Balancing technology and trust: The importance of human guidance in investing

Trust remains key in making investment decisions, which reinforces the balance between embracing innovation and human discretion into finance.
Trust remains key in making investment decisions, which reinforces the balance between embracing innovation and human discretion into finance.

Summary

  • This year is set to experience explosive growth in areas like AI-driven quantitative investing, cryptocurrency derivatives, and quantum data analytics.

We, as an economy, are on the cusp of a future powered by artificial intelligence (AI). This year is set to experience explosive growth in areas like AI-driven quantitative investing, cryptocurrency derivatives, and quantum data analytics. As we traverse new frontiers of investment opportunities unlocked by AI, it is crucial to maintain an equilibrium. Trust remains key in making investment decisions, which reinforces the balance between embracing innovation and human discretion into finance.

The acceleration of fintech

Global investment in financial technology took a serious hit, suffering a 5-year downturn in 2023, owing to the geopolitical conflicts around the globe, rising interest rates, and decreased valuations of fintech companies. What emerged as the saving grace was AI-driven investing which managed to hold momentum; holding mass investor interest. Algorithmic trading is now projected to account for over 60% of equity trades.

The grand success of the Unified Payments Interface (UPI) in India is a precursor to potential positive reception by the average Indian investor to AI-powered financial decision making. Not just the retail investor, but the institutional investment community is equally charmed by the prospect of AI-powered infrastructure. From analysing massive alternative data sets using satellite imagery to social media sentiment, and uncovering alpha-generating investment insights, the possibilities are seemingly endless. However, recent events like the 2023 AI bubble demonstrate the dangers of blindly following opaque algorithms without proper human oversight.

Also read: How to view all your MF holdings in one place?

 

The indispensable role of human expertise

While the benefits of advanced technologies are undeniable, there are inherent limitations of sole reliance on data-driven models. The 2024 launch of Ethereum 2.0 and explosion of DeFi (decentralized finance) products illustrates how rapidly evolving crypto markets can defy historical patterns. With the nature of the financial sector being inherently complex, human expertise becomes critical in evaluating new asset classes amidst regulatory uncertainties.

Machine learning capabilities are only as good as the data fed to the system. It is the same reason why black swan events like the covid pandemic or geopolitical conflicts that even the most sophisticated AI systems can fail to appropriately respond to unforeseen shocks that profoundly impact markets. Seasoned investment professionals leverage experience, intuition and multi-disciplinary knowledge to navigate such disruptions.

The cornerstone of any investment decision is trust. Considering that the adaptability of data-driven software evolves continually to a dynamic market landscape, human intervention becomes increasingly vital. According to a 2024 Edelman survey, developing nations helm the list of AI-based decision making, with India ranking 78th on the list. While the global average suggests that only 18% of investors fully trust AI investment advice over human guidance. It is clear that the shift towards AI is rapid and evolving. However, investments do not pertain to a single metric or formulae. Several qualitative factors that are non-quantifiable are taken into account while devising an effective investment strategy. The importance of personalized advice tailored to individual circumstances remains unchanged.

Human-AI collaboration

Balance remains key in an evolving financial landscape such as this. The path forward lies in harnessing a best-of-both-worlds approach. The harmony between human expertise and machine learning capabilities must be leveraged for superior returns. The transition nonetheless has to be gradual. With AI-integration still at the nascent juncture, the economic feasibility of replacing humans is still debatable. Overtime, the integration can be scaled for sustained returns. The immediate approach to kick-start the transition would be skill-development of the existing workforce.

Leading investment firms are now training professionals on cutting-edge technologies like quantum computing and block chain analytics, while leveraging AI assistants for data processing and routine tasks.

At its core, this collaborative framework recognizes that while technologies like machine learning can enhance decision support capabilities, human investment experts must remain the unreplaceable captains at the helm. They provide critical forward-looking insights based on experience, validate algorithmic recommendations, and most importantly, cultivate trust through rapport-based client relationships.

Also read: How a recent RBI proposal on KYC has got payment aggregators on the backfoot

 

Balancing for sustainable success

The industry must now thoughtfully navigate the delicate balance between innovation and trusted human guidance. AI, quantum analytics, DeFi and other breakthroughs will continue to challenge traditional investing paradigms. The foundation stone of a synergized approach can be laid down if policymakers and regulatory bodies of the economy display flexibility towards technological integration. While unanimous acceptance still remains conflicted and execution not without roadblocks, apex bodies cannot remain oblivious to the advent of a new-era of financial investment and portfolio-building.

Consequently, firms that stake their future on complete automation at the expense of human capital will struggle, inevitably. Sustained progress will only be achieved through harmonizing the dual capabilities. Professionals must look to integrate skill sets of critically leveraging technologies to enhance their core responsibilities. The industry can elevate personalization, innovation and excellence.

Anchored in the weight of human expertise, and accelerated by technological prowess, the investment landscape can flourish through dynamic equilibrium - balancing the scales of cutting-edge quantitative capabilities and unparalleled human discernment to inspire enduring trust and profitability.

Arun Poddar is CEO, Choice International Ltd

Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
more

MINT SPECIALS