Hindenburg Research shutting down: ’Won’t be missed; dismissed,’ says market expert Ajay Bagga, lists 5 possible reasons
Ajay Bagga analysed Hindenburg Research's shutdown, citing their negative report strategies and the unsustainable nature of short selling. He speculated on regulatory pressures possibly prompting their closure, emphasizing the detrimental impact of their actions on companies and investors.
Hindenburg news: Ajay Bagga, a prominent stock market expert, shared his thoughts on the social media platform X on Thursday about possible reasons behind Hindenburg Research shutting down. Investors in the Indian stock market will remember Hindenburg for releasing a damaging report on the Adani Group in 2023 that wiped off nearly $100 billion in value from group shares, causing widespread damage to shareholders. Hindenburg had accused Adani of being involved in a "brazen stock manipulation and accounting fraud scheme," which sparked a significant reaction in the market.
Hindenburg Research, founded in 2017, became known for causing massive stock price falls by exposing fraud and financial problems in the companies it investigated. The firm used a method called short-selling to profit when the stock prices of these companies fell after its reports.
On Wednesday, Nate Anderson announced that he was disbanding the organisation after it finished the pipeline of work it set out to do. Speculating on possible reasons behind the shutting down of Hindenburg Research, Bagga shared five possible reasons behind the action:
Possible Reasons Behind Hindenburg Closure
1. Operating in a Grey Zone: Bagga said Hindenburg's strategy involved publishing negative reports and taking short positions, sometimes through hedge funds that were not disclosing their positions. This way, he said, the short-seller operated in a grey zone, raising concerns about the usage of their methods.
2. Sustainability of Short Selling: Bagga points out that short selling rarely leads to sustained profits. "That is why the few who do, as for example in 2008, are celebrated so much. The rest make hardly any returns over the long term," Bagga said, signalling a possible reason why Hindenburg Research decided to shut operations within eight years.
3. Likely Regulatory Action: Bagga speculated that there may have been regulatory action on Hindenburg, with the firm opting to quietly shut down to avoid penalties. He said he hoped they are prosecuted and not let off so easily in case some regulatory or legal action is ongoing against them.
4. Targeted Attacks on Companies: Hindenburg's strategy hinges on targeting companies and promoters with scathing reports, with the aim to profit from the resulting market chaos. This, Bagga argues, has had long-term damaging effects on companies, markets, and investors alike.
5. Profit Motive, Not Altruism: Bagga asserted that Hindenburg's operations were far from the noble quest for truth. He said that it was no altruistic, "truth-seeking" endeavour but a model to benefit from issuing scathing reports on companies and benefitting from taking a short position on them ahead of the release of these reports.
Ultimately, Bagga concludes that Hindenburg will not be missed and hinted that its dismissal from the market could be a positive step.
Disclaimer: The views and recommendations above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, not Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Catch all the Business News , Market News , Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
- Top Gainers
- Top Losers
- 52 Week High