8 min read.Updated: 11 Mar 2021, 09:59 PM ISTPaul Wallace,Mark Burton,Agnieszka de Sousa,Debjit Chakraborty, Bloomberg
Oil and food prices are up, and copper is trading at levels seen a decade ago. Who are the winners and losers?
In India, home to the most arable land after the United States, oil prices do pinch but a spike in agricultural commodity prices could benefit. But it is a mixed bag given poverty levels.
You’d think a world tiptoeing its way out of the pandemic might only be good news for governments and economies. Yet, the consequent surge in the price of energy, metals and crops is highlighting the strengths of some countries and the vulnerabilities of others.
Oil has climbed 75% since the start of November as major economies vaccinate their populations and reopen after the pandemic shut down factories and grounded planes. Copper—used in everything from cars to washing machines and wind turbines—is trading at levels last seen a decade ago. Food prices have jumped every month since May.
That’s been a boon for exporters. The flood of cash is a welcome relief for energy behemoths such as Saudi Arabia and Russia, whose leaderships have domestic challenges to contend with.
But there are always two sides to a trade. Some countries that depend on imports are feeling the squeeze in bond and currency markets. Rising fuel prices cost the head of Brazil’s state oil company his job. They’ve led India—the world’s third-largest crude importer—to call on the Opec+ cartel to raise oil production and pushed Turkey’s inflation rate above 15%.
Fuel prices have become a particularly contentious political issue in India. “Higher prices push up inflation and that is not good for the economy," Mukesh Kumar Surana, chairman of Hindustan Petroleum Corp. Ltd, told Bloomberg television. “It (also) pushes people to look for more alternative resources in the energy basket," he said, adding that India would prefer an oil price in the $50 to $60 a barrel range. But it’s looking increasingly unlikely that crude will drop back to those levels. Top banks upgraded their price forecasts recently, with Goldman Sachs Group Inc seeing Brent crude at $80 a barrel in the third quarter.
Meanwhile, Goldman and some of its Wall Street rivals are talking of a new commodities “supercycle"—an extended period during which demand drives prices well above their long-run trend. Sometimes, such rallies in the commodities market can last years.
For some analysts, the current rally is rekindling memories of the supercycle seen during China’s rise to economic heavyweight status in the early 2000s. From around 2002, China entered a phase of roaring economic growth, fuelled by a rollout of modern infrastructure and cities on an unprecedented scale. Suppliers struggled to fulfil surging demand for natural resources. In commodities, there’s often a time lag to get the product where it’s wanted since adding capacity, such as opening a new mine, doesn’t happen overnight. For more than a decade, materials including iron ore were in tight supply. Copper, priced below $2,000 a ton for much of the 1990s, broke $10,000 and oil jumped from $20 a barrel to $140.
Commodities have experienced three other comparable cycles since the start of the 20th century. US industrialization sparked the first in the early 1900s, global rearmament fuelled another in the 1930s and the reindustrialization and reconstruction of Europe and Japan following the Second World War drove a third during the 1950s and 1960s.
The prospect of such a supercycle is already raising the spectre of more damaging inflation down the line—and richer countries aren’t immune, either.
The UK government backtracked on raising gasoline tax so as not to rile lockdown-weary drivers. In the US, Texan oil drillers and corn belt farmers may be benefiting, though others, including tech billionaires, are being squeezed. Elon Musk has pleaded with miners to dig up more nickel, a metal he needs to make batteries for Tesla Inc.’s electric vehicles.
Last year’s lockdowns and commodity downturn stung Australia, which experienced its first recession in almost three decades. But the government can expect a windfall in 2021. Sales of iron ore, its top export, hit a record in December, while those of wheat are edging toward the same level and cattle farmers are struggling to keep up with demand for beef.
The Australian dollar has performed better than any other major currency since the end of November, strengthening 5% against the US dollar.
It isn’t all plain sailing though. A diplomatic spat has seen China bar Australian goods ranging from coal to copper, wine and lobsters. Still, iron ore has been spared because Beijing can’t source enough of the steel ingredient from elsewhere. That helped ensure the trade fight only cost Australia about $3 billion last year, a small amount for a nation that’s seen its shipments to China balloon from around $5 billion annually at the start of the century to $120 billion.
The relative strength of Chile, the world’s biggest copper producer, has also been evident. The peso is the only major Latin American currency to appreciate against the dollar over the past three months and Chile’s stock market has been among the world’s most buoyant.With prices of the red metal rising above $4 a pound for the first time in about a decade, Chile’s finances are improving. Copper exports stood at $3.9 billion in February, up 42% from the month before.
Similar can be said for Zambia, which relies on copper for almost 80% of its export earnings. The country has been desperate for money after it became the first in Africa to default on its Eurobonds following the onset of the pandemic.
President Edgar Lungu faces a re-election battle in August and is trying to get a bailout from the International Monetary Fund, restructure Chinese loans, and stem soaring food prices, which have caused inflation to accelerate to 22%.
The country bought the local operations of Glencore Plc in January at what’s looking more and more like a favourable price and global investors have started to become more bullish. Zambia’s dollar debt has rallied the most this year among the roughly 75 emerging markets tracked by Bloomberg Barclays indexes.
All petro states suffered last year, but Iraq stood out. Its economy sank around 11%, more than that of almost any other major oil exporter, according to the International Monetary Fund. The government couldn’t pay teachers and civil servants on time and Iraqis took to the streets to rail against power cuts, dilapidated hospitals, crumbling roads and a lack of jobs.
The situation caused problems for Opec, of which Iraq is the second-biggest oil producer. Other members, including Saudi Arabia, criticized Baghdad for failing to cut output enough as the cartel tried to bolster prices.
As the crude market picked up, Iraq’s monthly fiscal revenue climbed to $5 billion from about $3 billion in the second quarter of 2020. They’re still far below what’s needed to balance the state budget, but there’s clear respite.
While the winners of the ongoing rally will no doubt relish the turnaround, the countries who are net importers of commodities are already starting to make mitigation plans. China, for instance, may be a big producer of everything from oil and zinc to food, but it is also the most important buyer of commodities and was almost single-handedly responsible for the last “supercycle" that ended roughly a decade ago. The rapid recovery of the world’s second-biggest economy from covid-19 is one of the main reasons as to why energy, metals and agricultural goods are rising this time around.
The rally can only go so far, however, before President Xi Jinping and the Communist Party step in. The topic of food security and pork prices featured prominently during China’s annual parliamentary pageant—the National People’s Congress—this month. The government announced a five-year roadmap to boost crop and livestock production.
In the Middle East, Egypt, as the world’s biggest buyer of wheat and a net oil importer, suffers badly whenever commodity prices pick up. It’s also politically sensitive because millions of people depend on subsidized bread. The Arab Spring uprisings a decade ago were triggered in part by increasing food costs and swept long-standing ruler Hosni Mubarak out of power.
So far, President Abdel-Fattah El-Sisi’s government has managed to keep a lid on inflation. Egypt is trying to protect itself against higher oil costs by buying more hedging contracts in the market, and foreign investors are still purchasing local bonds. But gross domestic product will rebound just 2.9% this year, according to a Bloomberg survey of analysts—around half the level expected for the global economy.
Higher food and fuel prices have already triggered social unrest in Pakistan, with opposition parties holding nationwide rallies last year to call on Prime Minister Imran Khan to resign. His government responded by increasing salaries for state employees by 25% last month.
The pressure has scarcely eased, however, with Khan narrowing winning a vote of confidence in parliament this month. The economic impact of business shutdowns and social restrictions to curb the virus will only be exacerbated if commodities keep climbing and add to the import bill of Pakistan, which produces barely any oil or minerals of its own.
In India, home to the most arable land after the US, oil prices do pinch but a spike in agricultural commodity prices could benefit. But it is a mixed bag. While India is the world’s biggest exporter of rice and the second-largest producer of wheat, at the same time, millions of Indians cannot access affordable food and the country has some of highest rates of child malnutrition.
Food remains at the centre of political tensions that have been dominating India. Protests by farmers escalated over a move by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government to liberalize the market for crops. Growers are concerned that the new law will push down prices.
If big countries like Egypt, Pakistan and India are struggling with the ongoing commodities cycle, spare a thought for smaller places on the map. The Dominican Republic may be the largest economy in the Caribbean, but its GDP is barely greater than the state of New Hampshire in the US and rising fuel prices are hitting before the key tourism industry has had a chance to recover from the pandemic.
The nation of 11 million people is heavily dependent on imports. Apart from gasoline and diesel for vehicles, it has to ship in natural gas, coal and fuel oil for the bulk of its power generation.
It has responded to previous commodity price booms with food subsidies. That might be difficult this time given its stretched finances. The country’s dollar bonds have lost 9% this year, making it one of the worst-performing emerging markets.
“These price spikes are destabilizing, not just because they induce a lot of hardship on communities and households, but also because there is this expectation that the government will do something about it," said Cullen Hendrix, a non-resident senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, a Washington-based think tank. “The implications are going to last longer and beyond the pandemic."