Active Stocks
Thu Mar 28 2024 15:59:33
  1. Tata Steel share price
  2. 155.90 2.00%
  1. ICICI Bank share price
  2. 1,095.75 1.08%
  1. HDFC Bank share price
  2. 1,448.20 0.52%
  1. ITC share price
  2. 428.55 0.13%
  1. Power Grid Corporation Of India share price
  2. 277.05 2.21%
Business News/ Money / Personal Finance/  Opinion | Should you invest in NCDs in current market conditions?
BackBack

Opinion | Should you invest in NCDs in current market conditions?

NCDs, whose tenure ranges from 2-10 years, offer substantially higher interest rates than bank FDs but carry higher risk of default
  • Neil Borate asks four experts whether or not it makes sense to invest in NCDs in the current environment
  •  (iStock)Premium
    (iStock)

    Non-convertible debentures (NCDs) are offering interest rates as high as 11% even as the debt markets are spooked given the crisis being faced by corporate groups, including IL&FS, ADAG Group, Essel Group and DHFL. Recent NCD issues include one by Muthoot Finance giving 10%, and by Indiabulls Consumer Finance offering 11%. NCDs, whose tenure ranges from 2-10 years, offer substantially higher interest rates than bank FDs but carry higher risk of default. Neil Borate asks four experts whether or not it makes sense to invest in NCDs in the current environment

    Don’t let high interest rates sway you, look at the risks

    Mrin Agarwal, Finsafe India Pvt. Ltd
    View Full Image
    Mrin Agarwal, Finsafe India Pvt. Ltd

    Mrin Agarwal, Financial Educator and Director, Finsafe India Pvt. Ltd.

    As such, investment into NCDs is not recommended due to the risks associated with it. The biggest risk in an NCD is that of default i.e credit risk. In the current market, with NBFCs going through a liquidity crisis and higher rated papers also defaulting, it’s better to stay away from NCDs.

    NCDs are also not liquid and it is not easy to exit before maturity as there may not be enough buyers.

    The bigger risk in NCDs is the concentration risk an investor faces in his/her portfolio. With NCDs, the investor exposes the portfolio to a single company, thus jeopardizing the capital at unfavourable times.

    In addition, NCDs are not tax efficient instruments and investors are better off investing in debt mutual funds which provide better diversification, liquidity and the benefit of professional fund management.

    Investors must not be swayed by the high interest rates that NCDs offer and must keep in mind the risks associated with these. The negatives associated with NCDs far outweigh the positives.

    Current debt market scenario not healthy for investments

    Shyam Sekhar, iThought Financial Consulting LLP
    View Full Image
    Shyam Sekhar, iThought Financial Consulting LLP

    Shyam Sekhar, Chief ideator and Founder, iThought Financial Consulting LLP.

    The current market scenario in debt markets is hardly healthy. Serious concerns persist about investment decision drivers like ratings, ability of firms to refinance debt with mutual funds and the liquidity of debt instruments in the secondary markets. This is reflected in the higher yields prevailing in recent NCDs.

    Investors are better off sitting out this trade as what we see is surely not reassuring. If mutual funds have not been able to ensure timely return of capital of unit holders by borrowers, a retail investor has to be realistic about his own bandwidth to manage such situations.

    There are strong reasons to be doubly concerned and careful. The distress in capital raising is not going away anytime soon. Retail NCDs which normally are seen as costly instruments will essentially be a last resort of capital hungry businesses. It would be prudent to stay away from risks of retail debt investing that NCDs present.

    The markets need more regulatory reassurance and rebuilding of credibility in ratings.

    Invest in NCDs as part of overall asset allocation, but check rating

    Vinit Iyer, Wealth Creators Financial Advisors
    View Full Image
    Vinit Iyer, Wealth Creators Financial Advisors

    Vinit Iyer, Co-founder, Wealth Creators Financial Advisors

    One should look to invest up to 25-30% of investible surplus meant for fixed income investment in NCDs, under overall asset allocation.

    Preferably, such NCDs should be secured by a collateral to reduce the risk significantly in case of a complete default. One can also look at the credit rating of at least two rating agencies to ascertain the risk involved. Most companies get ratings through agencies like Crisil or Care or Icra.

    Interestingly, in times like now, even good quality NCDs offer higher risk-adjusted returns owing to low investor sentiment and high credit crunch. Most investors benefit from such situations which demands a higher compensation in terms of higher yields.

    Also, assess the issuing company’s financial health and the reason why it’s raising money through NCDs. Short- to medium-term borrowing through NCDs by companies has comparatively lower risk of defaults, as per historical data.

    Overall, it’s worth it to ride the higher yield curve by having a certain allocation to NCDs.

    Debt funds make more sense for retail investors

    Deepali Sen, Srujan Financial Advisors LLP
    View Full Image
    Deepali Sen, Srujan Financial Advisors LLP

    Deepali Sen, Founder Partner, Srujan Financial Advisors LLP

    NCDs have higher yields than FDs but one should note the credit risks attached with NCDs. These risks can largely be judged by checking the credit rating but ratings can change. For instance, IL&FS was downgraded to D rating, from the highest credit rating of AAA in less than two months.

    Mutual funds offer a second layer of gate-keeping by assessing the quality of papers independent to credit rating. For clients needing to invest in fixed income for medium-term goals, MFs make sense for many reasons. First, debt funds in several categories would have assets spread across at least 40 securities or papers, reducing risk. Second, if the client holds a fixed-income fund for more than three years, the applicable long-term capital gains is 20% after indexation, minimizing tax liability. Third, investments can be pulled out in full or part anytime, subject to interest rate, liquidity and credit risks. Fourth, side-pocketing (which is yet to take off) can separate risky assets. Fifth, mutual funds are able to mirror market returns as they are marked to market

    Unlock a world of Benefits! From insightful newsletters to real-time stock tracking, breaking news and a personalized newsfeed – it's all here, just a click away! Login Now!

    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Neil Borate
    Neil heads the personal finance team at Mint. A former colleague called them 'money nerds' and that's what they are. They cover topics like mutual funds, taxation and retirement, all to improve your chances of building wealth. Neil graduated with a degree in law and economics. He passed the CFA Level I exam and began his writing career at Value Research, a mutual fund research firm in 2016. He joined the personal finance team Mint in 2019. Everyday, the Mint Money Team tackles personal finance questions such as where to invest and where to borrow, through articles, charts and reader queries. They also have a daily podcast - 'Why Not Mint Money' and an annual ranking of mutual funds - the Mint 20.
    Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
    More Less
    Published: 25 Feb 2019, 08:45 AM IST
    Next Story footLogo
    Recommended For You
    Switch to the Mint app for fast and personalized news - Get App