Govt claims growth potential unchanged as Moody’s says slump structural
Moody’s said India’s potential economic growth remains constrained unless reforms are advanced
New Delhi: A day after Prime Minister Narendra Modi claimed that the fundamentals of the economy remain strong, rating agency Moody’s Investor Service on Friday changed its outlook for India’s sovereign rating (Baa2) from stable to negative, saying that the domestic economic downturn could be structural.
The agency’s action does not amount to a rating downgrade, but comes as a caution against policy inaction. Moody’s credit rating of Baa2, the second-lowest investment grade score, is better than those of other agencies, such as S&P and Fitch, who have assigned the lowest investment grade to India with a stable outlook.
Countering Moody’s views, the Union finance ministry in a statement said that India’s potential growth rate remains unchanged, as evident from the assessment by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and other multilateral organizations that continue to hold a positive outlook on India.
“The government has undertaken a series of financial sector and other reforms to strengthen the economy as a whole. Government of India has also proactively taken policy decisions in response to the global slowdown. These measures would lead to a positive outlook on India and would attract capital flows and stimulate investments," the statement added.
India has often criticized the methodology followed by rating agencies. A finance ministry official, requesting anonymity, said while Moody’s had upgraded India’s upward growth cycle in 2017, the change in outlook within two years seems to be a knee-jerk reaction. “In the next two years, India should be back on trend growth," he added.
Moody’s said India’s potential gross domestic product (GDP) growth and job creation will remain constrained unless reforms are advanced to directly reduce restrictions on the productivity of labour and land, stimulate private sector investment, and sustainably strengthen the financial sector.
“The prospects of further reforms that would support business investment and growth at high levels, and significantly broaden the narrow tax base, have diminished," it added.
Moody’s said while government measures to support the economy should help reduce the depth and duration of India’s growth slowdown, the prolonged financial stress among rural households, weak job creation and, more recently, a credit crunch among non-bank financial institutions, have increased the probability of a more entrenched slowdown.
“If nominal GDP growth does not return to high rates, Moody’s expects that the government will face very significant constraints in narrowing the general government budget deficit and preventing a rise in the debt burden," it said.
Speaking at the Global Investors’ Meet in Dharamshala on Thursday, Modi said that in today’s global scenario, if India has stood firmly, it is because it has not allowed the fundamentals of the economy to be weakened.
“We have constantly maintained our commitment on macro-economy and have abided by fiscal discipline. Today, when global economic activity has come down to 3%, India is growing at more than 5%. Recent reports suggest that in coming months, India will grow at a faster pace. Our intention is genuine, as well as sensitive. There is firmness in our decisions and intentions," Modi said.
India’s economy had decelerated to a six-year low to 5% in the June quarter, forcing most international and domestic forecasters to cut their GDP projections close to, or below, 6% for 2019-20. The Centre has undertaken a series of reforms, including cutting corporate tax rates, to spur an investment-led growth. However, it has so far desisted from announcing a large fiscal stimulus package to boost slowing consumption, which was at an 18-quarter low in June. On Wednesday, the cabinet cleared a ₹25,000 crore package to revive stalled housing projects to boost the ailing real estate sector.
The rating agency said although these measures, including policy rate cuts by the Reserve Bank of India, will provide support to the economy, they are unlikely to restore productivity and real GDP growth to previous rates.
Moody’s said its Baa2 rating balances the country’s credit strengths, including its large and diverse economy and stable domestic financing base for government debt, against its principal challenges, such as high government debt, weak social and physical infrastructure, and fragile financial sector.
The rating agency said the drivers of the economic deceleration were many and primarily domestic. “In the context of a prolonged period of weak investment, private consumption has slowed, driven by financial stress among rural households and weak job creation," it added.