Decline in pledged shares sends promoters running for cover3 min read . Updated: 22 Mar 2020, 11:47 PM IST
- The value of pledged shareholding has fallen by almost 30% amid the bloodbath in the past few weeks
- Firms with steep fall in pledged promoter shareholding value include Future Retail, SpiceJet
Promoters who borrowed heavily by pledging company shares are in a soup as the market meltdown erodes collateral value, triggering loan covenants that force them to prepay loans, bring in more shares, or—in the worst case—see their companies slip out of control as those shares are sold in the market.
Data for pledged promoter shares of BSE 500 companies showed that amid the bloodbath in the past few weeks, the value of pledged shareholding has fallen by almost 30%. The total value of pledged promoter shares of these companies has come down to ₹1.27 trillion as on 20 March, from ₹1.78 trillion on 31 December.
Some of the companies with steep declines in pledged promoter shareholding value include Future Retail, SpiceJet, IndusInd Bank and Gayatri Projects. These companies have seen some of the highest percentage decline in pledge values, to date. In terms of absolute value of pledged shares, companies that have seen major declines include companies from the Adani group, Future group as well as JSW Steel and Emami Ltd.
In some cases, rating agencies have flagged the risk that falling prices carry for pledged shareholding. On 20 March, rating agency Icra downgraded Future group promoter entity Future Corporate Resources to below investment grade (BB+) citing high debt levels and substantial increase in pledged shareholding due to the decline in stock prices.
“Borrowings against listed securities is generally a very commoditized segment where you have standard covenants or trigger levels and promoters will have to top up collateral by offering more shares up to a certain point and then provide cash margins," said Rakshat Kapoor, fund manager and chief investment officer of Centrum Credit Opportunities Fund.
“In cases where absolute leverage is high, promoters won’t have too many more shares to pledge with every lender and they can’t pledge above a certain level as that will start impacting covenants at the operating company level loans. So, promoters will have to bring in some cash to top up their collaterals," he added.
However, several promoters are unlikely to be able to cope with the situation given the drastic fall in their stock prices and stretched promoter balance sheets. Experts said that there could be several cases of loan restructuring or strategic trades in cases where promoters are not able to bring in fresh collaterals.
“Lenders could allow for more time by extending the repayment period. Some lenders will restructure these loans given this is a force majeure event," said Sudhir Dash, founder and CEO at advisory firm UnaPrime.
“In situations where loans have already been restructured and promoters are out of options to bring more capital, lenders could look to take control of underlying assets and seek a strategic transaction," he added.
According to Kapoor of Centrum Credit Opportunities Fund, in cases where promoter leverage is low and operations are running fine, lenders would rather restructure loans than sell shares in the open market. “This is not a company-specific event, it is a macro issue. So in cases, where promoter leverage is low and company is doing well, they may opt to restructure the loan by taking other additional collateral and provide some moratorium on loan repayments," said Kapoor
Invoking share pledges at these prices and in these markets will further reduce share price and moreover you still won’t have buyers given the market situation, he added. Dash added that promoters could tap certain sources of capital in these times such as special situations funds, but these are relatively costlier sources.
“While there are certain types of capital available in the market for promoters to tap into, most of it is high-cost capital. Private equity investors such as ‘special situation funds’ will see a lot of opportunities to deploy capital in the next few months," he said.
However, for overleveraged promoters, the road to raising fresh capital to tide over the current problems is not going to be easy. Promoters who want to raise fresh capital will likely face difficulty given the sharp volatility in stock prices, said Ajay Garg, founder and managing director at Equirus Capital. “If there is a gradual correction in stock price over a period of time, then the promoter has the time to manage his liquidity and to arrange for additional collateral. But in the current market where the stocks are moving 8-10% daily, finding enough time to raise fresh collateral will be a challenge for some promoters," he said, adding that promoters who are sitting on a comfortable amount of liquidity are also using this as an opportunity to buy their own company’s stock.