₹50 lakh income-tax case: ITAT quashes reassessment after tax department issued notice beyond the legal deadline

A Surat ITAT ruling has quashed reassessment proceedings involving a ₹50 lakh IDS disclosure after finding the tax department’s section 148 notice was time-barred. The case also involved a bank error that delayed part of the taxpayer’s tax payment.

Kirti Jha
Published8 Oct 2026, 12:39 PM IST
The Surat bench, comprising Judicial Member Suchitra Kamble and Accountant Member B.M. Biyani, held that the section 148 notice was time-barred. (AI-generated image used for representational purpose.)
The Surat bench, comprising Judicial Member Suchitra Kamble and Accountant Member B.M. Biyani, held that the section 148 notice was time-barred. (AI-generated image used for representational purpose.)

A taxpayer who had declared ₹50 lakh under the Income Declaration Scheme (IDS), 2016, but could not complete the process after a bank-related payment issue, has received relief from the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). In Harshali Lavishkumar Jain v. ITO, Ward-1(2)(1), Surat (ITA No. 1463/SRT/2025), the Surat bench quashed the reassessment after finding that the tax department's fresh notice under section 148 was issued beyond the permissible time limit.

The case relates to the assessment year 2017-18. Jain had filed her return declaring income of ₹6.88 lakh. The tax department later received information that she had declared ₹50 lakh under IDS 2016 for assessment year 2012-13 but had not completed the declaration process by submitting Form-4, the certificate of final acceptance. The department subsequently reopened her assessment and eventually added the entire ₹50 lakh as unexplained income.

Why the ₹50 lakh was added

Under IDS 2016, Jain had declared ₹50 lakh and claimed that she had paid the required tax of ₹22.50 lakh. However, she said a payment of ₹5.625 lakh could not be credited to the government's account before the deadline because of a technical error at the bank's end.

According to her submissions before the tribunal, the bank issued a certificate acknowledging the error. She argued that the assessing officer had also accepted that the full ₹22.50 lakh tax had ultimately been paid, but Form-4 could not be submitted because of the payment issue.

Also Read | Paid a large credit-card bill in cash? ITAT clarifies tax rules

The assessing officer nevertheless treated the ₹50 lakh as unexplained income and added it under "income from other sources". The assessment was completed under section 147 read with sections 144 and 144B in May 2023. The taxpayer challenged the addition, but the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) dismissed her appeal.

ITAT focuses on the reassessment deadline

Before the ITAT, Jain also challenged the validity of the reassessment notice itself.

The original notice under section 148 had been issued on 30 June 2021, under the old reassessment regime. Following the Supreme Court's ruling in Union of India v. Ashish Agarwal, such notices were treated as notices under section 148A(b) under the new reassessment framework.

The Supreme Court subsequently clarified in Union of India v. Rajeev Bansal that tax authorities could use only the "surviving time" available under the applicable limitation provisions to complete the remaining reassessment proceedings. A fresh section 148 notice issued beyond that surviving period would be time-barred.

In Jain's case, the tax department supplied the relevant information and issued a section 148A(b) notice on 25 May 2022. Jain responded on 26 May. The ITAT found that, given the original notice was issued on the last day of the relevant period, the department had only a limited surviving period to issue the fresh section 148 notice.

However, the fresh notice under section 148 was issued on 29 June 2022. The tribunal held that this was beyond the permissible surviving period and therefore invalid.

ITAT quashes ₹50 lakh assessment

The Surat bench, comprising Judicial Member Suchitra Kamble and Accountant Member B.M. Biyani, held that the section 148 notice was time-barred. It consequently quashed the reassessment proceedings and the assessment order that had added ₹50 lakh to Jain's income. The appeal was allowed.

Importantly, the tribunal did not decide the underlying dispute about the IDS declaration or the bank's payment error on merits. Since the reassessment itself was found to be invalid on limitation grounds, the other grounds raised by the taxpayer became infructuous.

What taxpayers should know

The ruling does not mean that a bank-related payment problem automatically wipes out a tax liability. Nor does it establish that taxpayers can ignore Form-4 requirements under IDS.

The key takeaway is about reassessment notices and limitation periods. Taxpayers facing a reassessment should examine the dates of the original notice, subsequent notices, responses and the final section 148 notice. A reassessment initiated beyond the legally permitted period can be challenged even when the tax department has made an addition on the underlying income.

About the Author

Kirti Jha is a Senior Content Producer at Mint, where she writes on mutual funds, taxation, personal finance and macroeconomic developments. Her reporting focuses on helping readers understand complex financial developments through data-driven, research-backed stories that explain how policy changes, market trends and regulatory decisions affect investors and households. <br><br> Before joining Mint, Kirti worked at ET Money, where she specialised in mutual fund research and investment analysis. She tracked portfolio disclosures, fund manager strategies, sectoral allocation shifts and investment trends, distilling large datasets into investor-focused insights. Her work combined quantitative analysis with consumer-centric storytelling, enabling readers to better understand fund positioning, portfolio changes and long-term investment opportunities.<br><br> Kirti holds a Bachelor's degree in Economics from Indraprastha College for Women, University of Delhi, and a Master's in Finance from the Jindal School of Banking & Finance at O.P. Jindal Global University. Her academic training emphasised analytical thinking, quantitative research and financial decision-making, providing a strong foundation in understanding capital markets, financial systems and economic policy. With a combined experience in investment research and financial journalism, she is committed to producing accurate, accessible and insightful journalism that empowers readers to make well-informed financial decisions.

Get Latest real-time updates

Catch all the Instant Personal Loan, Business Loan, Business News, Money news, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

HomeMoneyPersonal Finance ₹50 lakh income-tax case: ITAT quashes reassessment after tax department issued notice beyond the legal deadline
More