and dabbling with everything in between.

Catch all the Business News , Economy news , Breaking News Events andLatest News Updates on Live Mint. Download TheMint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

More