6 min read.Updated: 01 Jun 2021, 01:52 AM ISTKEITH ZHAI, The Wall Street Journal
Beijing says married couples may have three children, up from two, after a recent census showed a rise in the percentage of Chinese aged 60 and above
China said Monday that it would allow all married couples to have as many as three children and provide government support for education and child rearing, a move that comes as Beijing struggles to reverse a worsening demographic situation that presents a host of social and economic challenges.
The shift comes more than five years after Beijing ended its decadeslong “one-child policy" to let all couples have two children, and follows the May 11 release of census figures showing China’s population on the cusp of a historic turning point after years of rapid growth.
The announcement came after a Monday meeting of the Politburo, the Chinese Communist Party’s top decision-making body, chaired by leader Xi Jinping—a signal of concern over the demographic situation at the country’s highest levels. State-run Xinhua News Agency said the change would “improve the country’s population structure, actively implement the national strategy to respond to the aging population, and maintain the country’s demographic advantage."
Traditionally, such decisions have come out of broader Communist Party policy conferences. Some demographers had expected a loosening or even a lifting of birth policies at the end of the year at a roughly annual gathering of the top few hundred party officials.
“It’s unprecedented," said Yi Fuxian, a U.S.-based researcher and longtime critic of China’s population policies. “It signals how concerned Xi Jinping is."
Mr. Yi said that by itself, the move won’t change the broader trends. More than merely lifting the cap on the number of children that families can have, though, Monday’s announcement sets the stage for a host of potentially sweeping changes on healthcare, retirement, pensions and social welfare.
Under the new policy, the government said it would offer more equitable educational resources and reduce educational expenditures for families—policies aimed at removing obstacles widely seen by experts as holding back couples from having more children.
The question now is whether the Chinese government’s relaxing of birth restrictions will make a difference in persuading more of the country’s couples to have more babies.
In 2013, the government allowed couples to have two children when one of the parents was an only child, and in 2015, Beijing said it would allow all couples to have up to two children.
About half of Chinese couples are willing to have two children, according to a 2017 study by the state-backed All-China Women’s Federation.
The once-in-a-decade census showed 12 million babies born in China last year, the fourth straight year in which births fell, despite the relaxed restrictions. In 2016, there were 17.86 million births.
The census also showed a sharp rise in the percentage of Chinese aged 60 and above, to 18.7% of the population as of the end of 2020, up from 13.3% in 2010. The portion of Chinese citizens aged between 15 and 59, representing the size of its working population, stood at 63.35% in 2020, down from 70.1% in 2010.
“Evidence in other countries suggests that, once [the] birthrate is on a downward trend, it is difficult to…reverse it," said Zhang Zhiwei, chief economist at Pinpoint Asset Management.
In Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore, South Korea and Japan, years of government efforts to reverse falling birthrates have largely failed. But the scale of China’s challenge is on a different order.
For more than three decades, China relied on young workers to fuel its economic growth and build up the world’s second-largest economy. Now, the impact of the one-child policy—imposed by Beijing in 1980—is becoming apparent, having effectively prevented the births of millions of workers and women of childbearing age, as the number of senior citizens is climbing.
As in many countries, the challenge China faces is in motivating parents like Xing Zhiwei, a 38-year-old Beijing father of two, to have another child.
“The policy is changed but it doesn’t mean we can afford to have another one," said Mr. Xing, who says the cost of raising two children has already deterred him and his wife.
“It takes a lot of money and energy to take care of a child," said Mr. Xing, who recently splurged to buy a small two-bedroom apartment near one of the top schools in the capital.
Mr. Xing is far from exceptional, particularly for Chinese living in big cities, says Mu Guangzong, a professor at Peking University’s Institute of Population Research in Beijing. Educated women, in particular, are postponing childbirth as they pursue careers, Mr. Mu said.
While Mr. Mu praised the government’s acknowledgment of issues including the cost of education, he said the financial commitment unveiled on Monday remained vague.
“The government is approaching this with steady, careful reform. But the fertility rate now is too low and it requires a complete relaxation," said Mr. Mu. “The government also needs to spend real money to deal with the rising cost of child-rearing."
As in the cities, the impact of the new policy is likely to be limited in the countryside. Many families already have two or more children because of China’s less restrictive birth policy in rural areas, said Wang Han, a 25-year-old woman from a rural county in the central Chinese province of Henan.
“My preference to have two children is based on the assessment of my economic circumstances and abilities," Ms. Wang said. However, she saw it as a positive that the government now will allow three children. “If a third baby were to happen, then I wouldn’t have to worry anymore."
China’s family-planning commission has historically had wide latitude to manage people’s private lives, including the power to fine couples who violated the one-child policy and sometimes to force women to have abortions.
In conjunction with its lifting of birth restrictions, the Politburo also said Monday that it would gradually raise the national retirement age and increase investment in its senior population, without elaborating.
While the relaxation of birth restrictions has long been advocated by demographers, it will do little to relieve the shorter-term pressures on the country’s labor force, which is projected to decline precipitously over the next two decades.
For that reason, said Mr. Zhang, the economist, “we expect the government will initiate policy to delay retirement to address this issue."
In March, authorities said they would act sometime in the next five years to postpone the official retirement age, signaling their determination to follow through on a contentious and unpopular policy that many economists say is essential.
China now has one of the world’s lowest retirement ages—60 for most men and 50 for women—and is facing pressure to ease the growing demands on its pension and healthcare systems.
For several years, senior officials have been discussing ways to put China’s pension system on a more sustainable footing. Xu Zhong, a former director of China’s central bank, said in a February article that the country’s underfunded pension system’s reform has reached a “critical moment."
Any move to delay the retirement age could also discourage childbearing, since many of today’s prospective parents are themselves only children who rely on their retired parents to be primary caregivers for their grandchildren.
"It is hard to imagine what we will have to face if we have more children and our parents are not able to help us with the delayed retirement," said Wang Shuo, a 31-year-old lawyer in Shenzhen who married last year but has no children.
On China’s Twitter-like Weibo platform, the new birth policy was greeted with widespread derision.
“I’m not buying three Rolls-Royces not because there’s any restriction, but because they’re expensive," read one widely-shared post, comparing children with the British luxury auto brand.
“If two only children get married, then they will have to take care of four parents, three children and retire at 65," read another widely-shared post. “Donkeys have a better life than this."
This story has been published from a wire agency feed without modifications to the text.
Subscribe to Mint Newsletters
* Enter a valid email
* Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter.
Never miss a story! Stay connected and informed with Mint.
our App Now!!