Home / News / India /  Intermediaries can’t track users 24x7, Centre says in new IT rules

NEW DELHI : Intermediaries such as social media firms will not be allowed to track users all the time under the guise of enforcing the first originator rules, the government said on Monday and reiterated that traceability norms laid down in the Information Technology (IT) Rules, 2021, do not compromise end-to-end encryption.

The ministry of electronics and information technology (MeitY) issued the clarifications in a 28-page frequently asked questions (FAQs) document relating to the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, or IT Rules.

The document comprising five sections also contains clarifications on terminology, due diligence to be followed by intermediaries and significant social media intermediaries (SSMIs), and the grounds of non-compliance to the rules.

According to the document, the definition of intermediaries will remain as defined in the IT Act, 2000, which includes everything from telecom service providers to search engines, online payment websites and even cyber cafes. The document adds that many other online platforms “may qualify as intermediaries with respect to the third-party content made available, shared, hosted, stored or transmitted on their platforms including websites and apps".

“Some entities may be functioning both like an intermediary as well as a ‘news aggregator’ or ‘publisher of news and current affairs content’ as defined in rule 2(o) and rule 2(t). Further clarification with respect to rule 5, and Part III of the Rules relating to news and current affairs content may be sought from the ministry of information and broadcasting," the document said.

“The whole document is focusing on the user perspective, which is very good," said N.S. Nappinai, Supreme Court lawyer and a cyberlaw expert. For instance, the clarification issued with respect to tracking the first originator of a message or post could be good for users.

“The clarification given for the first originator rules shows that you don’t really need that rule at all. It was already part of the law," Nappinai said. “The clarifications set out very clearly that only as and when directions under Section 69 of the IT Act are given, can they trace the user, which allays surveillance fears."

She added, though, that these clarifications may not suffice. For instance, Nappinai believes FAQs could have categorically defined the categories of intermediaries that are required to appoint grievance officers. She added that the document should have included examples of websites, or perhaps categories of apps and websites that will need to appoint these officers, as that would have further helped users to seek redress.

“The clarifications interestingly talk about stakeholder consultations without specifying where there was a consultation for the specific rules. It also selectively arbitrates the ratio decidendi (a legal term for ‘the reason’) of those judgments of the SC that support its promulgation, but ignores the key principles surrounding the grant of safe harbour protections to intermediaries," said Akash Karmakar, a partner at the Law Offices of Panag & Babu.

The government has also reiterated its stance that the traceability norms laid down in the new rules do not break end-to-end encryption—a technology used to make text messages, calls and other communications indecipherable to anyone other than its sender and receiver. Messaging major WhatsApp has sued the government on this rule and argued that it cannot find the first originator of a message without breaking encryption.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Prasid Banerjee

An engineering dropout, Prasid Banerjee has reported on technology in India for various publications. He reports on technology through text and audio, focusing on its core aspects, like consumer impact, policy and the future.
Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
More Less

Recommended For You

Trending Stocks

×
Get alerts on WhatsApp
Set Preferences My ReadsWatchlistFeedbackRedeem a Gift CardLogout