The retail bond inversion: Why small savers are taking risks institutions reject

Shachindra Nath
4 min read28 Sep 2026, 04:12 PM IST
logo
Nearly 66% of 208 bonds across five large platforms are rated A+ or below, exposing small investors to significant credit risk.
Summary
While institutional money sticks to AAA paper, retail investors are being funnelled into lower-rated debt. Nobody engineered this, but it needs fixing.

A salaried saver in Pune scrolls through a bond app. His fixed deposit renews at 6.9%. On screen is a debenture from a finance company he has never heard of: 13.5%, rated BBB, minimum ₹10,000. The rating sounds respectable enough. He buys.

He has staked his savings on one company surviving three years. He cannot read its loan book or judge whether it can refinance its own borrowings. If the company stops paying, he joins the queue behind the banks.

His position is not unusual. Across 208 bonds on five of the larger platforms, only 3% is AAA-rated and nearly 66% is A+ or below. And note the entry price: 68% of BBB bonds can be bought for ₹10,000 or less, against 17% of AAA. The weaker the borrower, the smaller the cheque it accepts.

The credit inversion

Consider who sits on each side of that trade. Banks, mutual funds and insurance companies employ credit teams and negotiate covenants, and they have largely decided not to lend to this rating band at all. Their own rules keep them in AAA and AA. So credit that India's most sophisticated investors have declined is reaching a saver with none of their tools. Nobody engineered this: smaller issuers need retail money and so issue in small denominations. But the result is an inversion. Those best equipped to price this risk are not taking it. Those least equipped are.

Most of these bonds will pay on schedule. The danger is what a few failures do to a young market. Households stayed out of equities for decades after being burnt by individual stocks, and came back only through mutual funds, where no one company could ruin them. Retail entered the bond market barely three years ago. A cluster of defaults now would empty it.

Also Read | Your risk profile is not what you tick. It is what you did when markets fell

A safer alternative

There is a safer instrument that exists today: the pass-through certificate. A finance company has already made 10,000 small loans: to a kirana store in Surat, a truck owner in Ludhiana, a workshop in Coimbatore. It puts them in a separate trust, which issues certificates. Each month, as those borrowers pay their EMIs, the money passes through to whoever holds them.

Three things make this safer than lending to one company. You are backing thousands of borrowers, so it takes a catastrophe for the pool to stop paying. There is a cushion: ₹110 to ₹125 of loans and cash may sit behind every ₹100 you invest, and losses eat that first. And the trust is separate from the company, so if it collapses, its lenders cannot touch the pool.

A pool is also sliced. The top slice is paid first and takes losses last, and it is the top slice a small investor would own. Is that safe in practice? Crisil has rated these pools for 33 years, and losses in the top slice have been very rare. The few failures at the highest grades are telling. One happened because a trustee was late passing on a payment, another because cash got stuck inside a lender that had collapsed. Even then, the borrowers were paying and the cushion was intact.

The other side reads differently. Since 2018, IL&FS, DHFL, Altico, Reliance Capital and Srei have all defaulted on debentures. DHFL's depositors and small debenture holders got back about 23 paise on the rupee nearly two years later. Many had chosen it for its rating, as our saver did.

The regulatory barrier

So why can he not buy one? Because the smallest amount you are allowed to put into a pool is ₹1 crore. The RBI set that floor and Sebi matched it.

There is one way round it today. A large investor buys the full ₹1 crore worth and later sells smaller pieces. That is legal, and it is how the few Indians who hold these certificates got them. But it has stayed tiny: about ₹170 crore from 1,900 investors, against ₹26,000 crore of ordinary bonds sold on the same platforms last year.

Also Read | Personalization of benefits is no longer an HR perk, it's leadership imperative

Even that is about to shut. On 27 July the RBI proposed that the ₹1 crore floor apply to every resale too, from 1 October. The reason given is that these pools are complicated. That is a disclosure problem. Anyone trusted to pick between a dozen debt mutual funds can handle a one-page factsheet.

There is a better answer than a flat ₹1 crore. Allow people to invest from ₹10,000, but only in pools that meet strict conditions. Rated A or better. Listed. The top slice only. Built from ordinary loans made by RBI-regulated lenders and spread across a large number of borrowers. The lending company's own money is still in the pool. And a monthly report showing how those borrowers are repaying. Everything else stays where it is.

There is no rating floor at all on the bond our saver bought. We are asking that the safer instrument be held to the stricter standard. He will take credit risk with his savings either way. He should be allowed the safer version of it.

The author is founder, vice chairman and managing director of UGRO Capital Limited.

Also Read | Kotak CEO hopeful Kashyap sees larger role for bond markets

Catch all the Instant Personal Loan, Business Loan, Business News, Money news, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

More