Subscribe
Wall Street Journal at flat 1500 offSubscribe@3499

RBI 1, ESMA 0: India protects domestic clearing house from EU interference

Shayan Ghosh, Subhana Shaikh
3 min read24 Feb 2026, 05:30 AM IST
In May 2023, Esma withdrew recognition of six Indian clearing houses, including CCIL, a move which threatened to raise costs for European banks using them for their trades.
In May 2023, Esma withdrew recognition of six Indian clearing houses, including CCIL, a move which threatened to raise costs for European banks using them for their trades.(Bloomberg)
Summary

Esma has dropped its demand to supervise Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), two people familiar with the development said.

In the regulatory tussle over supervision of India's clearing houses, the European Union blinked first.

In the regulatory tussle over supervision of India's clearing houses, the European Union blinked first.

Ending a three-year standoff over supervision of the Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (Esma) signed a memorandum of understanding on 27 January. While the two regulators did not release the details of the agreement signed alongside the conclusion of India-EU free trade talks, Esma has dropped its demand to supervise Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), two people familiar with the development said.

Ending a three-year standoff over supervision of the Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (Esma) signed a memorandum of understanding on 27 January. While the two regulators did not release the details of the agreement signed alongside the conclusion of India-EU free trade talks, Esma has dropped its demand to supervise Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), two people familiar with the development said.

In May 2023, Esma withdrew recognition of six Indian clearing houses, including CCIL, a move which threatened to raise costs for European banks using them for their trades. The dispute originated from differences between the RBI and Esma over granting supervisory access to Indian clearing houses.

“Esma has agreed not to interfere with the supervision process of CCIL and will rely on RBI’s expertise for that,” said the first person.

Hope for more?

While five other clearing houses remain unrecognized by Esma, there may be hope for them as well. Esma said on 27 January that it is in talks with other regulators who supervise them. While the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) supervises the Indian Clearing Corp. Ltd, NSE Clearing Ltd, and Multi Commodity Exchange Clearing Corp; Gift City regulator International Financial Services Centres Authority supervises NSE IFSC Clearing Corp. Ltd and India International Clearing Corp. Ltd.

Besides, the European regulator has also agreed to address the issue of CCIL being asked to apply for recognition. The person cited above said Esma has agreed to take up India’s concern on ‘extraterritoriality’ in the next edition of the European Market Infrastructure Regulation (Emir) .

“When that happens, the process of CCIL having to apply for recognition will not arise in the coming years. This will remove a key hurdle and allow CCIL to function without the overhang of being regulated by Esma,” the person added. This, the person said, will also ensure there is no interference in the functions of a regulator in one jurisdiction by one from another jurisdiction.

Following the 2008 financial crisis, the EU implemented the Emir in 2012 to enhance transparency and reduce risks in the over-the-counter derivatives market. Article 25 of EMIR requires central counterparties or clearing houses servicing European banks abroad to be approved by Esma.

Emails sent to RBI and CCIL remained unanswered, while a spokesperson for Esma declined to comment.

Cooperation

The RBI had said on 27 January that the agreement enables the two regulators to cooperate regarding central counterparties, in line with their respective laws and regulations. “The MoU establishes a framework for Esma to place reliance on RBI’s regulatory and supervisory activities while safeguarding the European Union’s financial stability,” it said.

The concessions are seen as a win for India’s central bank.

“This should be seen in the context of India’s growing heft in the global financial system,” said Soumyajit Niyogi, director at India Ratings and Research. Many global investors are now looking at India to diversify their investments, and the inclusion of India in the bond indices is a testimony to that, he said. “Be that as it may, given our current account deficit and the pressure on the rupee, investors will weigh their options when they place their bets.”

According to the second person, the regulator and the Indian government remained firm, ensuring that supervision remains within the country's jurisdiction. Whether these will be replicated across agreements with other Indian regulators remains to be seen.

Other regulators, Sebi and Ifsca are aiming to sign information-sharing agreements with Europe’s securities watchdog within the next 60 days. This step could allow five Indian clearing houses to seek re-recognition by the European Union, Mint reported on 30 January.

Meet the Author

Shayan Ghosh leads the BFSI coverage at Mint, reporting on traditional banks, shadow banks and the cRead more

entral bank. He has 14 years of experience in financial journalism. Based in Mint’s Mumbai bureau since 2018, he tracks interest rate movements and its impact on companies and the broader economy. His interests also include the distressed debt market, especially as India’s bankruptcy law attempts recoveries of billions' worth of toxic assets.

Read Less

Subhana is a journalist with over six years of experience covering India’s financial markets. She haRead more

s written extensively on money and equity markets, banking, and now tracks the Reserve Bank of India for Mint. Based in Mumbai, she enjoys exploring stories across the business spectrum, reading in her downtime, and spending time with her three cats.

Read Less
Catch all the Business News , Market News , Breaking News Events, JIO IPO Listing Today LIVE and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
HomeMarketsStock MarketsRBI 1, ESMA 0: India protects domestic clearing house from EU interference

RBI 1, ESMA 0: India protects domestic clearing house from EU interference

Shayan Ghosh, Subhana Shaikh
3 min read24 Feb 2026, 05:30 AM IST
In May 2023, Esma withdrew recognition of six Indian clearing houses, including CCIL, a move which threatened to raise costs for European banks using them for their trades.
In May 2023, Esma withdrew recognition of six Indian clearing houses, including CCIL, a move which threatened to raise costs for European banks using them for their trades.(Bloomberg)
Summary

Esma has dropped its demand to supervise Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), two people familiar with the development said.

In the regulatory tussle over supervision of India's clearing houses, the European Union blinked first.

In the regulatory tussle over supervision of India's clearing houses, the European Union blinked first.

Ending a three-year standoff over supervision of the Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (Esma) signed a memorandum of understanding on 27 January. While the two regulators did not release the details of the agreement signed alongside the conclusion of India-EU free trade talks, Esma has dropped its demand to supervise Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), two people familiar with the development said.

Ending a three-year standoff over supervision of the Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (Esma) signed a memorandum of understanding on 27 January. While the two regulators did not release the details of the agreement signed alongside the conclusion of India-EU free trade talks, Esma has dropped its demand to supervise Clearing Corp. of India Ltd (CCIL), two people familiar with the development said.

In May 2023, Esma withdrew recognition of six Indian clearing houses, including CCIL, a move which threatened to raise costs for European banks using them for their trades. The dispute originated from differences between the RBI and Esma over granting supervisory access to Indian clearing houses.

“Esma has agreed not to interfere with the supervision process of CCIL and will rely on RBI’s expertise for that,” said the first person.

Hope for more?

While five other clearing houses remain unrecognized by Esma, there may be hope for them as well. Esma said on 27 January that it is in talks with other regulators who supervise them. While the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) supervises the Indian Clearing Corp. Ltd, NSE Clearing Ltd, and Multi Commodity Exchange Clearing Corp; Gift City regulator International Financial Services Centres Authority supervises NSE IFSC Clearing Corp. Ltd and India International Clearing Corp. Ltd.

Besides, the European regulator has also agreed to address the issue of CCIL being asked to apply for recognition. The person cited above said Esma has agreed to take up India’s concern on ‘extraterritoriality’ in the next edition of the European Market Infrastructure Regulation (Emir) .

“When that happens, the process of CCIL having to apply for recognition will not arise in the coming years. This will remove a key hurdle and allow CCIL to function without the overhang of being regulated by Esma,” the person added. This, the person said, will also ensure there is no interference in the functions of a regulator in one jurisdiction by one from another jurisdiction.

Following the 2008 financial crisis, the EU implemented the Emir in 2012 to enhance transparency and reduce risks in the over-the-counter derivatives market. Article 25 of EMIR requires central counterparties or clearing houses servicing European banks abroad to be approved by Esma.

Emails sent to RBI and CCIL remained unanswered, while a spokesperson for Esma declined to comment.

Cooperation

The RBI had said on 27 January that the agreement enables the two regulators to cooperate regarding central counterparties, in line with their respective laws and regulations. “The MoU establishes a framework for Esma to place reliance on RBI’s regulatory and supervisory activities while safeguarding the European Union’s financial stability,” it said.

The concessions are seen as a win for India’s central bank.

“This should be seen in the context of India’s growing heft in the global financial system,” said Soumyajit Niyogi, director at India Ratings and Research. Many global investors are now looking at India to diversify their investments, and the inclusion of India in the bond indices is a testimony to that, he said. “Be that as it may, given our current account deficit and the pressure on the rupee, investors will weigh their options when they place their bets.”

According to the second person, the regulator and the Indian government remained firm, ensuring that supervision remains within the country's jurisdiction. Whether these will be replicated across agreements with other Indian regulators remains to be seen.

Other regulators, Sebi and Ifsca are aiming to sign information-sharing agreements with Europe’s securities watchdog within the next 60 days. This step could allow five Indian clearing houses to seek re-recognition by the European Union, Mint reported on 30 January.

Meet the Author

Shayan Ghosh leads the BFSI coverage at Mint, reporting on traditional banks, shadow banks and the cRead more

entral bank. He has 14 years of experience in financial journalism. Based in Mint’s Mumbai bureau since 2018, he tracks interest rate movements and its impact on companies and the broader economy. His interests also include the distressed debt market, especially as India’s bankruptcy law attempts recoveries of billions' worth of toxic assets.

Read Less

Subhana is a journalist with over six years of experience covering India’s financial markets. She haRead more

s written extensively on money and equity markets, banking, and now tracks the Reserve Bank of India for Mint. Based in Mumbai, she enjoys exploring stories across the business spectrum, reading in her downtime, and spending time with her three cats.

Read Less
Catch all the Business News , Market News , Breaking News Events, JIO IPO Listing Today LIVE and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
HomeMarketsStock MarketsRBI 1, ESMA 0: India protects domestic clearing house from EU interference
OPEN IN APP
HomeMarketsPremiumInstant LoanMint Shorts